Friday, October 31st 2025

Nintendo's Creature Capture Mechanic Patent Denied

Seemingly as part of its ongoing lawsuit against Palworld's developer, Pocketpair, Nintendo applied for several patents to protect what it saw as intellectual property being ripped from Pokémon games. One of those early patent filings at the Japanese Patent Office (JPO) described effectively the creature capture mechanics you see in most Pokémon and similar games these days. The patent describes the game mechanic as throwing an object at a character, after which the computer determines whether the character in question is successfully captured. It also mentions throwing an object at a character in a game in order to limit the character's movement in the field. According to Games Fray, this patent application has now been denied, meaning Nintendo may have to find another linchpin in its ongoing lawsuit against Palworld's developer.

The denial of the patent comes after the patent office examined prior art that was submitted by an unnamed third party. As Games Fray goes on to explain, however, the decision to deny Nintendo's patent doesn't necessarily spell victory for Palworld and Pocketpair. Firstly, the patent denial is "non-final," which means Nintendo can contest the ruling and defend its position. Secondly, and this appears to be more important, while Japanese judges regularly do consult with the JPO and respect the decision of the Patent Office, the patent is non-binding, meaning the final decision is still up to the judge's discretion. For Nintendo's part, the patent in question forms a core part of a family of patents, so if it is eventually "finally" denied, Nintendo may lose additional resources to fight against its perceived threats, since that patent would weaken its claim to other patents in the patent family.
Source: Games Fray
Add your own comment

18 Comments on Nintendo's Creature Capture Mechanic Patent Denied

#1
lexluthermiester
Good! Nintendo needs a smack-down. Also,
Firstly, the patent denial is "non-final," which means Nintendo can contest the ruling and defend its position.
This is rarely successful.
Nintendo may lose additional resources to fight against its perceived threats, since that patent would weaken its claim to other patents in the patent family.
This needs to happen.
Posted on Reply
#2
DeathtoGnomes
lexluthermiesterGood! Nintendo needs a smack-down. Also,

This is rarely successful.


This needs to happen.
I want to agree with you but...I also want Nintendo to win the lawsuit since losing would set a poor precedence in gaming development paving the way for possible future plagiarism, as if there isnt enough of that already.
Posted on Reply
#3
wurschti
"Creature Capture Mechanic"... Hey Nintendo, Ghostbusters did that in 1984. What the hell are you talking about?
Posted on Reply
#4
TheToi
wurschti"Creature Capture Mechanic"... Hey Nintendo, Ghostbusters did that in 1984. What the hell are you talking about?
In Final Fantasy V we can capture a creature then release it to fight other creatures.
Ironically FFV was released on SNES lol.
Posted on Reply
#6
Squared
I think it's been 29 years and 7 months. In the US, patents last 20 years from the date of file. I'm not a patent expert but I always thought that a patent is traditionally filed before a product using it reaches public knowledge, because if someone else uses the idea in public knowledge then it's no longer patentable by you. Maybe it's different in Japan or maybe I don't understand.
Posted on Reply
#7
Dristun
Ha! Regardless, the superior Pokemon games - Shin Megami Tensei and Digimon - are safe anyway.
Posted on Reply
#8
Onasi
DeathtoGnomesI want to agree with you but...I also want Nintendo to win the lawsuit since losing would set a poor precedence in gaming development paving the way for possible future plagiarism, as if there isnt enough of that already.
No. Allowing game mechanics and concepts to be patentable is an absolutely terrible idea and, if it had been implemented in, say, the 90s, would have completely fucked the entire industry. Games are iterative in their evolution and everyone stands on the ideas of those who came before.
Posted on Reply
#9
melkor_unlimited
SquaredI think it's been 29 years and 7 months. In the US, patents last 20 years from the date of file.
If the patent is expired, you may use that.
But you can not patent it now for yourself.
Squared.. patent is traditionally filed before a product using it reaches public knowledge.
Yeah. That is the usual way. As there are always some delays between inventing something and selling it.
Patent trolls fill for patents with intention to never use them other way than as "Hammer the others into oblivion" for crossing it.
Posted on Reply
#10
windwhirl
SquaredMaybe it's different in Japan or maybe I don't understand.
Doesn't seem to be too different. You can always apply for a patent on anything that's theoretically patentable but, in all cases anywhere in the world, prior art should be examined as well.

