• Welcome to TechPowerUp Forums, Guest! Please check out our forum guidelines for info related to our community.

The Case is Patent: Apple, Broadcom Ordered to Pay $1.1 billion to CalTech

Raevenlord

News Editor
Staff member
Joined
Aug 12, 2016
Messages
3,438 (2.07/day)
Location
Portugal
System Name The Ryzening
Processor AMD Ryzen 7 1700
Motherboard MSI X370 Gaming Pro Carbon
Cooling Arctic Cooling Liquid Freezer 120
Memory 16 GB G.Skill Trident Z F4-3200 (2x 8 GB)
Video Card(s) TPU's Awesome MSI GTX 1070 Gaming X
Storage Boot: Crucial MX100 128GB; Gaming: Crucial MX 300 525GB; Storage: Samsung 1TB HDD, Toshiba 2TB HDD
Display(s) Acer Nitro VG270UP (1440p 144 Hz IPS)
Case NOX Hummer MC Black
Audio Device(s) iFi Audio Zen DAC
Power Supply Seasonic Focus+ 750 W
Mouse Cooler Master Masterkeys Lite L
Keyboard Cooler Master Masterkeys Lite L
Software Windows 10 x64
There is a lot to say regarding patent applications and their defense, and the devious ways these can be used as a way to both stifle innovation, competition, and to leech other companies' funds with what is usually described as "patent troll" behavior. Being a seat of technological innovation, The California Institute of Technology (CalTech) registers patents as results of their attachés' work - some of these see the light of day as actual products, but more often than not, the patent rights are used as a way for the institute to receive funds from those that would license their intellectual property.

After entering a legal battle with Apple and Broadcom back in 2016, CalTech has now had its accusation of patent infringement against both companies come to a close, with the jury deciding in favor of the university. The accusation was of both companies deploying WiFi chips which were based on Caltech's patent designs - WiFi chips that were then shipped within millions of iPhones, iPads and MacBooks. As a result, both Apple and Broadcom were ordered to pay a total of $1.1 billion in compensation, with Apple taking the brunt of the decision ($837.8 million) and Broadcom coming in with a thinner slice at $270.2.





Both Apple and Broadcom have come forward saying they intend to appeal against the decision, with Apple using the tactic of shirking off responsibility. According to the company, they are "an indirect downstream party" to the patent-infringing WiFi modules, which means Apple believes they have no responsibility as to any patent infringements that were included in the design of the chips it ordered from Broadcom. Stock valuation of both Apple and Broadcom declined after the jury's decision was made public.

As for CalTech, the scholl said in a statement that they are "(...) pleased the jury found that Apple and Broadcom infringed Caltech patents. As a non-profit institution of higher education, Caltech is committed to protecting its intellectual property in furtherance of its mission to expand human knowledge and benefit society through research integrated with education."

View at TechPowerUp Main Site
 
Joined
Feb 11, 2009
Messages
3,099 (0.70/day)
System Name Cyberline
Processor Intel Core i7 2600k
Motherboard Asus P8P67 LE Rev 3.0
Cooling Tuniq Tower 120
Memory Corsair (4x2) 8gb 1600mhz
Video Card(s) AMD RX480
Storage Samsung 750 Evo 250gb SSD + WD 1tb x 2 + WD 2tb
Display(s) Philips 32inch LPF5605H (television)
Case antec 600
Audio Device(s) Focusrite 2i4 (USB)
Power Supply Seasonic 620watt 80+ Platinum
Mouse Elecom EX-G
Keyboard Rapoo V700
Software Windows 10 Pro 64bit
"As a non-profit institution of higher education"

yeah....sure they are
 
Joined
Aug 8, 2019
Messages
426 (0.75/day)
System Name R2V2 *In Progress
Processor Ryzen 7 2700
Motherboard Asrock X570 Taichi
Cooling W2A... water to air
Memory G.Skill Trident Z3466 B-die
Video Card(s) Radeon VII repaired and resurrected
Storage Adata and Samsung NVME
Display(s) Samsung LCD
Case Some ThermalTake
Audio Device(s) Asus Strix RAID DLX upgraded op amps
Power Supply Seasonic Prime something or other
Software Windows 10 Pro x64
"As a non-profit institution of higher education"

yeah....sure they are

Well it's a donation that will go to loweri...

