• Welcome to TechPowerUp Forums, Guest! Please check out our forum guidelines for info related to our community.

Revisiting The RV Park WiFi

Joined
Feb 11, 2013
Messages
40 (0.01/day)
About a year ago, I was helped out immensely by people here in updating a WiFi system for a local RV Park..

Here is the thread: http://www.techpowerup.com/forums/threads/wifi-hotspot-for-rv-park.180045/

Things went real smoothly for quite a few months, but now the system keeps collapsing. Not sure if it's from User overload or something else, but Management at the RV Park wants to update the system..

Since that last discussion back in 2013, the requirements have coalesced into being more specific.

What we need is an outdoor all-weather system such as this .....

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Extreme-Net...or-Access-Point-3550-5Yr-Warnty-/181294372320

.... but with a/b/g/n protocols.

We definitely need POE...

It needs to cover a lightly wooded area approx 400x400 feet http://sjfm.us/temp/RV012814.jpg

It needs to handle high load access such as streaming video for multiple (many) connections...

And it needs to come in under $5K-$8K...

And, while we're at it, lets see if we can bring peace to the Middle East and get that Mars Landing program done.. :D

Michale

NOTE: Cleared up time discrepancy. It wasn't 4 years ago, it was a year ago. My bust..
 
Last edited:
Joined
Dec 6, 2005
Messages
10,881 (1.63/day)
Location
Manchester, NH
System Name Senile
Processor I7-4790K@4.8 GHz 24/7
Motherboard MSI Z97-G45 Gaming
Cooling Be Quiet Pure Rock Air
Memory 16GB 4x4 G.Skill CAS9 2133 Sniper
Video Card(s) GIGABYTE Vega 64
Storage Samsung EVO 500GB / 8 Different WDs / QNAP TS-253 8GB NAS with 2x10Tb WD Blue
Display(s) 34" LG 34CB88-P 21:9 Curved UltraWide QHD (3440*1440) *FREE_SYNC*
Case Rosewill
Audio Device(s) Onboard + HD HDMI
Power Supply Corsair HX750
Mouse Logitech G5
Keyboard Corsair Strafe RGB & G610 Orion Red
Software Win 10
Are you looking for AC protocol as well? "A" is not used very much at all. Problem with AC is it's still emerging, so not nearly as many products on the market (yet). But it is far superior for bandwidth and range. More an more adaptors (and laptops and phones) you'll see will be both N and AC capable.

Google "Wireless AC Access point" and you won't find a lot of direct hits, but plenty of N units.

You can also build an outdoor enclosure if you want to go that route.
 
Joined
Feb 11, 2013
Messages
40 (0.01/day)
Are you looking for AC protocol as well? "A" is not used very much at all. Problem with AC is it's still emerging, so not nearly as many products on the market (yet). But it is far superior for bandwidth and range. More an more adaptors (and laptops and phones) you'll see will be both N and AC capable.

Google "Wireless AC Access point" and you won't find a lot of direct hits, but plenty of N units.

You can also build an outdoor enclosure if you want to go that route.

Yea, that's the way I went back in 2010...

http://sjfm.us/temp/rvwifiBox.jpg

And it works and I will likely go that way again with the expanded.

But having a weather proofed AP in place is a really nice way to go. :D

Thanx for the reply... I'll check out the AC units..
 
Joined
Dec 6, 2005
Messages
10,881 (1.63/day)
Location
Manchester, NH
System Name Senile
Processor I7-4790K@4.8 GHz 24/7
Motherboard MSI Z97-G45 Gaming
Cooling Be Quiet Pure Rock Air
Memory 16GB 4x4 G.Skill CAS9 2133 Sniper
Video Card(s) GIGABYTE Vega 64
Storage Samsung EVO 500GB / 8 Different WDs / QNAP TS-253 8GB NAS with 2x10Tb WD Blue
Display(s) 34" LG 34CB88-P 21:9 Curved UltraWide QHD (3440*1440) *FREE_SYNC*
Case Rosewill
Audio Device(s) Onboard + HD HDMI
Power Supply Corsair HX750
Mouse Logitech G5
Keyboard Corsair Strafe RGB & G610 Orion Red
Software Win 10
Yea, that's the way I went back in 2010...

http://sjfm.us/temp/rvwifiBox.jpg

And it works and I will likely go that way again with the expanded.

