Tuesday, December 12th 2023
Epic Wins Store Spat Against Google, Jury Holds Google Play Guilty of Monopolistic Practices
Epic Games won a pivotal anti-trust dispute against industry giant Google, with a Jury holding Google Play and its billing service guilty of running an illegal monopoly for the sale of software and digital assets. Epic had sued both Google and Apple of running restrictive, walled-garden marketplaces on their mobile platforms, which forced people to buy, subscribe, or pay for its products only through their marketplaces, namely Google Play and the App Store, after gouging huge revenue shares. Epic had sought to release its own marketplace, the Epic Games Store, on these platforms, so it could sell its wares just the way it does on the PC. With this favorable verdict, Epic stands to save "hundreds of millions or even billions of Dollars" in fees to Google. Meanwhile, Google stated that it is preparing to appeal in a higher court, on the basis that the Play Store isn't the only software/content marketplace, and that it is competing with Apple's App Store (although not on the same devices).
Source:
The Verge

71 Comments on Epic Wins Store Spat Against Google, Jury Holds Google Play Guilty of Monopolistic Practices
PC has done fine without a monopolized application store forever. It just works.
Malware is just as much of a recurring problem on Google's official Android application store. It doesn't solve any problem except distribution of updates.
Both Apple and Google are terrible but Android allows for options, iOS does not. Regardless of Epic, Apple is already in hot waters with the EU because of this, the Epic case brought more attention to the issue but unfortunately didn't help fast track the hole thing. It's completely ridiculous Apple has not simply been forced to open up the platform and allow users to install whatever the fuck they want.
I hope either Google or Apple file an appeal that they win, and Epic goes bankrupt.
The app stores might be a case of natural monopoly too. Probably even more so for the case of Apple, who provides all tools and everything necessary for things to run in iOS.
Google also does the same thing but in Android case it's open source. Technically speaking, for android at least there is no reason why Epic can't release their own EGS app, except not being on Google store.
The first problem is can you install stuff on android without the play store? Yes, yes you can and you don't need to pay anything to google. You can even create a completely separate app store where you make all the rules, i.e. the samsung or amazon app stores. The argument from epic is that google makes this too difficult and "scary" for consumers with warnings and such - this is a very dumb argument and should not hold any water. Hopefully the news headlines are just focusing on the more sensationalistic loss part and this was dismissed.
The second problem is google actively tries to discourage anyone who thinks of creating their own app store, both through bribes and other penalties within their power in the android ecosystem - i.e. One Plus when they wanted to pre-install fortnite and I think were considering also doing an app store. They're super guilty and there's dozen of smoking guns.
The news are focusing on the anti competitive part but the case was huge, hopefully as the dust settles more information that can be understood by laymen starts to appear.
While on the surface the ruling is great I bet Google or Apple will squeeze in some other areas of their revenue stream to make up for that "lost" profits ~ I still believe that there should be a cap on profits/margins for these megacorps but since most of the legislators across the globe are already bought I doubt that'd ever come to pass!
May be a good thing in the short/mid term for gamers etc. Not sure how this will shake out in the longer term.
We broke up Bell and they were one billionth the monopolistic scumbag company Google has become.
its funny if somebody thinks epic fights some good fight and it will benefit users they just don’t want share
I still think Epic suing for exclusivity is the biggest hypocrisy of the decade.
Although, Return to Moria and that new Avatar game look extremely appealing - I just hope they'll drop on to Steam in the not so distant future.Excellent point! Imagine owning a pub (bar) and some local brewery filing a complaint against you for selling their beer with a profit margin. How dare you? :rolleyes:
Epic's exclusivity deals on Windows games are definitely not a victory for me, but a major setback.Nothing prevents you from opening another pub. Oh, you don't have the financials, the manpower and the IP to do that properly? Poor you! :rolleyes:
Buying apps on Epic or Epic's exclusivity deals for Windows games is another topic.When an industry is expensive and difficult enough that few new players ever enter it, it is government's job to protect the customers from that monopoly and to curb anything that might be unfair to the customers and/or any potential new entrees into that field (who may be afraid to enter because of the strength and ruthlessness of the existing monopoly).
The ruling discussed seems to be out of your favour - could you tell us why? And I don't mean explaining why Epic is good or bad, but just about this ruling specifically. I fail to see how new restrictions for Google's margins could possibly hurt anyone while I see millions of customers and developers who may find this to be a small victory which will hopefully one day end up in lower altogether margins for all Google apps or something like that.