So, if your patent is about a concept that's been long known and used by others, that patent application will likely get shot down because of "prior art". So your patent needs to have something very distinctive from previous similar concepts. If it's distinctive enough, then it might be approved, otherwise it won't be approved at all.
DristunHa! Regardless, the superior Pokemon games - Shin Megami Tensei and Digimon - are safe anyway.
Yeah, I don't think Nintendo wants these patents to go to war against someone like Bandai Namco. That'd be ridiculously costly as Bandai would likely take a number of actions that are not in Nintendo's interests at all.
Posted on Reply
#11
Vayra86
DeathtoGnomesI want to agree with you but...I also want Nintendo to win the lawsuit since losing would set a poor precedence in gaming development paving the way for possible future plagiarism, as if there isnt enough of that already.
You just answered the reality of that supposed precedence. The fact is, copying happens all the time, everywhere.

Imagine if Blizzard was going to patent the exclamation and question mark for questgivers. That's just about what Nintendo is doing here.

The only good answer is GTFO with that shit. These are game concepts and a concept on its own does not make a game, and doesn't deny anyone else from making a better game.

Games are about execution of a concept. That's what sells them. People own and play games with the exact same gameplay all the time, heck, they even are fans of specific gameplay.
This lawsuit makes no sense whatsoever, and neither does the idea that copying in games is somehow problematic. It isn't. If its about IP like Mario or Luigi, sure. But game mechanics? Its ALWAYS bad for everyone else if someone can patent those.
Posted on Reply
#12
AGlezB
DeathtoGnomesI want to agree with you but...I also want Nintendo to win the lawsuit since losing would set a poor precedence in gaming development paving the way for possible future plagiarism, as if there isnt enough of that already.
At this point in time nintendo is not preventing plagiarism but competition. Just ask yourself why they didn't apply for that patent until recently, when the Pokemon franchise is about to turn 30? They know perfectly well what'll happen when people can play the same kind of game outside their little walled garden: competition will eat them alive because they lack the width of Sony and Xbox. They've put all their eggs in one very fragile basket and now they need an army of lawyers to guard it. FFS even the Reciprocating engine patent expired in 20 years. How long do you think is OK for a company to hold on to an idea from 3 decades ago?
Posted on Reply
#13
TheinsanegamerN
DeathtoGnomesI want to agree with you but...I also want Nintendo to win the lawsuit since losing would set a poor precedence in gaming development paving the way for possible future plagiarism, as if there isnt enough of that already.
Absolutely not!

A MECHANIC should not be protected by patent! Imagine if EA did that. They could patent map screens with planets (mass effect) , or FPS game with revival mechanics (battlefield), or steering wheels that respond to player input (f1) and effectively have a monopoly on RPG, FPS, and racing games!

Thank god the courts struck this down. Imagine if ONLY gamefreak could ever make a game where you capture monsters. Monster hunter, digimon, yu gi oh, all would have to immediately cease existence.
Posted on Reply
#14
Onasi
I would also like to note that the whole shebang is INCREDIBLY funny because Nintendo is being ridiculously hypocritical. Like, guys, are you not going to acknowledge the fact that Pokemon games as a concept itself and basically their entire gameplay loop is derived directly from SMT and it was always more or less kind of quietly accepted? Like, at the end of the day, Pokémon games are turn-based RPG dungeon crawlers with a monster based party system. No? Okay then.
Posted on Reply
#15
pablo603
DeathtoGnomesI want to agree with you but...I also want Nintendo to win the lawsuit since losing would set a poor precedence in gaming development paving the way for possible future plagiarism, as if there isnt enough of that already.
HELL NO.

Mechanics SHOULD NEVER BE patented. That's like patenting an art style.
You're asking for companies to be able to freely patent WASD movement or game menus or save files and prevent ANYONE from using them until the patent expires. GET OUT WITH THAT CRAP
Posted on Reply
#16
lexluthermiester
DeathtoGnomesI want to agree with you but...I also want Nintendo to win the lawsuit since losing would set a poor precedence in gaming development paving the way for possible future plagiarism, as if there isnt enough of that already.
Your opinion of "Plagiarism" needs to be checked against the definition of same. PalWorld is infringing no more than Crystalis, Neutopia, GoldenAxe Warrior and every other type of Action Adventure game the The Legend of Zelda inspired. There is a HUGE difference between direct copying and inspired re-imagination.

If Nintendo were to win this lawsuit, it would be an absolute disaster for inspired creativity. It would effectively cripple and end the video game industry, not to mention the wide reaching effects it would have on artistic expression everywhere else. This can not be tolerated.
Posted on Reply
#17
DeathtoGnomes
lexluthermiesterIf Nintendo were to win this lawsuit, it would be an absolute disaster for inspired creativity. It would effective cripple and end the video game industry, not to mention the wide reaching effects it would have on artistic expression everywhere else. This can not be tolerated.
I lied, I did actually agree with you [all] from the start. I can say I sparked a bit of controversy with my post. Nintendo is such a bully.
Posted on Reply
#18
Steevo
Nintendo is a patent troll these days, locked down switch hardware, and software, with still buggy controls.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 18th, 2026 05:51 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts