And what exactly is that? Clean the interiors of a computer? It doesn't take a magician to do that. Just a little patience, compressed air and a natural brush.
As for "experts", not sure what you call an expert in electronics support, but to me it is a properly trained and certified individual who has been recognized by his peers as an expert in that field. An expert in electronics is not a computer hobbyist or enthusiasts who has put together or fixed a few computers.
I don't even know what you are arguing about any more. My point was, and still is, if the bond between the mating surfaces is not broken, there is no need to replace the TIM. That's the point I am standing on and with your pictures as evidence, it is clear the bond was not broken, as you yourself admitted, because the pictures show there was no dust in there. The only legit reason to take it apart was simply because you wanted to.
Does TIM degrade in performance after "many" years? Yes! But only by a few degrees if the bond remains intact! And if you "need" those few degrees because your GPU is pushing 105°C or your CPU is pushing its limits, then you have more problems than just the TIM that need to be addressed. These include case cooling, fan speeds, dust, improper overclocking, improper application of TIM in the first place, failing components and more - including a combination of several of those things, which is normally the case.
Is one TIM better than the other? Yes but if you look at reviews the gap between the worst and best of the popular TIMs is typically less than 5°C and again, if you need that 5°C to keep your system stable or from toggling down, you have other problems you need to address.
Furmark, 3DMark Vantage, OCCT GPU Stress Test, Prime95, etc. are NOT realistic scenarios - they are designed to push and abuse the hardware to their limits and beyond - like taking your car to the drag race track and flooring it. And if that's what you want to do, fine! But that does not mean that is what "normal" users, even normal gamers need to do.
Enthusiast acceptable??? That's hogwash! Nothing but bragging rights! You cannot assume that every person coming to these forums seeking help is at that level because they sure do not need to be at that level. They need their systems work comfortably within "normal operating ranges".
So I am done here unless you can show us any paper, study, article, TIM maker, processor maker, graphics card maker, computer maker, gaming computer maker - "EXPERTS" in their fields - who say their TIM needs to be regularly replaced.