Who am I kidding, watch tuition go up. LoL
 
Joined
May 2, 2017
Messages
3,643 (2.61/day)
Location
Norwegian, currently in Lund, Sweden
Processor AMD Ryzen 5 1600X
Motherboard Biostar X370GTN
Cooling Custom CPU+GPU water loop
Memory 16GB G.Skill TridentZ DDR4-3200 C16
Video Card(s) AMD R9 Fury X
Storage 500GB 960 Evo (OS ++), 500GB 850 Evo (Games)
Display(s) Dell U2711
Case NZXT H200i
Power Supply EVGA Supernova G2 750W
Mouse Logitech G602
Keyboard Lenovo Compact Keyboard with Trackpoint
Software Windows 10 Pro
I would applaud this if it didn't happen within the massively corrupt US college system. Research institutions in general get far too little in return for their research, and most billion-dollar companies today wouldn't exist if it weren't for the contributions of external researchers. Heck, even in the US chances are the research in question was taxpayer funded. Oh well. Apple can afford to pay.
 
Low quality post by Vya Domus
Joined
Jan 8, 2017
Messages
6,470 (4.29/day)
System Name Good enough
Processor AMD Ryzen R7 1700X - 4.0 Ghz / 1.350V
Motherboard ASRock B450M Pro4
Cooling Deepcool Gammaxx L240 V2
Memory 16GB - Corsair Vengeance LPX - 3333 Mhz CL16
Video Card(s) OEM Dell GTX 1080 with Kraken G12 + Water 3.0 Performer C
Storage 1x Samsung 850 EVO 250GB , 1x Samsung 860 EVO 500GB
Display(s) 4K Samsung TV
Case Deepcool Matrexx 70
Power Supply GPS-750C
US legal systems and juries regarding patents are a real cesspool. Nothing to see here.
 
Joined
Feb 14, 2012
Messages
2,073 (0.63/day)
System Name msdos
Processor 8086
Motherboard mainboard
Cooling passive
Memory 640KB + 384KB extended
Video Card(s) EGA
Storage 5.25"
Display(s) 80x25
Case plastic
Audio Device(s) modchip
Power Supply 45 watts
Mouse serial
Keyboard yes
Software disk commander
Benchmark Scores still running
A reminder that universities are business first, education second.
 
Joined
Aug 20, 2007
Messages
14,157 (2.87/day)
System Name Pioneer
Processor Intel i9 9900k
Motherboard ASRock Z390 Taichi
Cooling Noctua NH-D15 + A whole lotta Sunon and Corsair Maglev blower fans...
Memory G.SKILL Ripjaws V Series 64GB (4 x 16GB) DDR4-3200
Video Card(s) EVGA GeForce RTX 2080 SUPER XC ULTRA
Storage 2x Mushkin Pilot-E 2TB NVMe SSDs in bootable RAID0 by HIGHPOINT SSD7202
Display(s) 55" LG 55" B9 OLED 4K Display
Case Thermaltake Core X31
Audio Device(s) VGA HDMI->Panasonic SC-HTB20/Schiit Modi MB/Asgard 2 DAC/Amp to AKG Pro K7712 Headphones
Power Supply Seasonic Prime Titanium 750W
Mouse ROCCAT Kone EMP
Keyboard WASD CODE 104-Key w/ Cherry MX Green Keyswitches, Doubleshot Vortex PBT White Transluscent Keycaps
Software Windows 10 Enterprise (Product of work, yes it's legit)
Benchmark Scores www.3dmark.com/fs/23478641 www.3dmark.com/spy/13863605 www.3dmark.com/pr/306218
Well it's a donation that will go to loweri...

Who am I kidding, watch tuition go up. LoL

Knowing my old campus at evergreen, when they get a large sum of money, tuition never comes up in discussion. Instead, they build useless buildings no one asked for.

One of the more recent ones is shaped like a curved concrete cylinder, and is refered to by students as "the UFO." I have no idea what they do with it. I used to joke they enriched uranium there.

A reminder that universities are business first, education second.

Most are. None should be.
 

Easy Rhino

Linux Advocate
Staff member
Joined
Nov 13, 2006
Messages
14,948 (2.86/day)
Location
Mid-Atlantic
System Name Desktop
Processor i5 7500 Kaby Lake
Motherboard AsRock MicroATX Z170M Extreme4
Cooling Stock
Memory 2x 16 Gb Gskill Ripjaws 2400
Video Card(s) AMD Radeon 5700
Storage Samsung 970 EVO 1 TB m.2 NVMe + Samsung 860 EVO 2 TB SATA3 SSD
Display(s) LG 34GK950F-B 34" 21:9 Ultragear WQHD Nano IPS Curved Gaming Monitor with Radeon FreeSync 2
Case Corsair Carbide 400C
Audio Device(s) On Board
Power Supply Seasonic SSR-650GD Flagship Prime Series 650W Gold
Mouse Logitech G900 Chaos Spectrum
Keyboard Corsair K63 Wireless
Software Windows 10
Apple should not have to pay anything. Broadcom is fully responsible. It is up to them to manage the legality of the products they sell. Seems like Apple is an easy target because they have so much money. I am not saying Apple has never participated in shady tactics but this seems like a railroad of Apple.
 
Joined
Jul 16, 2014
Messages
4,548 (1.88/day)
Location
SE Michigan
System Name Dumbass
Processor AMD-9370BE @4.6
Motherboard ASUS SABERTOOTH 990FX R2.0 +SB950
Cooling CM Nepton 280L
Memory G.Skill Sniper 16gb DDR3 2400
Video Card(s) GreenTeam 1080 Gaming X 8GB
Storage C:\SSD (240GB), D:\Seagate (2TB), E:\Western Digital (1TB)
Display(s) 1x Nixeus NX_EDG27, 2x Dell S2440L (16:9)
Case Phanteks Enthoo Primo w/8 140mm SP Fans
Audio Device(s) onboard (realtek?) SPKRS:Logitech Z623 200w 2.1
Power Supply Corsair HX1000i
Mouse Logitech G700s
Keyboard Logitech G910 Orion Spark
Software windows 10
Benchmark Scores https://i.imgur.com/aoz3vWY.jpg?2
Apple should not have to pay anything. Broadcom is fully responsible. It is up to them to manage the legality of the products they sell. Seems like Apple is an easy target because they have so much money. I am not saying Apple has never participated in shady tactics but this seems like a railroad of Apple.
Apple should have known better going into a deal like that, they are still culpable to a lesser extent.
 

Easy Rhino

Linux Advocate
Staff member
Joined
Nov 13, 2006
Messages
14,948 (2.86/day)
Location
Mid-Atlantic
System Name Desktop
Processor i5 7500 Kaby Lake
Motherboard AsRock MicroATX Z170M Extreme4
Cooling Stock
Memory 2x 16 Gb Gskill Ripjaws 2400
Video Card(s) AMD Radeon 5700
Storage Samsung 970 EVO 1 TB m.2 NVMe + Samsung 860 EVO 2 TB SATA3 SSD
Display(s) LG 34GK950F-B 34" 21:9 Ultragear WQHD Nano IPS Curved Gaming Monitor with Radeon FreeSync 2
Case Corsair Carbide 400C
Audio Device(s) On Board
Power Supply Seasonic SSR-650GD Flagship Prime Series 650W Gold
Mouse Logitech G900 Chaos Spectrum
Keyboard Corsair K63 Wireless
Software Windows 10
Apple should have known better going into a deal like that, they are still culpable to a lesser extent.

How should they have known better? Unless Broadcom told Apple that the patents were dubious then Apple does not need to know.
 
Joined
May 2, 2017
Messages
3,643 (2.61/day)
Location
Norwegian, currently in Lund, Sweden
Processor AMD Ryzen 5 1600X
Motherboard Biostar X370GTN
Cooling Custom CPU+GPU water loop
Memory 16GB G.Skill TridentZ DDR4-3200 C16
Video Card(s) AMD R9 Fury X
Storage 500GB 960 Evo (OS ++), 500GB 850 Evo (Games)
Display(s) Dell U2711
Case NZXT H200i
Power Supply EVGA Supernova G2 750W
Mouse Logitech G602
Keyboard Lenovo Compact Keyboard with Trackpoint
Software Windows 10 Pro
Isn't Apple pretty much Broadcom's only large scale WiFi customer at this point? Given that Apple uses them exclusively and buys their chipset in the tens if not hundreds of millions each year I would guess they are quite intimately involved with their development.
 
Joined
Jun 28, 2016
Messages
3,595 (2.11/day)
Very weird thread with very worrying comments.
Is this community so much against IP that even Apple gets some sympathy this time? :p

"Non-profit" does NOT mean an institution can't sell stuff.

