Value and Conclusion
- The Synology DS2419+ without any disks retails for $1499.99.
- Low impact on transfer speeds with encrypted files
- Solid build quality
- DSM OS
- Btrfs filesystem support (besides EXT4)
- Four Gigabit Ethernet ports
- Server-grade EMI/Transient filter
- Quiet operation
- HDD temperatures are low enough
- Tool-less installation of HDDs
- Quality fans that are easily replaced
- Support for up to forty camera licenses (comes with two free licenses)
- 4x USB 3.0 and 2x SATA ports
- Ability to skip disk checking during RAID setup (only in RAID 0, 1, and 10)
- SSD caching and TRIM support
- Memory total can easily be increased
- Compatible with Synology's DX1215 expansion unit (supports one of those)
- Fast boot and restart times
- 3-year warranty that can be extended to five years if you buy extended coverage
- Intimidating price
- Expected higher transfer speeds
- IOPs performance with multiple clients
- I would prefer a PSU with DC-DC converters
- C3538 CPU doesn't features a hardware-transcoding engine
- No HDMI port
- At this price, I would like to see a pair of Thunderbolt 3 ports
- Plastic HDD trays have no anti-vibration materials and locks
- You cannot format an external disk into NTFS (but NTFS disks are recognized properly)
The DS2419+ is not for everyone because of its vast storage capacity and the fact that it costs a bomb. $1500 puts it into the business-oriented product stack where reliability and features come first and cost is not as important a factor as it would be to home users. The DS2419+ currently costs $550 more than the DS1819+, so someone could wonder what this large price difference covers. Besides four more drive bays, you get a stronger power supply for support of up to twelve drives in total. Synology also threw a server-grade line filter into the bundle, which will effectively protect your NAS from EMI noise. Those are the main differences, and they don't seem enough to justify the $550 gap between these products. The DS2419+ should have a lower price tag, with $1200 sounding more reasonable.
What I like the most with Synology servers, next to their excellent DSM operating system, is that the boot process doesn't take long, contrary to QNAP's offerings. You might think why bother about how long the NAS takes to boot since you will have it running 24/7 in the majority of cases. However, there are several occasions where you need to restart the server—for app or firmware updates or to perform maintenance, for example, and to me, having to wait for a while for the NAS to reboot is just annoying. Like all Synology server, the DS2419+ fortunately doesn't have this problem.
Synology might not suffer from the slow-boot issue particular to QNAP's servers, but they don't come with HDMI inputs, which would, among other things, make operating it locally possible. I am tired of whining about this every time when it comes to a Synology product. The cost of adding one is next to nothing, and the extra capabilities and features such a port can offer are countless. Such an expensive NAS should also be equipped with Thunderbolt ports. Would it have had Thunderbolt ports, I could have overlooked its $1500 price tag since such ports are for some unfathomable reason considered a premium feature that is accordingly priced.
In general, I liked the DS2419+ and enjoyed reviewing it, though disassembly was tough. Furthermore, I had to conduct a massive number of tests to fully evaluate it. Completing all the tests I considered necessary took more than a month, and I haven't yet come across any instability issues, or other problems that could lead to data losses. This is an excellent server for small and mid-sized business environments, and the addition of an HDMI port along with proper locks for the trays and a pair of Thunderbolt ports would make this product great. A stronger CPU would probably boost transfer speeds as well, which are not as high as I expected. Apparently, the large number of drives puts a lot of stress on the system's SoC.
A lower price tag wouldn't hurt either, but you should always keep in mind that in this product category, you aren't only paying for the hardware, but also the provided software and support. When you store sensitive data and something goes wrong, you need the best support you can get. For everyday users, losing a couple of movies or several family photos can be an issue, but a company simply cannot afford to lose any financial or client data. Keeping multiple backups is the safest way to protect your data, but there can be cases where the problems occur before the backup is complete or all your data has been uploaded to the cloud.