Quick true story (in game lol) I was running from zombies and ended up gathering like 7 of em. I saw a dude running just in front of me and thought he could help me out. I hid in a building to try and lose the zombies which seemed to work but it only worked because the zombies ended up switching aggro on the dude. So I'm waiting inside the post office for a bit as I hear lots of zombies outside but can't actually see anything. Then out of nowhere the dude walks in there bringing the whole lot with him! We both hide behind the the bench in the post office and since the zombies can't jump were safe but trapped. Freshly spawned, armed with nothing but my new found friend's flashlight and bleeding all over the place I tell the dude to try and kill a few with the flashlight. He starts bashing away a bit never actually responding to anything I say. I then ask him if he wants to give me the flashlight so I can try? He doesn't say anything. After a short while of not getting anywhere, he too begins to bleed. He then walks over to me, stares at me for a few seconds and gives me one good wack with the flashlight. I die. The situation never quite works out the way you think it will lol. Ultimately if you can wait, then wait. Otherwise there are plenty of varying views, screenshots and videos of both to come to some sort of quick decisions yourself but otherwise you probably should find both equally satisfying. You could get annoyed by player induced deaths on either as the sheer act of dying by some other dude is just "ARGGHHHH!" enraging. Could simply be a matter of what you end up playing first. Depends on how you as a person see things. Again I must emphasize on how neither one is complete by any means. Its just a rough sketch out of the concepts right now.