The $1.1B figure looks silly and likely will get lower over the next court case.
But universities are research facilities as well. They have to protect their work.
 

cdawall

where the hell are my stars
Joined
Jul 23, 2006
Messages
27,670 (5.19/day)
Location
Houston
System Name All the cores || Into the Blue
Processor 2990WX || 5960X
Motherboard Asrock X399M || Asus X99M WS
Cooling CPU-XSPC RayStorm Neo, 2x240mm+360mm, D5PWM+140mL, GPU-2x360mm, 2xbyski, D4+D5+100mL || TBD
Memory 4x8GB G.Skill Trident Z 3200 CL16 || EVGA 3200 2x8GB
Video Card(s) (2) EVGA SC BLACK 1080Ti's || EVGA 1080Ti FE
Storage 2x Samsung SM951 512GB, Samsung PM961 512GB || OCZ Vector 180 480GB
Display(s) Dell UP2414Q 3840X2160@60hz || TBD
Case Caselabs Mercury S5+pedestal || Supermicro S5 (GS5A-753K)
Audio Device(s) Fischer HA-02->Fischer FA-002W High edition/FA-003/Jubilate/FA-011 depending on my mood
Power Supply Seasonic Prime 1200w || Seasonic Snow Silent 750w
Mouse Thermaltake Theron, Steam controller || TBD
Keyboard Thermaltake Poseidon ZX, Steam controller || Corsair K70
Software W10P || W10P
Apple should have known better going into a deal like that, they are still culpable to a lesser extent.

I do not believe apple gets a list of possible patent infringements when they order a chip to spec.
 
Joined
Jun 28, 2016
Messages
3,595 (2.11/day)
Apple should not have to pay anything. Broadcom is fully responsible. It is up to them to manage the legality of the products they sell. Seems like Apple is an easy target because they have so much money. I am not saying Apple has never participated in shady tactics but this seems like a railroad of Apple.
It's a bit more complex than that.

Patent infringement cases are not about companies earning undeserved profit. It's about patent owner losing money because he isn't being paid for his work.
The $1.1B is not a fine (you pay that to the government). It's a compensation for lost profit.

Here's an example of a situation this is designed to prevent.
Company "A" wants to buy a product that uses an IP from company "C".
Suppliers have to pay a fee X - per item made - to the license provider "C".
So I'm a company "B". I decide to make a product that uses "C"'s work, but I don't pay for the license.
I could still sell this product for as much as everyone else and make the whole stolen X, but that doesn't give me any competitive advantage.
Instead, I make my product cheaper by 0.75 * X.
As a result, I'm much cheaper than other suppliers, so I win the contract.
I still make more than every other supplier would (by 0.25 * X).
Buyer "A" earns additional 0.75 * X (compared to if he bought from a supplier that paid for IP use).

If "C" goes to court and wins this case, they should be given the whole X. "C"'s best interest has a priority.
And the real threat (going back to preventing things) is: what if "B" decided not to take any of the stolen value? They could sell a product for X less than everyone else. "A" would earn the whole X. And if "C" was only eligible to what "B" took for themselves... the whole IP idea would collapse.

How "A" and "B" settle this afterwards is of less improtance. Of course "A" can sue "B" and potentially get the 0.75*X back.
I do not believe apple gets a list of possible patent infringements when they order a chip to spec.
Apple, being a major and serious company, should check if the product they buy is "clean". And in the next court case they'll try to prove that they did everything possible - we'll see if the court agrees.
Expecting that a supplier will voluntarily give them such information is like expecting he also gives a list of possible production faults and design mistakes.

And now the inevitable car analogy (which works for any other material product):
If you buy a stolen car and you're "cought", the car will be returned to the rightful owner.
You, as a buyer, are obliged to check if the seller has the right to sell an item (he is an owner or an agent).
If you can't prove you checked ownership, you may be accused of fencing.
If the court decides you bought a stolen car inadvertently (you did some checks, you used sources available to a private buyer etc), you're off the hook for fencing, but you still lose the car, i.e. a lot of money (possibly way more than the thief).

And now when the material ownership becomes even more strict than IP stuff.
If the rightful owner can't be found (or is dead), you still lose the car.
 
