Monday, March 30th 2026

Crimson Desert Overtakes Pokémon Pokopia in Metacritic User Reviews

When Crimson Desert launched, its reviews—especially those from very early reviewers—were good, although less than stellar, however, the player retention figures painted a more positive picture. Now, it looks as though the reviews have caught up to those high early player counts, at least on Metacritic. As of the time of writing, the review aggregator site ranks Crimson Desert as the second highest-rated game of 2026 so far. With its 8.8 user score, Crimson Desert only trails Resident Evil Requiem, which has a strong lead, at 9.4 points. Following Crimson Desert are Pokémon Pokopia, with 8.5 points, Resident Evil Village Gold Edition, Resident Evil 7: Biohazard Gold Edition, and Cairn, with 8.5, 8.4, and 8.3 points respectively.

When it comes to the Metascore, however, Pokopia still holds onto its number-one spot, with 89 points, trailed by Resident Evil: Requiem, at 89 points, and Mewgenics, with a score of 88. Meanwhile, Crimson Desert has not yet been reviewed enough for an overall review score, but it currently has a PC Metascore of 77, which is based on very divided reviews, some giving it as low as 50 points, while others give it as much as 100 points. It's clear Crimson Desert will have a lot of competition in 2026, though, given what a packed year it is stacking up to be in the gaming industry. Aside from the already-launched hits like Resident Evil, Pokémon Pokopia, and Slay the Spire 2, massive launches like GTA VI, Pragmata, and Gears of War: E-Day are also slated to launch in 2026.
Source: Metacritic
Add your own comment

5 Comments on Crimson Desert Overtakes Pokémon Pokopia in Metacritic User Reviews

#1
Cheeseball
Not a Potato
HAH, the two games I'm currently playing. (aside from daily Terraria)
Posted on Reply
#2
cinemaware
Always fun to see a real world results valiantly defying the established online narrative. In this case, the game was supposed to be trash, because (allegedly) the story sucks. Well, what do you know, seems some people still like to play games for gameplay, and apparently this one has it in spades.
Posted on Reply
#3
Frick
Fishfaced Nincompoop
cinemawareAlways fun to see a real world results valiantly defying the established online narrative. In this case, the game was supposed to be trash, because (allegedly) the story sucks. Well, what do you know, seems some people still like to play games for gameplay, and apparently this one has it in spades.
Remember critcism is a profession, a profession with jargon and trends and all that. They have to stamp official "Good" or "Bad" judgements on what is fundementally subjective things, and they have deadlines and a limited time to play, and sometimes they only get to play review code. What I'm saying is "Good" or "Bad" has very little to do with whether or not people enjoy things, and people tend to confuse "I like it" with "Good". I like a ton of things people will explain to me are objectively bad. Sometimes what the reviewing professionals think is good will be the same as the normal players thing is good, but sometimes they disagree, but that doesn't matter. And I don't think a game getting mostly 7/10 reviews means it's getting trashed. A 7/10 is way more interesting than 9/10, to me anyway, because that usually means there are ... I like to think of it as sharp edges my mind can hold on to. If a game is too polished or streamlined I get bored (Horizon: Zero Dawn is a good example of this, without going off topic that game could have used some jank in it IMO).

And looking at metacritic, 8% of users gave this game a bad review, but only 1% of critics. So more users than critics properly trashed the game.

Anyway for me gamers loving this game makes me cautious. I was interested when the reviews coming in but The Gamers telling me they love something always gives me pause.
Posted on Reply
#4
Legacy-ZA
cinemawareAlways fun to see a real world results valiantly defying the established online narrative. In this case, the game was supposed to be trash, because (allegedly) the story sucks. Well, what do you know, seems some people still like to play games for gameplay, and apparently this one has it in spades.
You can have both, and they only delivered one. The criticism is valid.
Posted on Reply
#5
Vayra86
cinemawareAlways fun to see a real world results valiantly defying the established online narrative. In this case, the game was supposed to be trash, because (allegedly) the story sucks. Well, what do you know, seems some people still like to play games for gameplay, and apparently this one has it in spades.
Yep... just plain theme park farming, open world Skyrimification simply works.

The demands in the gaming space are super diverse. There is also a major segment in the audience that really jumps on story driven content over anything else... and a much bigger segment that just loves to farm and enjoy solid mechanics. The latter is often underestimated in todays gaming space, because corporate barely grasps this concept. They only see farming as a cash cow, a vehicle to drop dark pattern-infested bullshit on you to keep you playing. But the best farms don't feel like you're in that clusterfuck. They feel like they just want to keep on giving, and that's what keeps people playing.

World of Warcraft and the dozens of pretty great Korean farm games have explored this concept best.
Posted on Reply
Nov 20th, 2026 20:26 PST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts