Saturday, March 3rd 2007

SourceForge forced to remove BackupHDDVD from their website

A lot of *nix users know SourceForge as a great place to find (source code for) programs. A SourceForge member decided it would be a good idea to post a program called "BackupHDDVD". BackupHDDVD literally "backed up" HDDVD's, allowing for multiple copies to be stored and produced. SourceForge recently got a letter saying that any program that cracks copy protection like that is breaking a federal law, and so they decided to remove the program.Source: Nordic Hardware
Add your own comment

8 Comments on SourceForge forced to remove BackupHDDVD from their website

#1
Leon2ky
I wonder if it really is illegal or are they just making shit up. I don't recall it technically being illegal as long as you still have the original one.
Posted on Reply
#2
Thermopylae_480
I always thought you were allowed to have a personal back-up of software and movies, so long as you owned the original and did not distribute the film/program.
Posted on Reply
#3
Demon_82
At least in Spain we have in our laws that right of a personal back-up copy, but it's a right wich has been systematically ignored, overruled by anti-copy laws and that author associations sh¡t.
Posted on Reply
#4
Wile E
Power User
The problem is that the laws that protect us consumers, and the laws the protect the content providers, largely contradict themselves in most countries. There is currently no clear answer as to the legality of these issues. AKA: A GIANT gray area.
Posted on Reply
#5
Scavar
In technical terms its legal and illegal. There are laws in the United States supporting both. So its really just a gray warzone.
Posted on Reply
#6
Saurian
It's absolutely legal to backup a copy of whatever you purchase. However, it is absolutely illegal to break any sort of encryption algorithm applied to said product.

Basically you can buy the land and put a house on it, you just have no way to drive to and from it.
Posted on Reply
#7
WarEagleAU
Bird of Prey
They were just pissed because of the fact that someone broke their :unbreakable: drm system. Idiots. They should hire some of these crackers and pay them well to stop piracy.
Posted on Reply
#8
Bob The Fish
by: WarEagleAU
They were just pissed because of the fact that someone broke their :unbreakable: drm system. Idiots. They should hire some of these crackers and pay them well to stop piracy.
I agree, shame that some new hackers will just out hack them.
Posted on Reply