Badges seem kind of out of place here on TPU. But that may simply just be the case since they've only popped up in the last 24 hour or so and I'm not used to seeing them. I guess I wait and see how it all pans out.
In the mean time you can just get me a badge that says "Guy that knows some stuff, doesn't post enough to be overly helpful." and I'll be content.
I think this change has started the boulder down the slippery slope of Facebookification. Actually, it started with replacing Thanks with Like. I want Thanks back; I want Like and Rate gone. It was a simple system that worked--was positive in nature.
The new badges I find annoying. They distract from meaningful content. WCG and F@H were good because they advertised/honored donors which are both intrinsically good things that lead to more good things.
TL;DR: This new stuff is promoting the "us versus them" mentality that is already destroying the world. Please don't let it destroy TPU too.
Yes, please. I'm not a fan of "Like". Just because I may click "Like" for a post, doesn't mean I necessarily like it. I liked "Thanks" - just a simple way to thank them for a useful post, regardless if I actually like it or not.
As for the rating aspect, I think it looks tacky. You got some goofy + or - box on the right side of posts....if I hadn't been following the updates about it all I wouldn't know what the hell it was for. Just my two cents.
If the rating system sticks around, I hope it doesn't turn into some reddit crap-hole of people just rating posts up and down because they can.