But having a weather proofed AP in place is a really nice way to go. :D

Thanx for the reply... I'll check out the AC units..

Nice housing, what did you get for a router back then? I suggest AC for "future proofing". AC has been out for a while but companies are still putting out what can only be described as prototypes. Commercial use is still young.
 

Mussels

Freshwater Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 6, 2004
Messages
58,413 (8.22/day)
Location
Oystralia
System Name Rainbow Sparkles (Power efficient, <350W gaming load)
Processor Ryzen R7 5800x3D (Undervolted, 4.45GHz all core)
Motherboard Asus x570-F (BIOS Modded)
Cooling Alphacool Apex UV - Alphacool Eisblock XPX Aurora + EK Quantum ARGB 3090 w/ active backplate
Memory 2x32GB DDR4 3600 Corsair Vengeance RGB @3866 C18-22-22-22-42 TRFC704 (1.4V Hynix MJR - SoC 1.15V)
Video Card(s) Galax RTX 3090 SG 24GB: Underclocked to 1700Mhz 0.750v (375W down to 250W))
Storage 2TB WD SN850 NVME + 1TB Sasmsung 970 Pro NVME + 1TB Intel 6000P NVME USB 3.2
Display(s) Phillips 32 32M1N5800A (4k144), LG 32" (4K60) | Gigabyte G32QC (2k165) | Phillips 328m6fjrmb (2K144)
Case Fractal Design R6
Audio Device(s) Logitech G560 | Corsair Void pro RGB |Blue Yeti mic
Power Supply Fractal Ion+ 2 860W (Platinum) (This thing is God-tier. Silent and TINY)
Mouse Logitech G Pro wireless + Steelseries Prisma XL
Keyboard Razer Huntsman TE ( Sexy white keycaps)
VR HMD Oculus Rift S + Quest 2
Software Windows 11 pro x64 (Yes, it's genuinely a good OS) OpenRGB - ditch the branded bloatware!
Benchmark Scores Nyooom.
i say go with wifi N, the tech is mature and you get N150/N300/N600 as speed options in well tested hardware.

you could also go with powerline/homeplug tech for multiple backbones to the various AP's.
 
Joined
Feb 11, 2013
Messages
40 (0.01/day)
Nice housing, what did you get for a router back then? I suggest AC for "future proofing". AC has been out for a while but companies are still putting out what can only be described as prototypes. Commercial use is still young.

In that pic, I had a skinned Linksys WRT54G running DD-WRT... In the 2010 hardware update, I went with a series of Amped Wireless R2000G that was suggested by RemixedCat here...

Planning for possible future needs definitely has appeal...
 
Joined
Feb 11, 2013
Messages
40 (0.01/day)
i say go with wifi N, the tech is mature and you get N150/N300/N600 as speed options in well tested hardware.

you could also go with powerline/homeplug tech for multiple backbones to the various AP's.

Yea, I thought that as well. But my concern is that there are one or two bandwidth hogs that might be overtaxing the current AW R2000Gs that are installed new. I am just now starting to research the logging/QoS capabilities of the R2000Gs.. If anyone has any insight on that as well...

Well, as Ross Perot said in the 1992 Presidential Debates, "I am all ears"... :D
 
Joined
Feb 11, 2013
Messages
40 (0.01/day)
Keep in mind that a BIG part of what we need is POE. That was the down side to the AW R2000Gs that I ended up using. POE is a major requirement.
 

