Thursday, March 17th 2022
Apple's Graphics Performance Claims Proven Exaggerated by Mac Studio Reviews
Apple made some bold claims at the launch of its new Mac Studio computers when it came to the performance of the new systems and it looks like Apple was exaggerating those claims by quite some margin when it comes to the graphics performance. The first reviews of the new Mac Studio went live today and thanks to those reviews, despite the limited benchmarks that were performed on the new systems from Apple, that as so often Apple's performance metrics are still relying on the reality distortion field. Most of the publications that got their hands on the new systems focused on CPU benchmarks and there's no doubt the Ultra version of the M1 processor is a beast when used for things like video rendering and complex image manipulation, where it's butting heads with an AMD Ryzen Threadripper 3970X.
However, Apple's 64-core GPU isn't quite what the company claimed. In the presentation footnotes Apple provided details on the "highest-end discrete GPU" that they compared to, which was an NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3090. If we were to be kind to Apple, we would say that the company was slightly off target here, but it's actually not even remotely close. Tom's Guide tested the M1 Ultra SoC in Sid Meier's Civilization 6 and got a whopping 38.85 FPS at 1440p, which is beaten soundly by a Lenovo ThinkPad P1 Gen 4 with a GeForce RTX 3070 laptop GPU that scored 64.9 FPS at 4K. Likewise, The Verge decided to test the claims and had a system with an actual GeForce RTX 3090 in it and ran Shadow of the Tomb Raider and the PC managed 142 FPS at 1080p, with the M1 Ultra coming in quite far behind at 108 FPS. Moving up to 1440p the 3090 came in at 114 FPS, with the M1 still trailing behind, if not quite as badly at 96 FPS.The issue here isn't the actual performance, as it's no doubt decent figures considering the max power draw of the Mac Studio is 370 W, far less than any PC with a GeForce RTX 3090 in it. However, Apple's inflated performance claims are getting old and tired and the company really needs to do better. It's highly unlikely that anyone will be buying a US$4999 Mac Studio to play games on, as that's what the base model with the 64-core GPU costs. As such, Apple should provide realistic benchmark comparisons, as overall the Mac Studio is an impressive piece of kit in its own right. Based on the first reviews, it's likely going to end up being used by a lot of creative companies that would normally use Macs for their workflow.
Sources:
Tom's Guide, The Verge
However, Apple's 64-core GPU isn't quite what the company claimed. In the presentation footnotes Apple provided details on the "highest-end discrete GPU" that they compared to, which was an NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3090. If we were to be kind to Apple, we would say that the company was slightly off target here, but it's actually not even remotely close. Tom's Guide tested the M1 Ultra SoC in Sid Meier's Civilization 6 and got a whopping 38.85 FPS at 1440p, which is beaten soundly by a Lenovo ThinkPad P1 Gen 4 with a GeForce RTX 3070 laptop GPU that scored 64.9 FPS at 4K. Likewise, The Verge decided to test the claims and had a system with an actual GeForce RTX 3090 in it and ran Shadow of the Tomb Raider and the PC managed 142 FPS at 1080p, with the M1 Ultra coming in quite far behind at 108 FPS. Moving up to 1440p the 3090 came in at 114 FPS, with the M1 still trailing behind, if not quite as badly at 96 FPS.The issue here isn't the actual performance, as it's no doubt decent figures considering the max power draw of the Mac Studio is 370 W, far less than any PC with a GeForce RTX 3090 in it. However, Apple's inflated performance claims are getting old and tired and the company really needs to do better. It's highly unlikely that anyone will be buying a US$4999 Mac Studio to play games on, as that's what the base model with the 64-core GPU costs. As such, Apple should provide realistic benchmark comparisons, as overall the Mac Studio is an impressive piece of kit in its own right. Based on the first reviews, it's likely going to end up being used by a lot of creative companies that would normally use Macs for their workflow.


151 Comments on Apple's Graphics Performance Claims Proven Exaggerated by Mac Studio Reviews
The M1 Ultra is a 60W CPU that scores 25k.
