- Joined
- May 10, 2023
- Messages
- 951 (1.25/day)
- Location
- Brazil
Processor | 5950x |
---|---|
Motherboard | B550 ProArt |
Cooling | Fuma 2 |
Memory | 4x32GB 3200MHz Corsair LPX |
Video Card(s) | 2x RTX 3090 |
Display(s) | LG 42" C2 4k OLED |
Power Supply | XPG Core Reactor 850W |
Software | I use Arch btw |
The framework 13 sure looks like a great product, and even with regular DDR5 instead of LPDDR5X it still manages great performance and a reasonable power consumption, as per phoronix's benchmarks.
I'd personally prefer LPDDR5X for an even lower power consumption and more memory bandwidth. But my main gripe against it is that the battery is kinda small at 61Wh, whereas most competitors are using 70Wh+ batteries.
The demo with multiple FW desktops is also cool as a showcase for the rack and that it's possible, albeit in practice it's pretty useless due to that gimpy interconnect.
However, complaining about the lack of a full-width slot for usage with other PCIe devices, such as faster networking or more NVMe storage, is way more reasonable IMO.
I'd personally prefer LPDDR5X for an even lower power consumption and more memory bandwidth. But my main gripe against it is that the battery is kinda small at 61Wh, whereas most competitors are using 70Wh+ batteries.
The demo with multiple FW desktops is also cool as a showcase for the rack and that it's possible, albeit in practice it's pretty useless due to that gimpy interconnect.
Yeah, this pretty much summarizes my feelings for the demo itself.With one NIC @ 5Gbit this is basically useless for AI and clusters but at least this can push more awareness towards Jeff Gerlings Project MINI RACK ...and we hopefully get more competition for the MS-A2.
I think the dGPU argument for this specific product is a bit moot. It'd make no sense whatsoever to do so.Strix halo has access to 16 external PCIe lanes. There's no reason we couldn't have at least a x8 slot. GPUs age quickly, far faster than CPUs, and that's also not the only use for a x8/x16 slot. Even the likes of Dell/HP, when they use x4 slots, have the common courtesy to leave the end of the slot open so you can use cards with the x16 sized connector, since actual x4 edge connectors are very rare.
For a company that is all about longevity and repairability/modding/expansion, to the point they made a dGPU addon for one of their laptops, this is a pretty major oversight.
However, complaining about the lack of a full-width slot for usage with other PCIe devices, such as faster networking or more NVMe storage, is way more reasonable IMO.