Tuesday, December 6th 2011

Cornered Indian Ruling Party Proposes Internet and Social Media Censorship à-la China

India's United Progressive Alliance government is mulling censorship of the internet à-la China, to filter out any content that speaks against members of the ruling party. India's multi-partisan democracy is increasingly making use of the web as a medium of political discourse and exchange, something that only works to make voters more informed. Union minister of IT and Telecommunications Kapil Sibal kicked off a storm this week when he announced that he is in talks with representatives of search engines and social networking websites, Google, Facebook, Twitter, Yahoo, and Microsoft to work out a censorship model that filters content that "unfairly maligns" the government. Apart from anti-government content, the government is concerned about hateful or "blasphemous" content, which could disturb communal harmony. "Some of the content which is being carried is blasphemous. This can hurt religious sentiments and it has to be removed," Sibal said.

Google, fresh out of a censorship and GMail espionage tussle with China, stated that it will not remove any content from its search results that are legal, merely on grounds of being "controversial". "We work really hard to both follow the law and also give people as much access to information as we can. So we follow the law when it comes to illegal content. And even where content is legal but breaks our own terms and conditions we take that down too, once we've been notified about it," said Google in a statement. "When content is legal but controversial we don't remove it because people's differing views should be respected, so long as they are legal."
Facebook, on the other hand, sounded more cooperative about Sibal's plan. "[Facebook] will remove any content that violates our terms, which are designed to keep material that is hateful, threatening, incites violence or contains nudity off the service," it stated. Facebook said it recognises the government's interest in minimising the amount of abusive content that is available online and will continue to engage with the Indian authorities as they debate on the issue. Opposition parties slammed the government. The current United Progressive Alliance government finds itself cornered with allegations of corruption spanning across various ministries.
Source: New York Times
Add your own comment

40 Comments on Cornered Indian Ruling Party Proposes Internet and Social Media Censorship à-la China

#27
DannibusX
Bad news. Freedom of speech is an absolute right, not just from an American perspective (where it's written down and "guaranteed"). The internet revolutionized the way people communicate and interact throughout the world. Maybe the Indian government is scared of what they're seeing happen in the Middle East with the Spring movements, I don't know.

Limiting the freedom of thought and speech is wrong, no matter what nation is attempting to do it. Hell, even the Westboro Church has every right to protest military funerals in the US, and what they say is complete and utter bullshit.

I haven't heard anything about this in the American media. Thanks for enlightening me, bta.
Posted on Reply
#28
Yukikaze
There is no such thing as an "absolute right". There are only the rights the governments (and government collectives) grant humans. If humans do not stand up for their "natural human rights", they will quickly cease being so natural.
Posted on Reply
#29
DannibusX
YukikazeThere is no such thing as an "absolute right". There are only the rights the governments (and government collectives) grant humans. If humans do not stand up for their "natural human rights", they will quickly cease being so natural.
You obviously don't live in America.

Thanks for visiting!
Posted on Reply
#30
Yukikaze
DannibusXYou obviously don't live in America.

Thanks for visiting!
No, I do not. However, your point is?
Posted on Reply
#31
btarunr
Editor & Senior Moderator
YukikazeThere is no such thing as an "absolute right".
Everyone knows there's no such thing as "absolute rights". This censorship code proposes to specifically censor content that's against members of the ruling party. It's not an "absolute rights" issue, it's a "basic rights" one. In democracy, flaming a screwed up politician is your basic right.
Posted on Reply
#32
btarunr
Editor & Senior Moderator
And to preempt a possible "but even that flaming isn't an absolute right" argument; everyone knows the kind of criticism that they can deliver at failing politicians, the quality of criticism, and the nature of the criticism.

Obviously the objection isn't about censorship of "Mr. Politician you're an arsewhole, I hate your face" content, it's about "Mr. Politician, you squandered away my tax money, I have proof, quit now" content. If Sibal gets his way, he will come up with a law that allows censorship of even genuine and valid democratic dissent.
Posted on Reply
#33
Yukikaze
btarunrEveryone knows there's no such thing as "absolute rights". This censorship code proposes to specifically censor content that's against members of the ruling party. It's not an "absolute rights" issue, it's a "basic rights" one. In democracy, flaming a screwed up politician is your basic right.
I'm on your side bta ;)
Posted on Reply
#34
WarraWarra
BT we support you and your freedom.
Just confirmed with several investors that was going to create roughly 22000 jobs and invest US$5B in India to boycott the Indian Gov. by not creating these jobs and not invest there until the Gov. stop their Arizona USA / Apartheid's South Africa behavior. These folks would inform their linked company's and friends to do the same.

Maybe the Indian people could beat some common sense into their Ruling party leaders.

Sorry for the jobless to suffer as a result of this. There is so many good people that now has to suffer because of this Apartheid's behavior by the Indian Gov. .
We will support India once they have a competent level headed government again, same goes for the USA as well.
Will see who else we can get to boycott Indian Gov. as well.

Wonder what Tata, Mahindra and Mital would do about this ?

God damn it this is 2012 almost and we still have to have this primitive Apartheid's behavior in governments on planet earth WTF ?
Posted on Reply
#35
ArchStupid
Thanks for editing the article.

I would like to apologize to btarunr for overreacting on my first post.
Didn't think at the time that my post was so drama-queen-esque.

I certainly will not read his posts with a grain of salt. :)
Posted on Reply
#36
NdMk2o1o
qubitYeah, why am I know surprised that corruption and censorship is spreading far and wide?
eh? it's always been this way, just so happens we live in the digital age where nothing goes by without us knowing.
Posted on Reply
#37
de.das.dude
Pro Indian Modder
wait what?


will they censor the p0rn??
Posted on Reply
#38
entropy13
India OKs censoring Facebook, Google, Microsoft, YouTube
The Indian government has given the green light for the prosecution of “21 social networking sites.” The list features 10 foreign-based companies, and could affect websites provided by Facebook, Google, Microsoft, Yahoo, and YouTube. The recent development is part of an ongoing argument between the companies and India over whether content should be regulated (read: censored) in the country. The approval was actually made on December 23, 2011, but was only revealed today.

Earlier this week, Delhi’s High Court warned various companies they will be blocked in India if they fail to check and censor content. When counsel for Facebook and Google pointed to their global policy of non-interference even if contents posted on their webpages are found to be obscene or objectionable, the court told the Internet firms that this policy won’t work in India. “Like China, we too can block such websites,” said Justice Suresh Kait.
Full article here.
Posted on Reply
#39
qubit
Overclocked quantum bit
The censorship cancer spreads
entropy13India OKs censoring Facebook, Google, Microsoft, YouTube



Full article here.
First China, now everyone else. :nutkick:

Thanks for posting this.
Posted on Reply
#40
de.das.dude
Pro Indian Modder
if they block sites, there'll be a fuckin revolt that sends our ass-brained politicians home :p
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
May 4th, 2024 14:09 EDT change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

Controversial News Posts