Dude I think I just blew it. I was already at device manager, under advanced - it showed two line for my two cards - one of them working fine and the other with an exclamation mark.
I went to advanced for the second and it says this device is not working properly. I thought it would be a good idea to uninstall it and reinstall it. Apparently uninstall went ahead and uninstalled both cards. Now my resolution on my 22 inch is like 540x480 (kind of funny looking).
While I figure out the reinstall, yes there is a "Code 43" windows error message on one of the cards.