Mussels

Freshwater Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 6, 2004
Messages
58,413 (8.22/day)
Location
Oystralia
System Name Rainbow Sparkles (Power efficient, <350W gaming load)
Processor Ryzen R7 5800x3D (Undervolted, 4.45GHz all core)
Motherboard Asus x570-F (BIOS Modded)
Cooling Alphacool Apex UV - Alphacool Eisblock XPX Aurora + EK Quantum ARGB 3090 w/ active backplate
Memory 2x32GB DDR4 3600 Corsair Vengeance RGB @3866 C18-22-22-22-42 TRFC704 (1.4V Hynix MJR - SoC 1.15V)
Video Card(s) Galax RTX 3090 SG 24GB: Underclocked to 1700Mhz 0.750v (375W down to 250W))
Storage 2TB WD SN850 NVME + 1TB Sasmsung 970 Pro NVME + 1TB Intel 6000P NVME USB 3.2
Display(s) Phillips 32 32M1N5800A (4k144), LG 32" (4K60) | Gigabyte G32QC (2k165) | Phillips 328m6fjrmb (2K144)
Case Fractal Design R6
Audio Device(s) Logitech G560 | Corsair Void pro RGB |Blue Yeti mic
Power Supply Fractal Ion+ 2 860W (Platinum) (This thing is God-tier. Silent and TINY)
Mouse Logitech G Pro wireless + Steelseries Prisma XL
Keyboard Razer Huntsman TE ( Sexy white keycaps)
VR HMD Oculus Rift S + Quest 2
Software Windows 11 pro x64 (Yes, it's genuinely a good OS) OpenRGB - ditch the branded bloatware!
Benchmark Scores Nyooom.
Yea, I thought that as well. But my concern is that there are one or two bandwidth hogs that might be overtaxing the current AW R2000Gs that are installed new. I am just now starting to research the logging/QoS capabilities of the R2000Gs.. If anyone has any insight on that as well...

Well, as Ross Perot said in the 1992 Presidential Debates, "I am all ears"... :D


all i can advise is that the TP link routers i use all have per-IP bandwidth management. you can literally set a global rule say
192.168.1.2 through 192.168.1.255 all have max down of 400KB/s and max up of 40KB/s

then no one user can hammer the network, they just choke their own bandwidth pool. now clearly you should be able to get the same effect with better hardware, but if TP link can do it on a $20 router, you should be able to find a superior version with what you're dealing with.

one advantage here: you only need to do the shaping once, at the upstream level, more or less at the core modem/router.
disadvantage: if you're going to segregate the network with multiple DHCP servers, you'll have to give the router a higher allocation, and then re-shape the bandwidth after each router.


edit: the TP links i have also support PoE. they may not have the performance levels you require, however.
 

brandonwh64

Addicted to Bacon and StarCrunches!!!
Joined
Sep 6, 2009
Messages
19,542 (3.68/day)
I built you a system a in that other thread and it was over looked. I just built the same system using a P4 1GB ram with dual Gig NIC cards, a gig POE switch with 14 POE wireless N 300mbps nodes and it houses over 175 devices at this time and has ran strong for 3 months without a single slow down or reboot.
 
Joined
Feb 11, 2013
Messages
40 (0.01/day)
I built you a system a in that other thread and it was over looked. I just built the same system using a P4 1GB ram with dual Gig NIC cards, a gig POE switch with 14 POE wireless N 300mbps nodes and it houses over 175 devices at this time and has ran strong for 3 months without a single slow down or reboot.

At the time, I didn't have the knowledge to really understand what you were trying to say..

I am a little smarter now. :D

What OS are you running on the P4 machine that's acting as the router??
 

brandonwh64

Addicted to Bacon and StarCrunches!!!
Joined
Sep 6, 2009
Messages
19,542 (3.68/day)
Well with that software, the more NIC cards you put in the more interfaces you can create.

Also when it comes to access points, I would recommend UniFi AP's. They have a nice piece of software that you can control and map each of their locations along with monitor traffic/users individually.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Nov 4, 2005
Messages
11,642 (1.73/day)
System Name Compy 386
Processor 7800X3D
Motherboard Asus
Cooling Air for now.....
Memory 64 GB DDR5 6400Mhz
Video Card(s) 7900XTX 310 Merc
Storage Samsung 990 2TB, 2 SP 2TB SSDs and over 10TB spinning
Display(s) 56" Samsung 4K HDR
Audio Device(s) ATI HDMI
Mouse Logitech MX518
Keyboard Razer
Software A lot.
Benchmark Scores Its fast. Enough.
Ubiquity and any hardware router/firewall for bandwidth management.
 
Joined
Feb 11, 2013
Messages
40 (0.01/day)
Well with that software, the more NIC cards you put in the more interfaces you can create.

