Sunday, September 29th 2019

Intel Sunny Cove Successor Significantly Bigger: Jim Keller

Sunny Cove is codename for Intel's first truly new performance CPU core design since "Skylake," and made its debut with the company's 10 nm "Ice Lake" processors, packing the first tangible IPC increase in years. VLSI guru Jim Keller is leading the effort to build Intel's future CPU core designs, and dropped a big hint on what to expect, speaking at a gathering in U.C. Berkeley. It's unclear which specific core Keller is referring to. The immediate successor to "Sunny Cove" is codenamed "Willow Cove," and Intel's own public sketch hints at an incremental upgrade over Sunny Cove, with faster caches and process-level optimization. It's only with "Golden Cove," slated for 2021, that Intel speaks of its next round of IPC increases (dubbed "ST perf"). It's plausible that Keller is referring to this core since a 2021 launch would fit better with a 2018-19 design phase.

In his talk, Keller describes Intel's next big CPU core as being "significantly bigger" than "Sunny Cove," with its 800-wide instruction window, and "massive" data- and branch-predictors, to put Intel back on a linear performance growth trajectory between generations. Keller also commented on this being a "mindset change" at Intel, which over the past decade, only delivered minor IPC increments between generations, and focused on other areas, such as efficiency. In stark contrast, through the 1990s and 2000s, Intel delivered IPC leaps between generations, such as the one between "Netburst" and "Conroe," and onwards to "Nehalem." These were in-part helped by rapid process advancements that slowed in the 2010s as Intel approached the sub-10 nm scale.
The video presentation by U.C. Berkeley follows.

Add your own comment

59 Comments on Intel Sunny Cove Successor Significantly Bigger: Jim Keller

#51
efikkan
Chrispy_Like Danbert and Midland, I strongly disagree with you on this. You're comparing Sandy (DDR3-1333MHz max spec) with modern platforms that manage a minimum of ~2.5x the bandwidth and significantly lower latency at the same time.
Perhaps I could have been a little more precise. Yes, 1333 MHz vs 2666 MHz in today's games would impact performance somewhat. Around 2133-2400 MHz it starts to flatten out, and beyond 2666 MHz there are few significant differences (for Intel CPUs). My point that I didn't get across well enough is that memory speed matters much less than people think, and even the performance impact between 1333 MHz and 2666 MHz is usually only a few percent.

But no, memory latency haven't changed in the last 10+ years.
Chrispy_Who cares about average framerates when their 1% low and 0.1% low framerates are absolutely tanking performance when it matters?
I agree that consistency is much more important than average frame rate, no issue there.
Posted on Reply
#52
londiste
How much memory speed matters depends on application or game. At least among games there are definitely examples that rely on memory bandwidth and get decent improvements from faster memory, far more than a few percent.
Posted on Reply
#53
Chrispy_
efikkanBut no, memory latency haven't changed in the last 10+ years.
DDR3-1333 CL8 is 6.00ns of CAS latency, and that was the high-end stuff back in 2009 with a hefty premium.
DDR4-3200 CL14 is 4.37ns of CAS latency, and that's today's cheap stuff. You can buy 4600 CL17 if you want to pay the premium tax!

So yeah, we're probably looking at about a 50% improvement in latency alone if you take a mid-range kit from now and 10 years ago and compare the raw latency in nanoseconds. By saying memory latency hasn't changed in a decade is an insult to all the work and progress Samsung, Hynix, and Micron have made over the last few generations.

Ryzen loves faster RAM.
Intel loves faster RAM.

Even in 2017 on an i7-7700K, 3200MHz seemed to be the sweet spot with several mainstream titles doing up to 25% worse when dropping from 3200 to 2666. As far as most reviewers and youtubers are concerned, using less than DDR4-3200 is a bad idea these days because you're losing out on CPU performance. It doesn't matter if that's latency or bandwidth, the results are just worse with slower RAM.

Posted on Reply
#54
efikkan
Chrispy_DDR3-1333 CL8 is 6.00ns of CAS latency, and that was the high-end stuff back in 2009 with a hefty premium.
DDR4-3200 CL14 is 4.37ns of CAS latency, and that's today's cheap stuff. You can buy 4600 CL17 if you want to pay the premium tax!

So yeah, we're probably looking at about a 50% improvement in latency alone if you take a mid-range kit from now and 10 years ago and compare the raw latency in nanoseconds. By saying memory latency hasn't changed in a decade is an insult to all the work and progress Samsung, Hynix, and Micron have made over the last few generations.
I'm sorry, but you are completely wrong when it comes to latency.
You can read about memory latency here.
Access time of an arbitrary address in DRAM is about ~50ns, with memory controller overhead it's about ~70-90ns as you can see here. So when you compare memory with different CAS latency with is 1.5-2ns quicker, it's not 50% quicker, more like ~2-3% quicker (and that's assuming you are able to actually run it on the best case non-JEDEC speeds they put in the spec sheet).
As I said, DRAM latencies haven't changed much changed a lot since the old Pentiums, which was still around ~>80ns.
Chrispy_Ryzen loves faster RAM.
Intel loves faster RAM.
Zen/Zen2 benefits from faster memory frequencies because other timings are tied to it internally, so that's only indirectly.
As you increase the memory speed, you generally only get more bandwidth, as CAS latency has to be increased as the clock increases due to the inherit latencies in DRAM.
And if bandwidth were a bottleneck for gaming, gamers would all buy HEDT CPUs with quad/hex/octa channel memory, that's the easiest way to get a lot of memory bandwidth.
Also, the preliminary specs for upcoming DDR5 expects higher latencies than DDR4.
Posted on Reply
#55
Chrispy_
efikkanI'm sorry, but you are completely wrong when it comes to latency.
You can read about memory latency here.
Access time of an arbitrary address in DRAM is about ~50ns, with memory controller overhead it's about ~70-90ns as you can see here. So when you compare memory with different CAS latency with is 1.5-2ns quicker, it's not 50% quicker, more like ~2-3% quicker (and that's assuming you are able to actually run it on the best case non-JEDEC speeds they put in the spec sheet).
As I said, DRAM latencies haven't changed much changed a lot since the old Pentiums, which was still around ~>80ns.
Fair enough. I was just going on CAS latency x clock interval.

