i wouldnt go that far, if it wasnt for the government abusing its powers the unions wouldnt of needed to react the way they did.
as for what she did being right, yea well my town still aint recovered 30 years on as we still have higher than average unemployment after the mines closed. they was the biggest employer in this area and nothing has been done to replace them.
modernisation would of been the right thing to do, instead now we have to pay top dollar to fuel the power stations we still have which use it instead of using coal mined in the uk. not to mention the other resources which they would of no doubt found by now. so we have to get over the barrel for the russians.
well done....
Forgive me for replying to a couple of people's comments but only quoting you (I'm lazy
). I continue to sympathise with those ex mining communities that are still suffering from the pain that was caused by mine closures, mainly because i don't care about institutions, government or politicians, I care about people, my comments earlier on the subject were playing Devil's Advocate...... not taking sides.
As for your comments specifically, and again playing Devil's Advocate, even if Thatcher had not taken this stance, this country would have no significant mining industry today, you may or may not be aware that at the time of the strikes, 60% of coal used by industry in this country was actually imported, mainly from Argentina, simply because to import it was cheaper than buying locally sourced coal because miners but more importantly their Unions did not want modernisation and resisted it for 20 years, because inevitably modernisation increases efficiency, lowers the workforce and thus reduces costs, they were the instigators of their own industry's downfall ultimately (Unions NOT miners). At the time of closure, coal was pretty much the most expensive form of fuel, add to that the increased Yeilds of natural gas from the North Sea AND the increasing majority of housholds moving from coal to Gas and it resulted in a pretty bleak outlook...... of course at the same time the industry was being subsidised with Billions of taxpayers money.
Also, without playing Devil's Advocate now, so a personal view, I struggle to support any strike (and I beleive in the Unions and the voice of working people) when a National ballot of members DOES NOT take place, the one year long strike never went to a national ballot, whole splinter groups of the NUM representing specific Regional area's were against the strike and they were Blackmailed and bullied to the point of threats on life to participate.
Lastly, as for standard of living in the UK for working class people.... I agree, to me it has gone downhill, part of this is due to the recession to be fair, just go ask someone from Greece, Portugal or Spain and they would probably say the same but I do agree much is "self induced", however how many workforces can boast (for want of a better word) of a minimum wage, a benefits and health system etc etc like ours? Is it broken....... yes probably, but possibly less broken than most others