The M1 Pro uses 30W and scores 15k. (edit: apparently most people get 13k or a bit less)
So your 30W i9-12900k is slower than both the M1 Pro and M1 Ultra. The M1 only uses 10W.
Anyways, there is a fundamental duckup on the verge's chart, on SOTR my 3090 gets 196 fps at highest settings 1440p, yet they only get 140 at 1080p! That's how much my 5 year old 1080ti was getting. There is something very wrong there
www.anandtech.com/show/17024/apple-m1-max-performance-review/3Geekbench is a joke, it measure cache and memory latency first and foremost. I managed a 40% increased score just by clocking my ddr4 from stock no xmp to 4400c16 on a 10900k! I don't why but it loves memory
Part of the problem is you're using undervolting. Not stock voltages. The 11th gen took 82.6 watts. Do you think a stock 12900k limited without undervolt and 30W would score that high? I don't think the 12900k improved from 82 to 30W, but maybe, it is a large chip. Has DDR5 also.
I looked up Anandtech's latest review for the laptop 12900hk, but they used Cinebench R20 instead of R23. Ugh. Anyways doesn't matter ;)
Anandtech's SPEC testing also illustrates some of the nuances here: The M1 Max (8c+2ec) just about matches a 5800X (8c16t) in integer workloads, but trounces even the 5950X (16c32t) at floating point workloads. It's quite possible the massive memory bandwidth affects this too, but this is clearly a choice Apple made for a reason (i.e. it mattering to the workloads they care about). Different architectures lend themselves to different jobs in different ways. This makes like-for-like comparisons difficult, but it also means we need to be nuanced when discussing such comparisons.
Oh, and another value comparison worth making: since this is a pre-built kinda-workstation, let's look at a Lenovo Threadripper Pro comparison. Even with a 42% (!) rebate counted in, a ThinkStation P620 with a TR 3975WX, 64GB of RAM, a (no-longer-called-Quadro) RTX A4000 (close to a 3070), and a 1TB PCIe 4.0 m.2 SSD costs ... nearly $6500.
Edit: lol, misunderstood the memory configurator and accidentaly gave that config a single 64GB DIMM. With 4x16GB (sadly there's no way of filling all 8 channels at 64GB) it's $6790. Going top-of-the-line Mac Studio (same CPU, RTX A6000, 128GB RAM) puts you at about $12000 - about $3000 more than a specced out Mac Studio with 8TB of storage. Of course, one advantage of the P620 is that you can fit a whackton of GPUs, SSDs and accelerators if you want to - but it will cost you.
The 11th gen sucks, no questions about it.
No a stock 12900 wouldnt hit those numbers. BUT, the thing is, architecturally, it can achieve it. It all comes down to what Intel is willing to call a 12900k. That's a marketing decision, not a product decision. Intel decided that every chip managing to achieve 4.9 ghz at 240w is going to be named 12900k. They could just as well only choose the chips that could do that at 190w or whatever. It all comes down to how many chips Intel wants to sell as a full priced 12900k. Don't forget they are selling them for 600€, if they were selling them for 1.5k then yeah, every single 12900k would be binned to the highest degree.Yeah, was going to wonder if geekbench results have any practical ability in the real world. So thanks for explaining, cause Im not afraid to admit i was clueless.
Apple is bigger than Intel and AMD (waaaay bigger than AMD) and they can spend whatever they want in R&D. Their revenue stream is unmatched.Well, I don’t know which motherboard are you using, but definitely NO. basically every Z690 has no PL2 limit at all (it is set to 4096 that means “unlimited”).
How much it will draw depends on various factors: silicon lottery (I saw 30+ W difference between “identical” CPUs), motherboard (MSI Z690 seems to be very generous with stock voltage) and so on.
But I do agree with you: 272 W at stock is unreasonable.
By the way Cinebench R23 is not very “power hungry”. With Prime95 or OCCT I can draw way more Watts.
I’m using Strix A Gaming, so an Asus board, and I have no power limit at all (PL1=PL2=4096)
Same with the few MSI I used before.
