I never offered my opinion on the game with the exception of the golfing joke. As far as I'm concerned, the game ended perfectly in P1. I have no interest of seeing Joel break characterSorry man, the game wasn't bad at all. If you actually look into why the game didn't sell well had nothing to do with it being a bad story or game play.
in order to facilitate some unrewarding revenge story with Ellie. Not to mention the idea of playing as the murderer of a beloved character.