Here's one for you guys. It's a similar topic so I figured I'll ask now since we have some of the experts attention.
I work in a local PC shop and the other month we ordered the usual DVI-I to VGA adapters. Now this is a pretty common part that we order from our supplier on a regular basis.
But this time something is different. They sent us 2 of these adapters but they lacked the extra R,G,B,Sync pins. You know the 4 pins that are located 2 above, and 2 below the slot to the far side. Basically the extra pins that make a DVI-I, a DVI-I! So it was basically male Dual Link DVI-D to female 15-pin DE-15 D-SUB. That's right, DVI-D to VGA!
Now I know how these DVI-I to VGA adapters work. I know they don't convert digital to analog or anything of the sorts. They require the analog video to be passed through the extra pins in the DVI-I connector. So I look at these things and right away think WTF? These wont work!
So my boss (who doesn't understand these things) says are you sure? Why would they make this? Why would they send us this? It must work! Go try it! So of course I try it showing him every possible combination I could think of. DVI-D from onboard to a VGA monitor, DVI-I from a video card to a VGA monitor. My boss says, hrm. What about going the other way? From VGA on a video card to DVI on a monitor? Once again I know it wont work but I show him anyway. Pluging the adapter in the female DVI port on a monitor and running the VGA from the same video card. Of course as I suspected. Nothing works.
Now here's the crazy part. Our supplier swears they work. "They work on everything we try here" and "We sold like 5,000 of these to people" they say!
BULLSHIT!
So we sent them back and said they didn't work and that we wanted a credit for them and they end up sending us two more back instead. Sheesh.
But now why do these adapters even exist? I repeat male DVI-D on one side and female VGA on the other side. Looks just like the typical DVI-I to VGA adapter that comes with your video card. But without the extra 4 pins that make DVI-I, DVI-I!
This adapter must exist for some reason? There must be some odd application where it actually works? But I can't figure out what that would be!