Technology & Positioning
The ADATA XPG Mars 980 Blade is the company's first PCI-Express 5.0 solid-state drive using the Silicon Motion SM2508 controller. Earlier Gen 5 SSDs from ADATA used controllers from InnoGrit and Phison. This review is our sixth review of the SM2508, we previously reviewed the WD SN8100, Crucial T710, Acer GM9000, Kingston Fury Renegade and the Lexar NM1090 4 TB. Interestingly, we've noticed some quite significant differences between these drives, which was unexpected. With Phison controllers, all the drives performed almost identically. When I asked Silicon Motion about this, they pointed out that their approach is to provide not only a solid controller but also to give their customers the flexibility to customize the drives to suit their needs and market preferences. What also plays a role is the differences in NAND flash used—we've seen Micron 232-layer, Micron 276-layer, and Kioxia 218-layer like on the WD SN8100 and the Kingston Fury Renegade G5. The ADATA XPG Mars 980 Blade uses Micron 232-layer, but four chips in a double-sided configuration. As expected from a drive with a flagship positioning, a DRAM cache is installed, too. We found 2 GB DDR4-2666 on the Mars 980.
Synthetic Performance
The ADATA XPG Mars 980 Blade performed very well in most of our synthetic testing, but wasn't able to match the top scores of other SM2508-based drives. Sequential read performance, particularly at low queue depths, showed lower-than-expected results. In these tests the drive ran at full speed for a few seconds, and then lowered performance for a few seconds, and then returned to full speed. I verified that this isn't a thermal problem, and I retested it several times, also secure erasing the drive in-between. Another possible explanation is that it might be due to the relatively old firmware the drive is running, or it could be related to the NAND configuration.
However, what matters much more is real-life testing, because all controllers are optimized for typical synthetic reviewer workloads on a mostly empty drive. Our real-life testing is designed to run actual applications, not disk traces that compress time by assuming infinitely fast hardware and software. We're even running those tests with the drives filled to 85% capacity, not empty. This approach puts additional pressure on the various algorithms and the SLC cache, just like in real-life.
Real-Life Performance
In our real-world tests, ADATA's new drive delivered strong performance, consistently reaching top marks, but still ending up a bit behind other SM2508-based drives. These results align with the synthetic testing outcomes, so they're not entirely unexpected. On average, the drive is able to match the fastest Gen 4 disks, but falls behind the WD SN8100 by 5%, even though both drives are using the same controller.
SLC Cache / Sustained Performance
ADATA has configured their drive with an SLC cache size of 360 GB, which is a reasonable compromise. It means that 56% of the drive's capacity will be used in SLC mode first, which consumes three times the storage per byte, at much higher speed. Filling the whole 2 TB capacity completed at 3 GB/s, which is a highly impressive result that is better than other SM2508 SSDs that we've tested so far (Kingston Fury Renegade: 2.1 GB/s, WD SN8100 2.5 GB/s), but others are faster (Crucial T710: 3.3 GB/s, Acer GM9000 3.1 GB/s). This result is significantly higher than the leading competitor, the Samsung 9100 Pro, which has a speed of 1.8 GB/s. It also slightly surpasses the Phison E26-powered Corsair MP700 Pro, which has a speed of 2.8 GB/s.
Power Consumption / Heat
Thermals of Gen 5 drives have always been challenging, with all Phison E26 models requiring an active fan-cooled solution, a large heatsink, or both. One of Silicon Motion's development focuses was to lower heat output, which necessitates better energy efficiency. Their SM2508 controller is fabricated using a 6 nanometer process at TSMC Taiwan. A few weeks ago we introduced a new real-life thermal test. Our previous testing was only focused on stressing the drive as much as possible, which is something that basically never happens during actual usage. Our new benchmark runs over two dozen storage tests that simulate real applications like productivity, gaming, file copying, etc. I'm happy to report that the ADATA XPG Mars 980 Blade did not throttle during normal usage in a reasonably ventilated case—even without heatsink. In our thermal stress test, we observed significant throttling. One reason for this is that ADATA has set a very conservative thermal throttle limit for their drive—just 72°C. This is lower than most competitors, that allow up to 100°C, which greatly helps in avoiding thermal throttling.
In terms of efficiency, which considers both power consumption and data transfer speed, the Mars 980 claims a good spot, but can't beat the top SM2508 drives, which are a lot more energy-efficient.
Pricing & Alternatives
The pricing of PCIe Gen 5 drives has been quite high for years, but it seems we're finally beginning to see some movement in prices. The ADATA XPG Mars 980 Blade 2 TB is priced at a highly competitive $170, which makes it the most affordable Gen 5 SSD on the market. The main competitors are much more expensive: Samsung 9100 Pro and Crucial T710 2 TB are both $230, the Kingston Fury Renegade G5 goes for $245. Given the performance numbers we've been seeing, I think ADATA did the right thing by pricing their SSD aggressively. For those looking to benefit from the high transfer speeds of Gen 5 SSDs, this is a workable option that doesn't break the bank. Drives using the Phison E26 controller are more expensive, have higher power and heat requirements, and don't offer significantly better performance. Unless you need the super-high sequential transfer rates, it's worth checking out Gen 4 offerings, too. We recently reviewed the 2 TB WD Black SN7100, which is the fastest Gen 4 SSD we ever tested—$130. Other options are Samsung 990 Pro ($160), WD SN850X ($150) and of course MaxioTech MAP1602 drives such as the Lexar NM790 ($120).
