• Welcome to TechPowerUp Forums, Guest! Please check out our forum guidelines for info related to our community.

B-die equivalent for DDR5?

57er6uigyuholn

New Member
Joined
Mar 14, 2023
Messages
20 (0.02/day)
I'm looking to build and AM5 system and am looking for RAM. On my AM4 machine I have Viper Steel 4400 which is b-die, and I got lucky and all 4 sticks can really tighten down timing a lot.

What's the AM5 equivalent ≈? I read the memory controller lottery plays a big role. Plan to run a 9950x with 2x32GB sticks

What speed can 9000 series take? What kind of timings at those speeds?

Sorry I know it's a broad question, but all i can find is really outdated or contradictory info
 
DDR5 Hynix A die kits scale well with voltage similar to Samsung ddr4 B-Die.

8000mhz kits, proper motherboard. Should be no problem.
 
A die, or the 24GB rev.2 m-die kits. Crosshair Apex/Gene/GB Tachyon will be able to do 8200/8400 if your CPU's IMC is up to scratch. Had to go through 5 9950x's to find one that does more than 8200 on the Apex though. Single CCD CPU's can clock higher, their IMC has less strain with one GMI link.

Best kit would be the G.skill 2x16GB CL26 6000 kit or 2x24GB CL26 6000 kit. A die does tighter 8000, 24GB M die's can clock higher. Lexar's CL26 6000 does come close, but the G.skill is generally superior.
 
SK Hynix (16 Gbit) 2 GB A-Die has the lowest possible timings, excluding the oddball 8 Gbit ones that are in KLEVV FIT V. Those are dual-rank 32GB kits...very strange stuff.

SK Hynix (24 Gbit) 3 GB M-Die has the highest possible frequency currently. Not far behind A-Die for sub-timings. Both M (3GB) and A (2GB) can handle 1.5V just fine with a fan. I would say 1.6V if you have the right cooling, otherwise it will error out.
 
Plan to run a 9950x with 2x32GB sticks
That means 2R sticks.
Compared to 2x16GB and 2x24GB (which are 1R) it's reasonable to expect lower max. speeds.

A good starting point if you haven't already read it:
It's best to decide from the start if you want lower speed and tighter timings or higher speed and looser timings. Price of the kits should help you decide.
But the priority has to be capacity, you don't want to gimp your build just to have a "high performance" 32GB RAM kit.
The advantage of the Ryzen memory sweetspot of 6000 is that it allows very generous capacity 2R kits to run at that speed, sure with usually a little bit more voltage (1.4V) and not super tight timings (C30/C32).
 
I'm looking to build and AM5 system and am looking for RAM. On my AM4 machine I have Viper Steel 4400 which is b-die, and I got lucky and all 4 sticks can really tighten down timing a lot.

What's the AM5 equivalent ≈? I read the memory controller lottery plays a big role. Plan to run a 9950x with 2x32GB sticks

What speed can 9000 series take? What kind of timings at those speeds?

Sorry I know it's a broad question, but all i can find is really outdated or contradictory info
SK Hynix (16 Gbit) 2 GB A-Die has the lowest possible timings, excluding the oddball 8 Gbit ones that are in KLEVV FIT V. Those are dual-rank 32GB kits...very strange stuff.

SK Hynix (24 Gbit) 3 GB M-Die has the highest possible frequency currently. Not far behind A-Die for sub-timings. Both M (3GB) and A (2GB) can handle 1.5V just fine with a fan. I would say 1.6V if you have the right cooling, otherwise it will error out.
2x 2R sticks technically best you can do on AMD for the write bandwidth increase, since sweetspot is 6-6400 MT anyway, so the higher MT ratings you can get with 1R sticks are irrelevant. Going for A die if 2x 2R, or M die if 2x 1R, so 2x 32 GB, or 2x 24 GB.

Avoid any 4x setup, or even motherboards with four slots unless they're the fancy ASUS ones with optimized traces, I forget what they're called and am too lazy to look it up.
With DDR5, a 2x setup gives you more than enough capacity on dual channel systems anyway (64, 96, 128 GB). For the higher capacities, you want quad or higher channel anyway.

Note the bottleneck is still the IF, which clocks at best around 2000 MHz, maybe ~2100 or 2200 if you're extremely lucky. 6000 MT '1:1' means the memory and memory controller are both running at 3000 MHz, which still means the IF limits actual benefits of that, since it's 1.5:1 to the actual cores.

Explained here.

1752833629868.png


Zen 6 may fix the IF bottleneck as new packaging and less latency penalty, which in theory should mean X3D cache is less needed, that was a mitigation for the latency penalty of chiplet design as AMD built them.

Note that the IF being 2000 MHz essentially means it didn't get faster since AM4, X570 and Zen 3 could do 2000 MHz IF/FCLK for '1:1' with 4000 MT/2000 MHz DDR4, but more common was 3800 MT.

I ran a 5800X3D with 4000/14 DRAM and 2000 MT IF, still kinda miss that rig.

Nitropath, that's what ASUS calls their improved traces, supposedly brings 4 slot boards to the level of 2 slot boards, but I am skeptical, and irritated they didn't put it on their two slot boards too.
 
Back
Top