Technology & Positioning
The Lexar NM1090 Pro is the company's first PCI-Express 5.0 consumer SSD. It uses the new Silicon Motion SM2508 controller, which is SMI's first Gen 5 controller for the consumer space. We've reviewed the SM2508 three times before, focusing on the 2 TB models of the Acer GM9000, Kingston Fury Renegade, and Crucial T710. This is our first look at the 4 TB version of the SM2508. The 4 TB model has additional flash chips—four instead of two, which opens up new opportunities for parallelism, so the performance numbers will be interesting, and also how it performs against the Gen 5 controllers from Phison and Samsung. The NAND flash chips used are Micron 232-layer 3D TLC—we've seen those on a lot of Phison E26 drives in the past. As expected from a drive with a flagship positioning, a DRAM cache is installed, too. We found 4 GB LPDDR4-3733 on the NM1090 Pro, which is a bit slower than the 4266 MT/s memory on the competing models. Just to clarify, there is no NM1090 non-Pro model.
Synthetic Performance
The Lexar NM1090 did fine in our synthetic testing, performing better than the Corsair MP700 Pro (Phison E26), but slower than the Samsung 9100 Pro. While sequential writes and sequential mixed are near the top, sequential read at QD1 is a little bit slower than expected. Random IO is very good across the board. Interestingly, we saw a drop at QD4 Sequential, which is unexpected, and it didn't go away even when tested several times. I asked Lexar for testing/clarification, but never heard back from them, so they probably had no additional feedback to share with the public. What matters much more is real-life testing, because all controllers are optimized for typical synthetic reviewer workloads on a mostly empty drive. Our real-life testing is designed to run actual applications, not disk traces that compress time by assuming infinitely fast hardware and software. We're even running those tests with the drives filled to 85% capacity, not empty. This approach puts additional pressure on the various algorithms and the SLC cache, just like in real-life.
Real-Life Performance
In our real-life tests, the new SMI controller performed very well, achieving performance that's better than all the PCIe 4.0 drives on the market. The Lexar NM1090 Pro 4 TB is very close behind the Phison E26-based Corsair MP700 Pro (1%), and beats the Phison E31-based Kioxia Exceria Plus G4 by 1%. The Samsung 9100 Pro is a small 2% faster. Other SM2508 drives are offering a little bit higher performance than the NM1090 Pro, the Kingston Fury Renegade is 1% ahead, the Crucial T710, with the newer Micron TLC NAND is 3% faster. One possible reason is that the NM1090 pro uses a 3733 MT/s DRAM chip, whereas the other drives are running with 4266 MT/s. Taking a look at individual benchmarks we can see that each controller wins some tests, and other controllers win other tests, depending on the load pattern and the controller's optimizations. Compared to older Gen 4 drives, the performance uplift is around 10%, but the best PCIe 4.0 drives with modern controllers are not much slower than the various Gen 5 offerings, unless of course you need those massive transfer speeds, which is quite rare.
SLC Cache / Sustained Performance
Lexar has configured their drive with an SLC cache size of 755 GB (or 55% in SLC mode), which is enough to soak up nearly all bursts of write activity. Once the SLC cache is exhausted, transfer rates are dropping only by a small amount—still reaching an incredible 6.5 GB/s. After 2.6 TB written, there's a second drop to 2 GB/s—still plenty. Filling the whole 4 TB capacity completed at 4.2 GB/s, which is the best result we've ever seen here, by a pretty big margin. Compared to the Samsung 9100 Pro 2 TB, this is more than twice as fast. It's also 1.5 GB/s better than Crucial T700 Pro, which is the fastest Phison E26 4 TB drive in this test. What matters here is that due to the large 4 TB capacity, the controller has more chips to work with, improving throughput thanks to parallelism.
Power Consumption / Heat
Thermals of Gen 5 drives have always been challenging, with all Phison E26 models requiring an active fan-cooled solution, a large heatsink, or both. One of Silicon Motion's development focuses was to lower heat output, which necessitates better energy efficiency. Their SM2508 controller is fabricated using a 6 nanometer process at TSMC Taiwan. While we can confirm that the Lexar NM1090 Pro achieved "good" efficiency, the results are definitely less impressive than what we saw on the SM2508+Kioxia Kingston Fury Renegade G5. Still, power levels are not that far from power-hungry Gen 4 models, which means cooling requirements are much more reasonable. In typical usage, we're now seeing around 5 W, which is not that hard to keep cool. Maximum power hits 8.5 W, a bit high, but still better than the Phison E26, which peaked at almost 11 W.
Just a week ago we introduced a new real-life thermal test. Our previous testing was only focused on stressing the drive as much as possible, which is something that basically never happens during actual usage. Our new benchmark runs over two dozen storage tests that simulate real applications like productivity, gaming, file copying, etc. Here we see that even without a heatsink the NM1090 Pro runs perfectly fine, without thermal throttling. Still, as you can see in the stress test results, for heavy usage it's definitely recommended to install a decent heatsink on top of the SSD.
Pricing & Alternatives
While pricing of PCIe Gen 5 drives has been pretty high for years, we're starting to see some downwards action, thanks to the newfound competition. The Lexar NM1090 Pro's MSRP is $495, but right now you can find it for just $390 on Amazon, which is a pretty competitive price for a 4 TB SSD. Strong competition comes from the Samsung 9100 Pro, which is faster and only slightly more expensive at $400. WD's new flagship, the SN8100 (review soon) sells for $450, which is a pretty significant cost increase that won't be easy to justify. The new Crucial T710 SSD is the fastest drive we've ever tested, but its price is quite high, with the 4 TB model costing $550 right now. WD's SN7100—the fastest Gen 4 SSD we've reviewed—offers basically the same performance as the NM1090 Pro in typical workloads, and sells for $245, for 4 TB, which is a huge cost savings. If you're willing to consider a Gen 4 SSD, then there are lots of other options, too, like the MaxioTech MAP1602-based drives such as the Lexar NM790 ($240).
