- The Gigabyte B850I Aorus Pro is currently listed online for $260
- Tool-free M.2 port
- GPU release button
- Active M.2 SSD cooling
- Additional M.2 thermal pads
- Single-piece screwless Wi-Fi connector
- Simple and effective software
- PCIe Gen 5 GPU and M.2 support
- Disappointing VRM temperatures
- M.2 heatsink fascia massively restricts airflow
- M.2 fan intrusively loud
- Out of the box configuration unable to tame PCIe Gen 5 SSDs
- No USB4
- Other USB ports limited to 3.2 Gen 2 10 Gbps
- No optical audio output
- Optional backside SSD thermal pad pointless in most Mini-ITX cases
- Uninspiring features
- Less desirable than its predecessor
At $260, the Gigabyte B850I Aorus Pro's main competition comes from the MSI MPG B850I Edge TI Wi-Fi which costs about the same, Gigabyte's own X870I Aorus Pro Ice at around $25 more, and also from ASRock's B850I Lightning Wi-Fi with it's reduced specification saving around $50. For some reason the excellent ASUS ROG Strix B850-I Gaming Wi-Fi has shot up in price recently to $350, and apart from dual PCIe Gen 5 M.2 ports and one or two other features, the extra cash means it's somewhat out of contention here, but we'll look at it in more detail in a minute.
Another interesting comparison is between this board and its predecessor, the B650I Aorus Ultra. If anything the new kid on the block is something of a let-down given that board had a far more elaborate cooling array as well as a unique Mini-ITX selling point of offering three M.2 ports—two Gen 4 and one Gen 5, and one of those was passively cooled by the backplate, too. We also got a USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 20 Gbps Type-C header and double the number of SATA ports. Apart from Wi-Fi 7 the B850I Aorus Pro feels like a definite downgrade, and the predecessor board is still available for less than $220.
Moving on to the negatives here and our revision 1.1 of the board paired with the latest EFI resulted in that M.2 heatsink fan making way too much noise. This was especially true with a PCIe Gen 5 SSD planted in there, as the fan input PCH temperature rarely saw the fan rpm drop below 10,000 rpm. The situation was better with a PCIe Gen 4 SSD, but under sustained sequential workloads the noise was still intrusive.
Of course the real issue here isn't the heatsink size and while the fan is smaller and therefore louder than the one used in the MSI MPG B850I Edge TI Wi-Fi, removing the top fascia and actually allowing the fan to breathe drastically improves temperatures. Again, this board's predecessor also had a fascia here, but this included a vent above the fan. Thankfully, exposing the fan is easy to do and does not damage the fascia, should you want to replace it later.
Once removed you simply set a fixed low RPM or just prevent the fan exceeding 7,000 rpm, and you'll see noise levels reduced to near silence against the ambient background noise. If you're using a Gen 4 SSD then you don't need the fan on at all. The VRM temperatures are also on the high side, but seeing as these were a fair way from being concerning or resulting in performance issues, we can't be too critical, although we'd avoid manual overclocks with 16-core CPUs.
MSI is very late to the party with its AMD 800-series chipset Mini-ITX boards, but the MPG B850I Edge TI Wi-Fi impressed us for a few reasons. It's M.2 fan is larger and quieter than the one on the Gigabyte B850I Aorus Pro, and can be configured to offer excellent M.2 cooling with zero noise, while MSI's EFI is generally a lot more modern than Gigabyte's, plus its VRM temperatures were lower too. It has an extra fan header plus USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 20 Gbps Type-C on the rear panel, while this Gigabyte board is limited to 10 Gbps. The MSI board also has some useful accessories for Mini-ITX case owners.
ASRock on the other hand will save you around $50, and still had cooler VRMs, easily handling our Ryzen 9 9950X, besides including a thermistor probe header and still offering PCIe Gen 5 M.2 and GPU support. However, you do lose Wi-Fi 7, USB 3.2 Gen 2 10 Gbps is as fast as things get, and the front panel Type-C header is only USB 3.0. It's fanless heatsink also failed to deal adequately with our PCIe Gen 5 SSD, but if you're happy with an older Wi-Fi standard and will be using PCIe Gen 4 SSDs, then it's good value compared to the Gigabyte B850I Aorus Pro.
If you're looking for a white motherboard, then Gigabyte's X870I Aorus Pro Ice is the whitest you'll find and thankfully, Gigabyte has seen sense and not slapped a massive premium on it due to its X870 chipset. Instead, it costs just $20 more currently, which is just as well as apart from USB4 and its white theme, there's very little more on offer.
Overall, once you rip off the M.2 heatsink fascia and tweak the fan speed, there's not much wrong here other than some slightly toasty VRMs if you end up pushing a 16-core CPU to its limits for a good 20 to 30 minutes. For Gigabyte fans, though, this feels like a backward step compared to it's compelling B650 predecessor, while MSI has a slightly better current-gen package in the MPG B850I Edge TI Wi-Fi, and ASRock has something much cheaper but lower-specced.
It's a shame that ASUS has somewhat priced itself out of contention, as the now $350 ROG Strix B850-I Gaming Wi-Fi is a great board, but right now, if you have about $250 to spend on an AMD Mini-ITX motherboard our money would go to MSI, or if you can handle slightly older tech and want three M.2 ports for less cash, the Gigabyte B650I Aorus Ultra. MSI is hopefully releasing its X870 option soon too, so we'd suggest holding off until we know its pricing.