In terms of memory improvements though, I don't think it even matters that overall memory latency hasn't changed much. People can argue hypothetical theory all day, but in the real world, in real applications and real games, a significant portion of performance can be attributed to faster RAM, with a simple litmus test of "put in slower RAM and watch the performance vanish".
Posted on Reply
#56
londiste
Chrispy_DDR3-1333 CL8 is 6.00ns of CAS latency, and that was the high-end stuff back in 2009 with a hefty premium.
DDR4-3200 CL14 is 4.37ns of CAS latency, and that's today's cheap stuff. You can buy 4600 CL17 if you want to pay the premium tax!
This is not a good comparison. 2009 was early in DDR3 lifecycle and while a common module was DDR3-1333 there definitely were DDR3-1600 and faster modules available by the end of DDR3, you could get DDR3-1866 or DDR3-2133. DDR4 is much closer to the end of its life cycle by today. Look back to similar place in its life cycle a your DDR3 example and an average module was DDR4-2400 :)

DDR4-3200 CL14 is most definitely not cheap stuff. DDR4-3200 CL16 costs almost half of what CL14 costs.
efikkanAnd if bandwidth were a bottleneck for gaming, gamers would all buy HEDT CPUs with quad/hex/octa channel memory, that's the easiest way to get a lot of memory bandwidth.
Gamers did buy HEDT CPUs for a while and there are clear benefits even in gaming from more memory bandwidth. However, today the HEDT CPUs are overkill in terms of core count on one hand and/or not the best organization of inter-core communication for latency and this has clear negative effect on gaming. Both Intel's mesh CPUs and Threadrippers have the same problem here. Zen2-based Threadrippers might bring a change to this, hopefully.
efikkanAlso, the preliminary specs for upcoming DDR5 expects higher latencies than DDR4.
As was the case with DDR2, DDR3 and DDR4 ;)
Posted on Reply
#57
Chrispy_
londisteThis is not a good comparison. 2009 was early in DDR3 lifecycle and while a common module was DDR3-1333 there definitely were DDR3-1600 and faster modules available by the end of DDR3, you could get DDR3-1866 or DDR3-2133. DDR4 is much closer to the end of its life cycle by today. Look back to similar place in its life cycle a your DDR3 example and an average module was DDR4-2400 :)
I only picked those values because they are the Intel and AMD spec of Sandy Bridge and Zen 2 respectively to indicate the ~10 year difference. (it's 8 years, 9 months, actually).

As for pricing, I suspect that's just regional variation. 3200 14-16-16 is guaranteed on Samsung B-die It shouldn't be expensive and I certainly haven't paid much of a premium for it in the last quarter. You do have to read between the lines a bit because JEDEC-spec 3200 (PC4-25600) ranges from CL22 to CL20 and it's practically impossible to even buy RAM that slow. Even the lowest-grade Micron A-die or Samsung B-die will likely meet AMD's recommendations of 3200 CL14. It's not as if the XMP info in the SPD is particularly helpful either because it's not optimised for Ryzen and even across different generation of Intel DDR4-compatible CPUs there's a lot of variation in their RAM tolerance and IMC quality.

What I tried to say in my previous post is that none of these minor latency or timing details really matter. If you take any modern processor on today's mainstream DDR4 (somewhere around 3200) you are going to see drastic performance loss if you swap in much slower RAM, which brings us back to the original point of this discussion - that significant IPC gains made in the last decade are at least partly attributable to the improvements in DRAM speed and not something Intel can claim as true IPC gains. We all know that Haswell benefitted from a RAM overclock, despite the spec only being officially capped at 1600MHz.
Posted on Reply
#58
londiste
It is not so much the difference in years but a difference in where the RAM type is in its life cycle. DDR3 came out in 2007 and 2009 was pretty early in its life cycle. For DDR4 that came out in 2014 the same timeframe would be somewhere 2016-ish. CPU IMC spec's especially when it comes to Intel is probably a bad baseline.

You are also talking about memory overclocking here. Yeah, B-dies do 3200 CL14 but out-of-box spec module prices are a bit different thing. Looking at prices in Europe, 2x8GB CL16 will cost about 70€ and CL14 about 130€. Same relative difference applies to other sizes as well. JEDEC spec is a bit of a different thing because it states 1.2V as working voltage and low voltage is what gives you 3200 CL18-22.

How much of the speedup is attributable to RAM speedup is not a single question. There are benchmarks that really don't care. Cinebench (especially R15) is a very good example.
Posted on Reply
#59
yeeeeman
dont whant to set it"'Why just now they (Intel) rejoining the inovative part of the scene , as ever since "Skylake" , it's as if Intel was in retirement cashing pension coupons or viewed another way , a multy year sabbatical.
So , in another parallel universe, I am safekeeping my 2 entry-level Skylake cpu's one being a Pentium spec whilst the other is a Celeron spec , having them donated to museums all the while story talking my children/grandchildren on how the x86 cpu's "war's" were "fought" and reminiscent of the era's when Intel was top dog in most of those , until "Ivy-Lake" .

"Good night and faa iuu"
I guess you don't read news. They had MASSIVE issues with 10nm. That is why.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 19th, 2026 03:08 PST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts