The ASUS ROG Crosshair X870E Extreme sits at the top of the company's current lineup of Socket AM5 boards, offering all the benefits of X870E, with a mountain of features besides. As we said at the start though, while it's easy to get starry eyed here, more than half of the asking price is spent on features that will in no way offer extra performance for the average user. Even if you have custom watercooling and dabble in a bit of manual overclocking, there is essentially nothing here that in a daily driver setup will get you higher frame rates or better content creation performance.
What the ASUS ROG Crosshair X870E Extreme does offer is a mix of extreme overclocking tools paired with one of the most lavishly-equipped daily driver boards on the motherboard market. If you won't be needing those tools, though, and liquid nitrogen is something from James Bond films and YouTube videos rather than an overclocking aid, then the ROG Crosshair X870E Hero is $350 cheaper and still packs a punch, albeit without one or two headliners such as inbuilt 10 Gbps Ethernet.
Reiterating what we said at the start of this review, you shouldn't prioritize your motherboard budget over the rest of your hardware. Even if you can justify spending a little more for the likes of USB4, Wi-Fi 7, PCIe Gen 5 SSD and GPU support, and perhaps beefed-up power delivery over your case's front panel Type-C port to fast-charge your smartphone or even charge your laptop, these can usually be had for a lot less than $999.
What we have here is a flagship that will likely not leave you wanting in any department, whether its accessories, features, cooling, aesthetics or I/O. Has ASUS done enough with the ROG Crosshair X870E Extreme to make it jump out at those with wallets fat enough to make carrying them around uncomfortable? Well, the 5-inch LCD screen is certainly a head-turner, plus the extra width of its E-ATX dimensions means that the DIMM.2 module returns and with it excellent M.2 SSD temperatures and easy SSD access. We also have dual high speed Ethernet ports and right-angled connectors, shrouds and backplates, all doing their job to boost this halo motherboard's aesthetics and cooling.
Previous examples as well as current options from the competition have opted for out-of-the-box watercooling, but for a board focusing on extreme overclocking, that's maybe pointing things in the wrong direction. The screen certainly shouts flagship and the addition of the exclusive ASUS DIMM.2 module are both eye-catchers, but apart from 10 Gbps Ethernet and three PCIe Gen 5 M.2 ports, is there really enough here to justify that $999 asking price?
Features you might feel are missing are a complete set of tool-free M.2 heatsinks, and that bottom heatsink not only requires you to remove your graphics card to get at it too, but also blocks one of the motherboard mounting holes. The VRM fan is also a little pointless as it didn't do much, seeming more like an afterthought. Apart from the screen there isn't really much new here either other than the 6-pin ARGB header to cut the number of cables. But that's something the competition goes a little further with, such as the MSI MEG X870E Godlike with its EZ Link port.
The MSI Godlike combines a variety of headers into one cable using a hub. All of its M.2 heatsinks are tool-free, and instead of DIMM.2 it has a PCIe expansion card with dual PCIe Gen 5 M.2 ports and a fan-assisted heatsink. It's rear I/O panel looks even more extreme than the ASUS board too, and it's a close match elsewhere, besides support for extreme sub-ambient overclocking. Gigabyte's X870E Aorus Xtreme AI TOP is another alternative, certainly getting first place in the snazzy category as well as offering dual 10 Gbps Ethernet, but again lacks the range of extreme overclocking features.
The MSI Godlike gives this ASUS board the best run for the money and is perhaps more balanced if you're not into extreme overclocking. Unlike the ASUS board, it sticks to being consistently premium across the PCB, with greater attention being paid to tool-free features and cable tidying. The end result is that picking the best option from these will likely depend more on brand loyalty as well as whether you need those extreme overclocking features. But apart from the shock of needing a screwdriver for one of its M.2 heatsinks and its software being a tad flaky (please fix this ASAP ASUS), the ASUS ROG Crosshair X870E Extreme certainly lives up to its name, and we doubt anyone that's lucky enough to comfortably afford one would be disappointed.