Winchip DDR3 1600 MHz 1 GB Kit Review 8

Winchip DDR3 1600 MHz 1 GB Kit Review

Value & Conclusion »

Test Setup

Test System
CPU:Intel E6300 Conroe
1.8 GHz, 2 MB Cache
Motherboard:ASUS P5K3 Deluxe BIOS 0602
Video Card:PowerColor X800XL Pro 16 PCI-E
Harddisk:Samsung P80 80 GB
Power Supply:Ultra V-Power 450W
Software:Windows XP SP2, Catalyst 7.6

Performance & Overclocking

Even though the Winchip DDR3 is meant to run at 1600 MHz, CL-8-8-8-15 using 1.95 - 2.05V, the SPD timings on the memory only go up to 1422 MHz with CL 8-8-8-27. Winchip simply takes the memory ICs and sorts out the ones, which manage 1600 at CL8-8-8-15. To actually get the memory running at this speed, the mainboard FSB needs to be set at 400 MHz. This translates to 2.8 GHz or 940 MHz overclock on the Core 2 Duo E6300. Intel is currently in the process of releasing 1333 MHz based CPUs which run at 333 MHz FSB, these would not require such a high overclock to reach the magical 400 MHz needed for the 1:2 ratio to result in 1600 MHz. After running the memory at the rated speed, the timings were loosend to CL10-10-10-30, but the memory simply would not budge any further at 2.05V. The E6300 used in this test is easily capable of running well over 2.8 GHz, thus it is the memory that is the limiting factor here.

The second step was to find the minimum CL the DDR3 would run at. The ASUS P5K3 can be set all the way down to CL5-3-3, but Winchip's memory was not stable at this setting, no matter how much voltage was applied. Loosening the timings to CL5-4-4-12 resulted in a booting system even at the standard 1.5V and 800 MHz. The success did not pay off, as the memory would become unstable with slightly higher clocks and would not be stable beyond 842 MHz, no matter how much voltage was applied.

Then, the Winchip DDR3 modules were set to CL5-5-5-15, a very popular timing on high-end DDR2 memory these days. At this rating the memory actually managed a very respectable 1066 Mhz with 1.6V with no problems. Further raising the speed did not succeed beyond 1072 MHz, no matter how much voltage was applied. There is a pattern to be seen here. The memory works at tight timings but simply cannot get past a certain point.

The next step meant loosening the memory to CL6-6-6-15. This resulted in a much broader overclock and managed 1268 MHz at 1.7V. Once again, this was the end of the line for the memory at CL 6. CL7-7-7-15 raised that bar one more, just barely missing the 1400 MHz mark with 1394 MHz at, once again 1.7V. Raising the voltage further did result in a few extra MHz, but the system was not completely stable and would freeze or restart during benchmarking. The memory only manages the get beyond that with the advertised CL8-8-8-15. At this it runs all the way up to the advertised speed, but not even 6 MHz beyond that.

Winchip DDR3 1600 MHz 1 GB Kit
CPU Clock &
Memory Ratio
Memory
Speed
Memory
Timings
Everest
Read
Everest
Write
Everest
Latency
Quake 3
Timedemo
3DMark
2001SE
SuperPi
Mod 1M
7 x 266 2:3 400 MHz 5-4-4-12 1.5V 6281 MB/s 4846 MB/s 80.1 ns 533.7 fps 2436129.00 s
7 x 281 2:3 421 MHz 5-4-4-12 1.5V 6599 MB/s 5056 MB/s 75.4 ns 561.0 fps 2533027.53 s
7 x 266 2:3 400 MHz 5-5-5-15 1.5V 6246 MB/s 4820 MB/s 81.3 ns 530.3 fps 2427729.09 s
7 x 355 2:3 533 MHz 5-5-5-15 1.6V 8004 MB/s 5628 MB/s 63.7 ns 614.0 fps 2650425.14 s
7 x 289 1:2578 MHz 6-6-6-15 1.5V 7356 MB/s 5251 MB/s 70.3 ns 578.2 fps 2569026.61 s
7 x 308 1:2616 MHz6-6-6-15 1.6V 7839 MB/s 5536 MB/s 66.0 ns 617.6 fps 2652924.96 s
7 x 308 1:2634 MHz6-6-6-15 1.7V 7783 MB/s 5745 MB/s 64.2 ns 630.6 fps 2690724.3 s
7 x 306 1:2612 MHz7-7-7-15 1.5V 7741 MB/s 5546 MB/s 64.2 ns 609.3 fps 2659125.46 s
7 x 333 1:2667 MHz7-7-7-15 1.6V 8125 MB/s 6005 MB/s 64.8 ns 660.7 fps 2770423.17 s
7 x 347 1:2694 MHz7-7-7-15 1.7V 8428 MB/s 6187 MB/s 62.4 ns 688.9 fps 28010 22.31 s
7 x 355 1:2710 MHz8-8-8-15 1.5V 8300 MB/s 6419 MB/s 64.0 ns 689.3 fps 28219 21.92 s
7 x 376 1:2752 MHz8-8-8-15 1.7V 8804 MB/s 6716 MB/s 60.4 ns 730.4 fps 2896720.67 s
7 x 400 1:2800 MHz8-8-8-15 2.05V 9282 MB/s 7043 MB/s 63.0 ns 775.4 fps 2928019.45 s







This graph shows you at a quick glance which clock frequencies you can expect at which voltage. Please note that each individual module overclocks different, the results here can only be seen as an indicator of performance.
Next Page »Value & Conclusion
View as single page
Apr 24th, 2024 20:57 EDT change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

Controversial News Posts