• Welcome to TechPowerUp Forums, Guest! Please check out our forum guidelines for info related to our community.

Microsoft Readies Security Feature-Update for Windows 11 Needing an OS Reinstall to Use

btarunr

btarunr

Editor & Senior Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 9, 2007
Messages
47,668 (7.43/day)
Location
Dublin, Ireland
System Specs
System Name RBMK-1000
Processor AMD Ryzen 7 5700G
Motherboard Gigabyte B550 AORUS Elite V2
Cooling DeepCool Gammax L240 V2
Memory 2x 16GB DDR4-3200
Video Card(s) Galax RTX 4070 Ti EX
Storage Samsung 990 1TB
Display(s) BenQ 1440p 60 Hz 27-inch
Case Corsair Carbide 100R
Audio Device(s) ASUS SupremeFX S1220A
Power Supply Cooler Master MWE Gold 650W
Mouse ASUS ROG Strix Impact
Keyboard Gamdias Hermes E2
Software Windows 11 Pro
Microsoft is giving final touches to a what it refers to as a groundbreaking new security feature update for the Windows 11 operating system, which should significantly improve application-level security, and safeguard you from malicious apps based on the way they behave. Trouble is, to use the feature, you will have to reinstall your operating system (i.e. a clean reinstall), if you're on the current release of Windows 11, or any build that's older than the one that carries this update.

The Smart App Control feature by default blocks untrusted or uncertified applications from running on your PC, and unlike browser-level protections such as Smart Screen, is baked directly into the OS, and monitors application code at a process level, to detect potentially malicious application behavior. It does this using a combination of code-signing by the application publisher and an AI model for trust within the Microsoft cloud. The OS keeps in touch with the cloud 24x7 (whenever the PC is up), to receive the latest threat intelligence and AI model updates from the cloud. It's very likely that Smart App Control will be part of the next significant version milestone of Windows 11 (such as "22H2"), which means everyone on 22H1 or older will be made to reinstall to use it.



View at TechPowerUp Main Site | Source
 
Smart App Control will be part of the next significant version milestone of Windows 11 (such as "22H2"), which means everyone on 22H1 or older will be made to reinstall to use it.
Click to expand...

I hope this it's not true and a workaround will be available, because makes no sense that I can install Windows 7 and upgrade to 8, 10 and 11, and now we need a clean install for a new feature...
 
clopezi said:
I hope this it's not true and a workaround will be available, because makes no sense that I can install Windows 7 and upgrade to 8, 10 and 11, and now we need a clean install for a new feature...
Click to expand...

The problem here is, do user(s) still have they windows key going back that far. It maybe wise to track & backup your current key if a new install turns out to be true.
 
So HIPS, but with the extra costs of having to trust Microsoft with [even more of] your data.
And, according to gHacks, you can't even exclude applications that MS disallows you to run.

Meh. Looks like just another smart screen-ish toggle to turn off.
 
Shihabyooo said:
So HIPS, but with the extra costs of having to trust Microsoft with [even more of] your data.
And, according to gHacks, you can't even exclude applications that MS disallows you to run.

Meh. Looks like just another smart screen-ish toggle to turn off.
Click to expand...
That's probably true, but the problem is if they would allow to update future releases without reinstalling, or this will be mandatory until now. It's my concern about it.
 
delshay said:
The problem here is, do user(s) still have they windows key going back that far. It maybe wise to track & backup your current key if a new install turns out to be true.
Click to expand...
I'm not sure that going back to W7 is needed for people here that are used to do a clean install.

I mean, I've done the upgrade from W7 but that's just once for each computer thanks to GatherOSState.exe.

Installing W7 just to upgrade to W10 over and over again seems tedious, does anyone actually do that?

Edit: GatherOSState.exe lets you do a clean install directly, no upgrade needed. It's been too long since I did it lol.
 
Last edited:
delshay said:
The problem here is, do user(s) still have they windows key going back that far. It maybe wise to track & backup your current key if a new install turns out to be true.
Click to expand...

Windows usually saves it to your M$ account so there is usually not need to even enter it again.
 
Tigger said:
Windows usually saves it to your M$ account so there is usually not need to even enter it again.
Click to expand...

OK, never knew that. I don't have a Microsoft account & I have seen a small number of user(s) also claiming not to have one. It looks like I a maybe forced to open an account saving me storing multiple windows keys.
 
delshay said:
OK, never knew that. I don't have a Microsoft account & I have seen a small number of user(s) also claiming not to have one. It looks like I a maybe forced to open an account saving me storing multiple windows keys.
Click to expand...
Dunno how that works, do you enter a key every time you install? I never enter any key, and it activates when I go online. No MS account.
 
Mats said:
Or, keeps track of the HWID tied to the install for those that doesn't use MS account. At least for W10, dunno about W11.
Click to expand...

I would expect going forward W11 is supported, but what about older Windows keys???


EDIT: @Thread

I wonder if a new complete install kicks out those users that bypass W11 security feature? ie users without TPM.
 
Last edited:
delshay said:
Mostly windows 7. ...But I have windows 10 & 8.0 disc & key also.
Click to expand...
AFAIK, key handling, licensing and activation process haven't changed for either version so I doubt it will change for older versions.
 
Smart App Control sounds like a nightmare to me and other devs whom often run self made programs or from other people, windows defender is already a pain. I hope I can just disable this thing all the time.
 
This is the new Denuvo but it is M$ backed, so they want to make it harder to use open source apps. I think that you will need to pay a fee to be able to certify an app.
This is also going to be a nightmare for code developers as this will make it harder to run self made apps.
 
First TPM nonsense now this.

Do they even want to sell 11 or are they intent on making it fail with full certainty? The market share has already stalled completely, and for good reasons.

You don't want this, right? Why would you? The GUI has gone to complete shit, taskbar is worse than it ever was, it tries to be Apple but has none of its unique selling points, but all of its problems, and security apparently is full of holes.

I smell a Windows 8
 
So... Windows 12?

When was the last time an update required a reinstall? I imagine that means fresh install. That's really a bothersome requirement.
 
Vayra86 said:
Do they even want to sell 11 or are they intent on making it fail with full certainty? The market share has already stalled completely, and for good reasons.
Click to expand...
I dunno, I certainly don't expect Windows market share to go up no matter what they do.
 
The Smart App Control feature by default blocks untrusted or uncertified applications from running on your PC, and unlike browser-level protections such as Smart Screen, is baked directly into the OS, and monitors application code at a process level, to detect potentially malicious application behavior. It does this using a combination of code-signing by the application publisher and an AI model for trust within the Microsoft cloud. The OS keeps in touch with the cloud 24x7 (whenever the PC is up), to receive the latest threat intelligence and AI model updates from the cloud.
Click to expand...

This is your telemetry hard at work. I wonder if there is a separate download you can install in offline mode. This cloud contact is BS and intrusive, its a step in the direction that m$ wants to go, complete cloud control, windows 11 as a service.
 
I still believe that it's all leading to a subscription service. :mad:
 
Audioave10 said:
I still believe that it's all leading to a subscription service. :mad:
Click to expand...
While not impossible, we've heard this for a decade by now.
I don't think it will happen, unless MS want's their market share to drop even more.

1649246283919.png
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top