Although I'm not really "watching" them, I read some RC posts about the two series of the episodes that went beyond the ones I did watch. They're not that "great", good maybe, but not "great" or must watch.
So far only Denpa Onna to Seishun Otoko and Mawaru Penguindrum warrants that. And Break Blade (since they're "movies", you can say that the ones released in 2011 were 2011 shows even though the first movie was released in 2010).
Kamisama Dolls redeemed itself a bit for me with how well it ended, a good "cliffhanger" so to speak.
I like the anime, but i still hate kyouhei and hibino, god i hate kyhouhei's voice, in any show it appears, and hibino for being oversized and plain normal, Kuko (demented personality), Mahiro (crazy, yandere, demented bitch and strong, how many female "heroines" like her??), and utau the faces she makes are hilarious, and she isnt weak either...
Madoka redefines the genre previously composed of mostly cute girls doing cute things with cute mascots and pink powers, Being Nanoha an exception that redefined the genre by itself by proposing an action magical girl show, Madoka goes further and it isnt afraid of the consequences, the future in Madoka is grim and being a magical girl means
steins Gate is unique, and no other anime presented such setting, good characters and story, it has never been done...
So both of these are original in the anime world...
Madoka is not for you then. I find it rather polarising, its either you think its really good, or its just "another magical girl anime which is just popular".