Joined
Apr 12, 2013
Messages
3,916 (1.36/day)
I do not believe apple gets a list of possible patent infringements when they order a chip to spec.
Pretty sure when signing such massive deals, Apple does know what they are getting into. Any competent legal department will take a look at something like that & knowing Apple, especially their dubious patent litigation history, they would've looked into it.

I would applaud this if it didn't happen within the massively corrupt US college system.
You could apply that to the 3 branches of govt as well, across the globe in fact. As I've repeatedly said ~ money, power, influence have corrupted everything around the world & the US is no better in that regard.
 
Last edited:
Low quality post by Xaled
Joined
Jun 18, 2015
Messages
472 (0.23/day)
Nice to see universities finally start to charge for what they've been giving for free for almost 300 years; feeding the capital with science and qualified workforce, raping students and promoting homosexuality.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Nov 11, 2004
Messages
7,541 (1.27/day)
Location
Formosa
System Name Overlord Mk MXVI
Processor AMD Ryzen 7 3800X
Motherboard Gigabyte X570 Aorus Master
Cooling Corsair H115i Pro
Memory 32GB Viper Steel 3600 DDR4 @ 3800MHz 16-19-16-19-36
Video Card(s) Gigabyte RTX 2080 Gaming OC 8G
Storage 1TB WD Black NVMe (2018), 2TB Viper VPN100, 1TB WD Blue 3D NAND
Display(s) Asus PG27AQ
Case Corsair Carbide 275Q
Audio Device(s) Corsair Virtuoso SE
Power Supply Corsair RM750
Mouse Logitech G502 Lightspeed
Keyboard Wooting Two
Software Windows 10 Pro
Benchmark Scores https://valid.x86.fr/33u9si
Isn't Apple pretty much Broadcom's only large scale WiFi customer at this point? Given that Apple uses them exclusively and buys their chipset in the tens if not hundreds of millions each year I would guess they are quite intimately involved with their development.
On the client side, maybe. But Broadcom is the major WiFi router/AP chip player. If say there's 2 to 1 ratio of Broadcom based routers/APs to all other brands combined.
 
Joined
Jul 5, 2013
Messages
12,229 (4.38/day)
Location
USA
System Name GPD-Q9
Processor Rockchip RK-3288 1.8ghz quad core
Motherboard GPD Q9_V6_150528
Cooling Passive
Memory 2GB DDR3
Video Card(s) Mali T764
Storage 16GB Samsung NAND
Display(s) IPS 1024x600
I'm glad to see things have finally worked out the correct way for once. This proves that Apple is less than trustworthy and has been that way for a long time. And because it's a jury trial, an appeal will be MUCH more difficult, effectively a waste of time. Jury verdicts are rarely over-ruled by an appellate court. Whether they like it or not, Apple and Broadcom are going to have to pay for their dishonesty.
 
Joined
May 2, 2017
Messages
3,643 (2.61/day)
Location
Norwegian, currently in Lund, Sweden
Processor AMD Ryzen 5 1600X
Motherboard Biostar X370GTN
Cooling Custom CPU+GPU water loop
Memory 16GB G.Skill TridentZ DDR4-3200 C16
Video Card(s) AMD R9 Fury X
Storage 500GB 960 Evo (OS ++), 500GB 850 Evo (Games)
Display(s) Dell U2711
Case NZXT H200i
Power Supply EVGA Supernova G2 750W
Mouse Logitech G602
Keyboard Lenovo Compact Keyboard with Trackpoint
Software Windows 10 Pro
Pretty sure when signing such massive deals, Apple does know what they are getting into. Any competent legal department will take a look at something like that & knowing Apple, especially their dubious patent litigation history, they would've looked into it.

