Alright, it is now time to get down to business. With all the testing and overclocking out of the way we can focus on the talking points that may persuade and dissuade people from purchasing this kit.
First and foremost, let's take care of the biggest question of whether this will be good for your CPU. Well, the answer is not a one fits all types of answer. Like peeling an onion, the first layer is the XMP profile of 4400 MT/s. Overall, I would say this is great for Intel platforms. Generally speaking, the higher the overall speed you can achieve, the better performance will be. A caveat to this recommendation is balancing what is considered safe for long-term use. It can take a good amount of voltage on the CPU memory controller to reach these higher frequencies.
In some instances, lower is actually better. The loss of overall bandwidth the CPU can access is often offset by lower primary timings. As discussed in the overclocking section, it also benefits AMD to keep the Infinity Fabric in sync. I have a hard time recommending this kit to AMD users simply because DDR4-3600 to DDR4-4000 is the ideal range for optimal performance.
That being said, if you have a motherboard that is compatible with some extreme frequencies, this XPG SPECTRIX D45G kit does not disappoint. I was able to achieve DDR4-5000 thanks to the SK-Hynix DJR ICs. I know overclocking and tinkering with memory is a sub-group inside general overclocking. If that is your hobby, this is a fun memory kit to play around with. However, I generally suggest buying kits at the frequency you want to run in the first place. Overclocking or tightening up the primary timings is just a bonus and not always a cheaper alternative.
Switching gears, having had the memory in hand shows that XPG has put thought and care into the design of this product. Not only does the heatspreader have a bit of weight, it has raised, angled stripes that improve heat dissipation. This little addition blurs the line between a heatspreader and heatsink. In either case, it benefits the memory. I think the matte black is a slightly boring look and lacks flare. It doesn't make for that pronounced "premium" look as something shiny might. This is my personal opinion, of course.
XPG does make up for the mediocre branding style with a clean RGB lighting setup. I could not easily discern where the individual LEDs are located. Usually, the locations can be seen from the sides or if the mixing of colors isn't synchronized correctly.
In conclusion, I would recommend the XPG SPECTRIX D45G DDR4-4400 2x 8 GB kit for Intel users since it is highly versatile. I also would recommend it to AMD owners if into overclocking or memory tweaking. For those strictly the plug and play type, a DDR4-3600 kit is a good alternative to avoid any complications that may arise with such high-frequency memory.
With a market in which hundreds of different configurations exists, sifting through the marketing and getting to the core of what is considered an ideal memory kit can be daunting. Unfortunately, no one answer fully answers the question. However, I can point people in the right direction with as much information as possible to make a correct decision. This SPECTRIX D45G kit gets my approval and is a prime example of how to create a good product even if it doesn't give off that premium vibe in every way.