• Welcome to TechPowerUp Forums, Guest! Please check out our forum guidelines for info related to our community.

Metacritic Spammed With Fake Positive Reviews of Assassin's Creed Origins

Raevenlord

News Editor
Joined
Aug 12, 2016
Messages
3,755 (1.18/day)
Location
Portugal
System Name The Ryzening
Processor AMD Ryzen 9 5900X
Motherboard MSI X570 MAG TOMAHAWK
Cooling Lian Li Galahad 360mm AIO
Memory 32 GB G.Skill Trident Z F4-3733 (4x 8 GB)
Video Card(s) Gigabyte RTX 3070 Ti
Storage Boot: Transcend MTE220S 2TB, Kintson A2000 1TB, Seagate Firewolf Pro 14 TB
Display(s) Acer Nitro VG270UP (1440p 144 Hz IPS)
Case Lian Li O11DX Dynamic White
Audio Device(s) iFi Audio Zen DAC
Power Supply Seasonic Focus+ 750 W
Mouse Cooler Master Masterkeys Lite L
Keyboard Cooler Master Masterkeys Lite L
Software Windows 10 x64
Metacritic has been invaded by a veritable flood of what appear to be semi-sentient robots, spamming the website with favorable Assassin's Creed Origins reviews. This isn't a common occurrence, but isn't unheard of either - there have been a number of scandals regarding fake reviews on Metacritic and other review score aggregators, with some publishers having even been brought to the center of the discussion.

The semi-sentient part derives from the fact that usernames are obviously a mashing-up of keyboard keys, and no amount of effort has been put towards hiding the fact that these are fake scores. The wording is practically the same, as sometimes even the English in these is of dubious quality. This type of actions usually hurt more a games' reception than help it, if done badly, as these reviews are. So if the idea is to improves Assassin's Creed Origins in the eyes of potential buyers, certainly the fact that these are clearly fake reviews will affect perception negatively. This reminds this editor of those Chinese review farms that were reported some time ago, where entire companies were created that devoted employees towards simply posting positive reviews for apps and programs, while being paid to do so.





"It's not a frequent occurrence - maybe 2 - 3 games a year," Metacritic co-founder Marc Doyle told Kotaku. "We've been moderating those reviews (and suspending those accounts - most off of which [sic] had one single review in their history). The people doing it appear to be changing it up with the chunk of text they keep replicating, but our moderators are working overtime to combat it."



Some user reviews on Metacritic said it best, though: "Ways better than assassins creed unity and assassins creed syndicate, it is more mature and bayek is interseting character, and de historical characters are handeld well."

View at TechPowerUp Main Site
 
Esnprzs.png
 
Just don't buy Ubisoft games. Ubisoft games are bad, m'kay?
 
The next thing you know, Ubi will blame russian hackers... :laugh:
 
So not only do they make crappy optimized games and cpu strangeling drm.

Now they also make fake reveiws.

How low are ubisoft willing to go, for selling there crap.

Ubisoft sucks.
 
Far Cry (original) was good. The rest was just endless milking of the franchise. Just like pretty much everything under Ubisoft's belt. Their cookie cutter milking model is even worse than EA's was when they were slamming year numbers on games every single year...
 
Far Cry (original) was good. The rest was just endless milking of the franchise. Just like pretty much everything under Ubisoft's belt. Their cookie cutter milking model is even worse than EA's was when they were slamming year numbers on games every single year...

Well, AC Black Flag was pretty different. So much so that many AC fanatics feel it isn't really even an AC game, just a really good pirate game.
 
Silent Hunter was the only good thing Ubisoft ever did.

They also killed it, so it's a neutral point at best.
 
Silent Hunter was the only good thing Ubisoft ever did.

They also killed it, so it's a neutral point at best.
I actually think that the games made by Michel Ancel are among the best games that were made.
Rayman , (the 3 was insane) beyond good and evil... rayman and the raving rabbids wasn't made by him, he was only a character designer, that was just Ubisoft trying to milk the franchise, but then Rayman went back to greatness with Rayman origin (made by him) who also happened to be DRM free.
 
I wonder why Ubi would resort to this. It seems beneath them.

Or am I giving them too much credit? lol
 
definitly russia...

covfefe
 
Why not just shut off the voting system for the game completely and give it a pathetic rating since its being clearly funded by Shittysoft themselves?
 
Remember Failcry 2 that as fake-rated 9/10 while being worth at most 4 ? You know....the no AI no story no action buggy one with sucky sound enemies shooting backwards, useless road trips etc...
 
I actually think that the games made by Michel Ancel are among the best games that were made.
Rayman , (the 3 was insane) beyond good and evil... rayman and the raving rabbids wasn't made by him, he was only a character designer, that was just Ubisoft trying to milk the franchise, but then Rayman went back to greatness with Rayman origin (made by him) who also happened to be DRM free.

I was speaking more of the modern "corperate Ubisoft" from the Uplay and forward era.

In it's earlier years, Ubisoft had some moments.
 
2017 and these people cannot even think of some anti-bot registration and posting. GEEZUS.
 
Hmmm... But I do like the Far Cry series...:oops:

It's getting there slooooowly,like come on they know how to make a good popular game "COUGH Ghost Recon" but they don't want to do some thing so open to the public.

They don't want you to be able to make maps and complex missions as that don't make them money.

Well, AC Black Flag was pretty different. So much so that many AC fanatics feel it isn't really even an AC game, just a really good pirate game.

Black Flag after the updates was awesome, well then they spoiled the experience with that add on content which had no were the attention and love.
 
And a streamer on Twitch claims this crap is better than Witcher 3. Perhaps try playing W3 first?
 
Well, AC Black Flag was pretty different. So much so that many AC fanatics feel it isn't really even an AC game, just a really good pirate game.
Yeah it was the best of the games, funny that the worst part of ACBF was doing the eponymous assassin crap.
 
Confused... I didn't see anywhere that Ubi was behind this...

Did I miss something or is everyone piling on the lemming train of unsubstantiated hate?

The odds of Ubi behind behind it are slim to none. Considering the sheer money publishers spend on marketing, they'd probably pay native english speakers to post fake reviews and/or hire YouTubers/Streamers to give positive reviews (the latter they already have been doing for years). People just hate Ubisoft so much (and with fair reasoning) that they're attributing dodgy practice to them.

They could pay PewDiePie a few hundred thousand and that would probably net them more guaranteed sales than using some backwater Chinese/Russian fake review botnet.

EDIT: I'd go as far to say as this is purposefully being done to bring the game/publisher into a negative light. Astroturfing a bunch of blatantly fake positive reviews is a great way to bring Ubi's and AssCreed's image down.
 
Last edited:
This shit is the reason i dont go by what other people have to say about a game or a movie because primarily, they dont speak for me. I play what looks good and not base what I wanna do, play, or watch off of what someone else thinks. Thats being a sheep. I have a mind for myself.
 
Playing right now and i like it. It's has good twist in the series, more like an action RPG. No problem running it at 1080p on ultra settings.
 
The odds of Ubi behind behind it are slim to none. Considering the sheer money publishers spend on marketing, they'd probably pay native english speakers to post fake reviews and/or hire YouTubers/Streamers to give positive reviews (the latter they already have been doing for years). People just hate Ubisoft so much (and with fair reasoning) that they're attributing dodgy practice to them.

They could pay PewDiePie a few hundred thousand and that would probably net them more guaranteed sales than using some backwater Chinese/Russian fake review botnet.

EDIT: I'd go as far to say as this is purposefully being done to bring the game/publisher into a negative light. Astroturfing a bunch of blatantly fake positive reviews is a great way to bring Ubi's and AssCreed's image down.
:toast:
My thoughts exactly.
 
Back
Top