It's not a permanent solution, it's like putting a bandaid on a gaping would caused by a shotgun slug. The big 3 are dying because nobody is buying thier cars. Tell me, if I give the big 3 automakers my money, how in all creation is it going to save them? Sure they'll stay afloat for a while, but again, bandaid on a shotgun slug wound... they'll just bleed out again. Nobody is buying thier cars because nobody has the money TO buy cars in the first place!