You could apply that to the 3 branches of govt as well, across the globe in fact. As I've repeatedly said ~ money, power, influence have corrupted everything around the world & the US is no better in that regard.
I don't entirely disagree with you, but it would sure be nice if you didn't bungle your quotations there. Appreciate it if you were to fix that.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Aug 20, 2007
Messages
14,157 (2.87/day)
System Name Pioneer
Processor Intel i9 9900k
Motherboard ASRock Z390 Taichi
Cooling Noctua NH-D15 + A whole lotta Sunon and Corsair Maglev blower fans...
Memory G.SKILL Ripjaws V Series 64GB (4 x 16GB) DDR4-3200
Video Card(s) EVGA GeForce RTX 2080 SUPER XC ULTRA
Storage 2x Mushkin Pilot-E 2TB NVMe SSDs in bootable RAID0 by HIGHPOINT SSD7202
Display(s) 55" LG 55" B9 OLED 4K Display
Case Thermaltake Core X31
Audio Device(s) VGA HDMI->Panasonic SC-HTB20/Schiit Modi MB/Asgard 2 DAC/Amp to AKG Pro K7712 Headphones
Power Supply Seasonic Prime Titanium 750W
Mouse ROCCAT Kone EMP
Keyboard WASD CODE 104-Key w/ Cherry MX Green Keyswitches, Doubleshot Vortex PBT White Transluscent Keycaps
Software Windows 10 Enterprise (Product of work, yes it's legit)
Benchmark Scores www.3dmark.com/fs/23478641 www.3dmark.com/spy/13863605 www.3dmark.com/pr/306218
I'm glad to see things have finally worked out the correct way for once. This proves that Apple is less than trustworthy and has been that way for a long time. And because it's a jury trial, an appeal will be MUCH more difficult, effectively a waste of time. Jury verdicts are rarely over-ruled by an appellate court. Whether they like it or not, Apple and Broadcom are going to have to pay for their dishonesty.

Apple may have a point here in an appeal, but Broadcom is screwed.

Apple merely licensed the infringing product. How were they to know?
 
Joined
Jul 5, 2013
Messages
12,229 (4.38/day)
Location
USA
System Name GPD-Q9
Processor Rockchip RK-3288 1.8ghz quad core
Motherboard GPD Q9_V6_150528
Cooling Passive
Memory 2GB DDR3
Video Card(s) Mali T764
Storage 16GB Samsung NAND
Display(s) IPS 1024x600
Joined
Jun 2, 2017
Messages
3,566 (2.61/day)
System Name Best AMD Computer
Processor AMD TR4 2920X
Motherboard ASUS X399 STrix
Cooling Alphacool Eisbaer 420 x2 Noctua XPX Pro TR4 block
Memory ADATA D60 3600MHZ 32 GB
Video Card(s) MSI 6800XT Gaming Trio X
Storage 6 x NVME 480 GB, 2 x SSD 2TB, 5TB HDD, 2 TB HDD, 2x 2TB SSHD
Display(s) GIGABYTE 32QC
Case PHANTEKS ENTHOO PRO
Audio Device(s) Corsair Void Pro, Logitch Z523 5.1
Power Supply Corsair HX1200!
Mouse Logitech g7 gaming mouse
Keyboard Logitech G510
Software Windows 10 Pro 64 Steam. GOG, Uplay, Origin
Benchmark Scores Firestrike: 24955 Time Spy: 13500
They don't have a prayer because...

That's the point and why the jury slammed them, they knew!

Unfortunately the way I see Apple will be happy to spend more than 1 billion dollars to appeal this case. They have made so many infringements it is not funny.
 
Joined
Jul 16, 2014
Messages
4,548 (1.88/day)
Location
SE Michigan
System Name Dumbass
Processor AMD-9370BE @4.6
Motherboard ASUS SABERTOOTH 990FX R2.0 +SB950
Cooling CM Nepton 280L
Memory G.Skill Sniper 16gb DDR3 2400
Video Card(s) GreenTeam 1080 Gaming X 8GB
Storage C:\SSD (240GB), D:\Seagate (2TB), E:\Western Digital (1TB)
Display(s) 1x Nixeus NX_EDG27, 2x Dell S2440L (16:9)
Case Phanteks Enthoo Primo w/8 140mm SP Fans
Audio Device(s) onboard (realtek?) SPKRS:Logitech Z623 200w 2.1
Power Supply Corsair HX1000i
Mouse Logitech G700s
Keyboard Logitech G910 Orion Spark
Software windows 10
Benchmark Scores https://i.imgur.com/aoz3vWY.jpg?2
How should they have known better? Unless Broadcom told Apple that the patents were dubious then Apple does not need to know.
You are assuming they never asked. I am assuming Apple is smart enough to ask.

I do not believe apple gets a list of possible patent infringements when they order a chip to spec.
blindly ordering like they did is asking for trouble and they got it.
 
Joined
Apr 12, 2013
Messages
3,916 (1.36/day)
but it would sure be nice if you didn't bungle your quotations there. Appreciate it if you were to fix that.
Not sure why your name is showing in the first quote, pretty sure it was the other poster when I first submitted the reply.
 
Top