Huh? You say you disagree then completely verified exactly what I said! You said,
"you separate the bond between the GPU and the heatsink. This is what requires you to clean that area and reapply the TIM". Those are YOUR words!!!!!
And there is no reason to remove a heatsink to clean the system of dust. That just risks damaging the processor, the processor's socket, and/or the board.
This has been discussed over and over again. But check the link in my sig. I am not a hobbyist. I know a thing or two about electronics hardware. I have asked over and over again for those claiming TIM needs regular replacing to show us where the manufacturer of their favorite TIM (or any popular TIM) says it needs to be replaced regularly. Surely their marketing departments would exploit that if true to increase sales. But they don't.
I have asked over and over again to show us any white paper, study or professional article that says TIM needs to be periodically replaced. But no one can because there are none! In fact, what you can find is this,
The Heatsink Guide: Info about thermal compound and note the following (my
bold added),
And
Artic says their TIM has an "8" Year durability and,
So once again, TIM does NOT need to be replace UNLESS the bond between the mating surfaces is broken.
Unless you (or anybody) can show
any study, professional article, or even a TIM maker that says TIM needs regular replacing, IT IS JUST NOT SO!
To be sure, users replacing TIM has made me lots of money. They bring in their computers and when I ask what happened, they say, "
Someone on a forum said I need to replace my thermal paste because my temperatures were too hot. Now my computer won't boot." Then I find out they,
Didn't take any ESD precautions,
Didn't unplug from the wall,
Didn't thoroughly clean the mating surfaces of old TIM,
Applied gobs of new TIM,
Didn't properly re-mount and/or secure the HSF assembly,
Bent pins on the CPU or socket through mishandling,
The screwdriver slipped and they cut a Grand Canyon size gorge (microscopically speaking) in the motherboard.
All for what? A few degrees of cooling? The fact of the matter is, if you
need those 5° or so of cooling to keep your computer stable, your case is not doing its job! And that means the user has not done his or her job of properly configuring or maintaining his or her case cooling.
So as a technician with a shop, users replacing TIM is good for my business. But as a forum helper/advisor who specializes in hardware support, I find it disturbing when users are simply told by folks with no formal training in "applied electronics" to replace their TIM when there is absolutely
no evidence anywhere to suggest it is needed. And I find it even further disturbing when such advice is given haphazardly! That is, with no warnings about ESD precautions, site preparation or proper application of the TIM! That is just bad advice giving that does a disservice, not a service to those seeking help.