It's often the case that Mini-ITX motherboards are a very personal choice, linking features with your specific needs, this makes sense seeing as there's far more variation in those features and layouts than other motherboard sizes. It's often been the case that ASRock undercuts the competition, but probably the biggest issue the ASRock Phantom Gaming B860I Lightning Wi-Fi faces is the fact that ASUS and Gigabyte B860 options are the same price.
As we've seen elsewhere, they both offer better EFIs and are arguably better-looking than the Phantom Gaming B860I Lighting Wi-Fi too. More critically is that both include Wi-Fi 7, which the ASRock board lacks. The rest is a tit-for-tat exchange of features. The ASRock board has Realtek ALC1220 audio as does the ASUS board, but the Gigabyte dips down to ALC897. The ASUS board has a paltry 1 A/12 W per fan header, Gigabyte offers up to 2 A/24 W per fan header, while the ASRock has a peak of 3 A/36 W available on its AIO pump header.
The Gigabyte board also has the least SATA ports at just two, ASRock offers three and ASUS four, while USB Type-A port count on the rear I/O panel sees ASRock with the advantage at seven, ASUS with six and Gigabyte offering just five. Both ASUS and ASRock boards have thermistor sensors, the Gigabyte does not. All three boards have Thunderbolt/USB4 Type-C ports and USB 3.2 Gen 2 Type-C front panel headers, but the ASUS board has an additional USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 Type-C port on the rear I/O panel.
The ASUS board also has a CMOS clear button on the rear I/O panel, but lacks USB BIOS Flashback, which could be an issue if you're picking the board up used in future as it may lack next generation CPU support. If you're worried about VRM temperatures then the ASRock Phantom Gaming B860I Lightning Wi-Fi's VRM cooling fan potentially gives it an edge, although we can't say for sure not having tested the other two boards, which means we can't comment further than specifications either. It's also worth noting that MSI will be releasing additional Mini-ITX boards in the near future.
If you'll be using a Core Ultra 7 or Ultra 5 CPU, then it's also worth considering the ASRock B860I Wi-Fi, which is $60 cheaper. Of course, it ditches power phases, ALC1220 audio and Thunderbolt 4 to get there, but if you just want an affordable LGA1851 Mini-ITX board then it will save a decent amount of cash compared to the three other options discussed above.
Overall, there are a few reasons to consider the ASRock Phantom Gaming B860I Lightning Wi-Fi over the identically-priced competition, such as more powerful fan headers, more USB ports, active VRM cooling and the inclusion of USB BIOS Flashback as well as ALC1220 audio, and even a thermistor header.
The Lightning Wi-Fi is maybe the more balanced of the three $220 B860 Mini-ITX boards we've mentioned, but with caveats, including that it will struggle to cool PCIe Gen 5 SSDs under heavy workloads, the EFI isn't as appealing, and we'd argue the board itself is not as good-looking either. Other than those issues it's a solid Mini-ITX option for Intel users that aren't looking to overclock.