Intel's first attempt at non-monolithic disaggregated desktop CPUs with the LGA 1851 platform hasn't quite gone to plan. Nevertheless, besides reducing the price of its CPUs, releasing a steady stream of performance updates and even new features such as the 200S Boost option, Intel is bringing Arrow Lake closer to where it should have been at launch. If you are interested in owning Intel's latest consumer platform, then the next question should be whether you want to overclock or not, given you'll need the Z890 chipset for that, if the answer is yes, then ASRock's Phantom Gaming Z890 Riptide Wi-Fi is definitely worthy of consideration.
If you aren't overclocking then there are much cheaper and arguably better suited options available that use the B860 chipset, such as ASRock's own B860 Steel Legend Wi-Fi, MSI's MAG B860 Tomahawk Wi-Fi or Colorful's iGame B860M Ultra V20. Given there's $100 or more to be saved here with minimal compromises in other areas, that cash can be put to much better use elsewhere, especially as the ASRock B860 Steel Legend Wi-Fi in particular has an otherwise similar specification—even with extras such as RGB lighting—for a much lower price tag.
The solid credentials offered for a potential Z890 motherboard owner are compelling. However, before we discuss the positives, let's consider the negatives. The VRM temperatures we've seen are a little higher than we're used to. While there's still headroom for overclocking, there's clearly more on other LGA1851 boards, such as the similarly-priced ASUS TUF Gaming Z890-Pro Wi-Fi, while the MSI MAG Z890 Tomahawk Wi-Fi offers even lower VRM temperatures.
The MSI Tomahawk board also has 5 Gbps Ethernet compared to 2.5 Gbps and—like the ASUS TUF Gaming Z890-Pro Wi-Fi—a much better EFI than the ASRock, which feels dated, not as well laid out and simply lacking in some areas. While it has USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 support for its Type-C front panel port that can dish out some crazy speeds with the latest portable SSDs, it lacks any enhanced power delivery to charge your smartphone faster for example.
Apart from these far from deal-breaking niggles, ASRock continues its strong streak of offering premium features and performance for a competitive price tag. Its M.2 temperatures were exceptional, and it easily tamed our toasty PCIe Gen 5 SSD when all the aforementioned options besides the ASRock B860 Steel Legend Wi-Fi failed to do so. All the M.2 heatsinks are tool-free, but many of those other boards lack their own RGB lighting, while the Phantom Gaming Z890 Riptide Wi-Fi ticks that box.
ASRock offers a well-balanced specification elsewhere too. There are plenty of fan headers and even a 2-pin thermistor header with a probe included in the box. The eight Type-A USB ports on the rear panel is a decent number plus there's more high-speed ports here in both USB 3.2 Gen 2 and USB 3.0 flavors than most of the previously mentioned alternatives. That's in addition to two versatile and high bandwidth Thunderbolt 4 ports.
If you have a bit of extra money to spend, you might consider something more premium. For example, ASRock's Z890 Taichi Lite is an option. It costs about $60 more. Here you get more head-turning aesthetics, faster Ethernet, more premium features such as an audio DAC, power and reset buttons along with additional USB ports and power phases. Overall, spending more here is less necessary than it would be for an option in the $200 price range. For example, the ASRock Z890 Pro-A lacks Wi-Fi, Thunderbolt 4, has fewer power phases and inferior audio as well as heatsinks that will struggle to cool toasty PCIE Gen 5 SSDs and the VRMs under sustained load.
Current pricing has seen the excellent MSI MAG Z890 Tomahawk Wi-Fi rocket up to over $330, but the ASUS TUF Gaming Z890-Pro Wi-Fi can be had for less than $270. With PCIe Gen 5 SSDs still representing a premium, the fact the ASUS board fared worse in cooling is something of a moot point, and combined with a much better EFI and software suite as well as 30 W power delivery over its front panel Type-C port and cooler-running VRMs, the ASUS TUF edges the ASRock board slightly overall. Still, we're happy to recommend the ASRock Phantom Gaming Z890 Riptide Wi-Fi as a strong overall contender in its own right.