Also when it comes to access points, I would recommend UniFi AP's. They have a nice piece of software that you can control and map each of their locations along with monitor traffic/users individually.

That sounds like EXACTLY what I need... Do you have any recommendations on specific models??
 
Joined
Feb 11, 2013
Messages
40 (0.01/day)
OK, I am writing up a proposal for the management for an upgrade...

One question though.. The UniFi AC AP that is POE ready would STILL require a ToughSwitch type device to actually feed the power to the APs, right?? I was thinking that, if I went for the AC units as opposed to the B/G/N units, I could forgo the ToughSwitch on the AC units.

But that's not the case. Regardless of whether I go with the AC or with the B/G/N, I will still need that TouchSwitch... Right??
 
Joined
May 13, 2010
Messages
5,616 (1.11/day)
System Name RemixedBeast-NX
Processor Intel Xeon E5-2690 @ 2.9Ghz (8C/16T)
Motherboard Dell Inc. 08HPGT (CPU 1)
Cooling Dell Standard
Memory 24GB ECC
Video Card(s) Gigabyte Nvidia RTX2060 6GB
Storage 2TB Samsung 860 EVO SSD//2TB WD Black HDD
Display(s) Samsung SyncMaster P2350 23in @ 1920x1080 + Dell E2013H 20 in @1600x900
Case Dell Precision T3600 Chassis
Audio Device(s) Beyerdynamic DT770 Pro 80 // Fiio E7 Amp/DAC
Power Supply 630w Dell T3600 PSU
Mouse Logitech G700s/G502
Keyboard Logitech K740
Software Linux Mint 20
Benchmark Scores Network: APs: Cisco Meraki MR32, Ubiquiti Unifi AP-AC-LR and Lite Router/Sw:Meraki MX64 MS220-8P
You had them this long and you didnt' try the QoS???

If you want the absolute best nitty gritty QoS controls I recommend Cisco Meraki. I have tested 2 of thier routers and I have one of thier access points... the MR12.

Here's a screen shot of the QoS controls:

Group policies configuration - Meraki Dashboard.png

See this review I wrote for one of the routers I tested:
http://remixedcat.blogspot.com/2014/01/cisco-meraki-mx60w-review.html

Put the RV park guests on the seprate VLAN and throttle torrents and stuff.

Thing is the meraki stuff is more on the pricey side MR12 is 300 some including the software license, the MX60W is around 1000USD, However the range isn't as good as the amped units so you would need to deploy more of them


Now the extreme networks unit you mentioned requires a wlan controller which adds to the cost. Meraki does not require that as it's cloud managed. also with it being cloud managed it's anti theft and also they have air marshall in them as well as auto rf.
 
Last edited:

brandonwh64

Addicted to Bacon and StarCrunches!!!
Joined
Sep 6, 2009
Messages
19,542 (3.68/day)
Yea remixcat, the IPcop has a pretty good QoS setup that can be done but its up to him on price he has on this project and what he want to do as the local IT support cause he may not be familar with how cisco management works. I do agree that is a good router.
 
Joined
May 13, 2010
Messages
5,616 (1.11/day)
System Name RemixedBeast-NX
Processor Intel Xeon E5-2690 @ 2.9Ghz (8C/16T)
Motherboard Dell Inc. 08HPGT (CPU 1)
Cooling Dell Standard
Memory 24GB ECC
Video Card(s) Gigabyte Nvidia RTX2060 6GB
Storage 2TB Samsung 860 EVO SSD//2TB WD Black HDD
Display(s) Samsung SyncMaster P2350 23in @ 1920x1080 + Dell E2013H 20 in @1600x900
Case Dell Precision T3600 Chassis
Audio Device(s) Beyerdynamic DT770 Pro 80 // Fiio E7 Amp/DAC
Power Supply 630w Dell T3600 PSU
Mouse Logitech G700s/G502
Keyboard Logitech K740
Software Linux Mint 20
Benchmark Scores Network: APs: Cisco Meraki MR32, Ubiquiti Unifi AP-AC-LR and Lite Router/Sw:Meraki MX64 MS220-8P
Is IPCop's QoS like the Meraki???
 
Top