But I don’t remember any question by the Asus :confused:
By the way… 12900K on air cooling you are courageous :D
"Civilization 6" runs in Rosetta translation from x86 based using OpenGL 4.1 that Apple depreciated ages ago.
Of course it runs poorly! These "translated" NON-NATIVE games in no way measures the power of Apple's M1, M1 Pro, M1 Max or M1 Ultra GPU.
Are any of the games tested NATIVE on the Mac M1 series of chips?
When looking at productivity tests, the M1 GPU chip kicks ass.
System Lambda Lambda Vector AMD Ryzen Threadripper PRO 3975WX s 4368 MHz (32 cores)
Uploaded December 20th, 2021
Platform Linux
Single-Core Score 1355
Multi-Core Score 34962
I would say 11,000 more in the multicore is pretty significant.
I mean I think AMD and Intel were caught a bit off guard but even the merging of the two dies with the higher end M1 Studio seems to maybe used Apple's version of what AMD started with infinity fabric. AMD's new 3D V-Cache stacking technology AMD says is adding up to 15 percent advantage in gaming for the 5800X3D compared to the 5900X and at lower voltage.
So I think it will be interesting as Intel is already doing lower and higher clocked cores and now AMD is pushing other stuff it is causing innovation. Apple will continue to be able to do it in a more power friendly manner. Yet look at the heatsink that is required to keep it cool even at like 60 watts. Half the build is heatsink and fans.I mean OpenGL hasn't been updated in nearly 5 years. Vulkan replaced it. Even if you used OpenGL for anything it doesn't support HDR I believe or anything like DLSS etc. It is just old. I don't see how any comparisons with OpenGl even make sense just because you can't get, pardon the pun, an apples to apples comparison.
I frankly don't see how 3D cache is relevant here outside of "other tech vendors are also doing exotic packaging", which, as seen above, shouldn't be news to anyone. It's an IPC (and likely efficiency) boost for AMD, but ... other than that it's not directly relevant here - it's not like the 5800X3D will be particularly more competitive with the M1 Ultra than the 5800X - that's not what it's for, and the 5950X already exists.The CPU pulls 60 watts. The full package under heavy load likely exceeds that significantly. This thing comes with a 400W PSU, after all, and it doesn't have much else consuming power. 6x15W from the TB ports + 2x10W from the USB ports + however much the motherboard and fans consume still leaves a power budget of >250W for the SoC. And given that the M1 Max pulls up to 92W under a combined CPU+GPU load, it's not unreasonable to expect the full M1 Ultra package to come close to doubling that. Remember, the total chip size here is huge - ~864mm², making the 628mm² GA102 powering the RTX 3090 look rather puny in comparison. And it's made on a much denser production node in addition to this - these two chips have 114 billion transistors, compared to the 28.3 billion of the GA102. It has a lot of resources to work with, and it can certainly use power when it needs to. Just because the CPU cores max out at around ~60W doesn't make that the package power limit - there's also the GPU, NPU, accelerators and RAM on that package. Also, have you picked up on how quiet that thing is under load? That's also a huge reason for a huge heatsink - more surface area = less need for crazy airflow to dissipate heat. It definitely doesn't have an unreasonable heatsink for its power level when taking these things into consideration.Yet a lot of MacOS game ports still run OpenGL - in part because Vulkan AFAIK isn't supported on MacOS at all. Hence why non-Metal games are problematic as benchmarks.You keep insisting on reading "most powerful chip" as "most powerful CPU". I mean, this is a slightly underclocked TR 3970X and an RTX 3070 Ti-ish on the same chip. With unheard of video playback acceleration, and a rather powerful ML accelerator. Of course that is the most powerful chip for a PC. It's not even close. It doesn't need any of its constituent parts to be the fastest for this to be true, it only needs the sum of those parts to be true. And it is - the closest chip in existence would either be the Xbox Series X APU or some of Nvidia's SoCs for self-driving cars, but even those are quite far behind in total performance compared to this.
Most powerful chip/cpu in a Apple machine, not in a PC.
Some Apple user look down on PC like some sort of lower life form, why do we care what they think or use? or how powerful or not this Apple only chip is.