Silicon Motion SM2504 XT Engineering Sample Review - Efficiency Record 22

Silicon Motion SM2504 XT Engineering Sample Review - Efficiency Record

(22 Comments) »

Introduction

Silicon Motion Logo

Silicon Motion is a leading global supplier of NAND flash controllers for solid-state storage devices. The company designs high-performance, power-efficient controllers used in SSDs, eMMC, and UFS solutions for many storage manufacturers. Most recently, they've expanded into the consumer PCIe Gen 5 controller market, to challenge Phison's dominance.



In the past months we've seen several drives released on the SMI SM2508 controller, which offers outstanding performance that rivals or beats that of the market-leading Phison E26 controller—but with much lower power consumption. That means less heat, which makes it much easier to cool these drives. Popular examples of drives using the SM2508 are Crucial T710, WD SN8100, Kingston Fury Renegade G5, Lexar NM1090 Pro, ADATA Mars 980 Blade and Acer Predator GM9000.

Earlier this year, at Computex, Silicon Motion announced that they are working on a new controller called SM2504, which is a more cost-optimized model with support for DRAM-less operation and even better energy efficiency, that is still able to offer excellent performance. I was fortunate to receive a sample of the SM2504 for this preview article. Please note, this is not the final product, so some changes are to be expected. Still, the results are highly impressive and should put pressure on Phison, who's E31 controller is the direct competitor to SM2504.

Specs like endurance and pricing are unknown at this time, but I think it's quite certain that we'll see capacities of 1 TB and 2 TB for the SM2504, possibly 4 TB as well. In the Performance per Dollar and Price per TB charts I used a theoretical price point of $180, so we can get a feel for where the drive has to end up to be competitive.

Specifications: Silicon Motion SM2504 Engineering Sample 2 TB SSD
Brand:Silicon Motion
Model:SM2504-ES
Capacity:2000 GB (1862 GB usable)
48 GB additional overprovisioning
Controller:Silicon Motion SM2504XT
Flash:TLC, 200+ layers, Unknown (SMI requested not to publish)
DRAM:N/A, but 64 MB HMB
Endurance:TBD
Form Factor:M.2 2280
Interface:PCIe Gen 5 x4, NVMe 2.0
Device ID:2504
Firmware:Y0819A00
Warranty:TBD, No reason it won't be 5 years
Price at Time
of Review:
TBD

The Drive

SSD Front
SSD Back

The drive is designed for the M.2 2280 form factor, which makes it 22 mm wide and 80 mm long.

SSD Interface Connector

PCI-Express 5.0 x4 is used as the host interface to the rest of the system, which doubles the theoretical bandwidth compared to PCIe 4.0 x4.

SSD Teardown PCB Front
SSD Teardown PCB Back

On the PCB you'll find the controller and two flash chips.


One very interesting discovery I made is that the SM2504 controller is very thin. This means that it doesn't have the same height as the NAND flash chip that sits right next to it. For a heatsink with a flat base, like most of them, this means it won't make contact with the controller.


I solved this by folding a thermal pad a couple of layers high, thick enough to ensure contact with the heatsink base, around 0.3 mm or so. This is definitely not optimal, because heat has to travel through a lot of material before it reaches the heatsink.

Chip Component Analysis

SSD Controller

The Silicon Motion SM2504 is a four-channel PCI-Express 5.0 controller with support for DRAM-less operation and NVMe 2.0. It is fabricated on a 6 nm TSMC production process, same as the SM2508. SM2504 supports both TLC and QLC NAND.

SSD Flash Chips

SMI requested to not share too many details about the flash chips, I photoshopped out any markings. The chips are modern TLC with more than 200 layers, but nothing secret or unreleased.

Test Setup

Test System SSD 2024
Processor:Intel Core i9-13900KS
Raptor Lake
6.0 GHz, 8+16 cores / 32 threads
Motherboard:ASUS ROG Z790 Dark Hero
BIOS 1102
Memory:2x 16 GB DDR5-6000
Graphics:Zotac GeForce RTX 5070 Solid
Cooling:Valkyrie Syn 360 mm AIO
Thermal Paste:Arctic MX-6
Power Supply:Thermaltake Toughpower GF3 850 W
ATX 3.0 / 16-pin 12VHPWR
Case:darkFlash DRX70 White
Operating System:Windows 11 Professional 64-bit 23H2
VBS enabled (Windows 11 default)
Drivers:NVIDIA: 552.12 WHQL



Synthetic Testing

  • Tests are run with a 20-second-long warm-up time (result recording starts at second 21)
  • Between each test, the drive is left idle for 60 seconds, to allow it to flush and reorganize its internal data
  • All write requests contain random, incompressible data
  • Disk cache is flushed between all tests
  • During these tests, M.2 drives are tested with additional active fan-cooling, to ensure thermal throttling can't happen

Real-life Testing

  • After initial configuration and installation, a disk image is created; it is used to test every drive
  • Automated updates are disabled for the OS and all programs. This ensures that—for every review—each drive uses the same settings, without interference from previous testing
  • Our disk image consumes around 700 GB—partitions are resized to fill all available space on the drive
  • All drives are filled with random data to 85% of their capacity. This is intentional, to run the drive in realistic operating conditions—nobody uses a nearly-empty SSD in their system. It also puts additional stress on the pseudo-SLC cache subsystem, because there is less free NAND space to work with
  • Partitions are aligned properly
  • Disk cache is flushed between all tests
  • In order to minimize random variation, each real-life performance test is run several times, with reboots between tests to minimize the impact of disk cache
  • All application benchmarks run the actual application and do not replay any disk traces
  • Our real-life testing data includes performance numbers for a typical high-performance HDD, using results from a Western Digital WD Black 1 TB 7200 RPM 3.5" SATA
  • HDDs are significantly slower than SSDs, which is why we're not putting the result in the chart, as that would break the scaling, making the SSDs indistinguishable in comparison. Instead, we've added the HDD performance numbers in the title of each test entry
  • During these tests, M.2 drives are tested with additional active fan-cooling, to ensure thermal throttling can't happen

Comparison Drives

We compare the tested drive to a wide selection of SSDs currently available on the market. Besides popular drives, our focus is also on including common controller and flash type combinations.

TechPowerUp SSD Review Test Group
 ControllerChannelsFlashDRAMInterface
ADATA SX8200 Pro 1 TBSilicon Motion SM2262ENG8TLC / MicronYesPCIe 3.0 x4
Corsair MP400 2 TBPhison E12S8QLC / MicronYesPCIe 4.0 x4
Corsair MP600 Elite 2 TBPhison E274TLC / ToshibaNoPCIe 4.0 x4
Corsair MP700 Pro 2 TBPhison E268TLC / MicronYesPCIe 5.0 x4
Crucial BX500 1 TBSilicon Motion SM2258XT4TLC / MicronNoSATA
Crucial MX500 1 TBSilicon Motion SM2258H4TLC / MicronYesSATA
Crucial P1 1 TBSilicon Motion SM2263ENG8QLC / MicronYesPCIe 3.0 x4
Crucial P5 1 TBMicron DM01B28TLC / MicronYesPCIe 3.0 x4
Crucial P5 Plus 1 TBMicron DM02A18TLC / MicronYesPCIe 4.0 x4
Crucial T500 2 TBPhison E254TLC / MicronYesPCIe 4.0 x4
Crucial T710 2 TBSilicon Motion SM25088TLC / MicronYesPCIe 5.0 x4
Hynix Gold P31 2 TBHynix ACNT0388TLC / HynixYesPCIe 3.0 x4
Hynix P51 Platinum 2 TBHynix ACNT0938TLC / HynixYesPCIe 5.0 x4
Kingston Fury Renegade G5 2 TBSilicon Motion SM25088TLC / KioxiaYesPCIe 5.0 x4
Kingston KC3000 2 TBPhison E188TLC / MicronYesPCIe 4.0 x4
Kingston NV2 1 TBPhison E214TLC / ToshibaNoPCIe 4.0 x4
Kioxia Exceria Plus G4 2 TBPhison E314TLC / KioxiaNoPCIe 5.0 x4
Lexar NM710 2 2 TBMaxiotech MAP1602A4TLC / YMTCNoPCIe 4.0 x4
Lexar NM790 2 2 TBMaxiotech MAP1602A4TLC / YMTCNoPCIe 4.0 x4
MSI Spatium M450 1 TBPhison E194TLC / MicronNoPCIe 4.0 x4
Neo Forza NFP495 2 TBTenaFE TC22014TLC / YMTCNoPCIe 4.0 x4
Samsung 860 EVO 1 TBSamsung MJX8TLC / SamsungYesSATA
Samsung 870 QVO 1 TBSamsung MKX8QLC / SamsungYesSATA
Samsung 970 EVO Plus 1 TBSamsung Phoenix8TLC / SamsungYesPCIe 3.0 x4
Samsung 980 1 TBSamsung Pablo8TLC / SamsungYesPCIe 3.0 x4
Samsung 980 Pro 1 TBSamsung Elpis8TLC / SamsungYesPCIe 4.0 x4
Samsung 990 Pro 2 TBSamsung Pascal8TLC / SamsungYesPCIe 4.0 x4
Samsung 9100 Pro 2 TBSamsung Presto8TLC / SamsungYesPCIe 5.0 x4
Seagate Barracuda 120 1 TBPhison S128TLC / IntelYesSATA
Seagate FireCuda 510 1 TBPhison E128TLC / ToshibaYesPCIe 3.0 x4
Solidigm P44 Pro 2 TBSK hynix ACNS0758TLC / HynixYesPCIe 4.0 x4
WD Black SN5100 2 TBSandisk A101-0001034QLC / SandiskNoPCIe 4.0 x4
WD Black SN7100 2 TBSandisk A101-0001724TLC / SandiskNoPCIe 4.0 x4
WD Black SN8100 2 TBSilicon Motion SM25088TLC / SandiskYesPCIe 5.0 x4
WD Black SN770 1 TBSandisk 20-82-100814TLC / SandiskNoPCIe 4.0 x4
WD Black SN850 1 TBSandisk 20-82-100358TLC / SandiskYesPCIe 4.0 x4
WD Black SN850X 2 TBSandisk 20-82-20035-B28TLC / KioxiaYesPCIe 4.0 x4
WD Blue SN570 1 TBSandisk 20-82-100234TLC / SandiskNoPCIe 3.0 x4
WD Blue SN580 1 TBSandisk 20-82-100824TLC / SandiskNoPCIe 4.0 x4
XPG Atom 50 2 TBSilicon Motion SM22694TLC / MicronNoPCIe 4.0 x4
XPG Gammix S70 Blade 2 TBInnoGrit IG52368TLC / MicronYesPCIe 4.0 x4
Our Patreon Silver Supporters can read articles in single-page format.
Nov 22nd, 2026 13:42 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts