Monday, December 22nd 2025

Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 Loses Indie Game Awards Wins Over AI Use

The Indie Game Awards has previously taken a stance against the use of generative AI, confirming that games that used generative AI during the development process are not eligible for consideration for any awards. Now, it has upheld that stance, with a new announcement from the IGA's Nomination Committee officially retracting Clair Obscur: Expedition 33's Game of the Year and Debut Game awards after Sandfall Interactive admitted to using generative AI during the production of the game. This is in spite of Sandbox Interactive previously confirming during the deliberation process that it had not used generative AI in the game. The studio later admitted to using generative AI during the development process—and accidentally shipping AI assets at launch—which goes against The Indie Game Awards's stance on the controversial technology.

The Indie Game Awards has instead awarded the Best Debut Game award to Sorry We're Closed, a story-driven survival horror game that mixes top-down navigation and exploration with arcade-style first-person shooting. Meanwhile, the 2025 Game of the Year award was awarded to Blue Prince, a "strategy puzzle adventure" roguelite game. Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 still has the multiple awards that it won during the 2025 The Game Awards, although those awards have also been called into question by the gaming community because of the game's budget and its large workforce, which some argue should disqualify it from indie status. An extended statement about the IGA retractions follows.
The Indie Game Awards have a hard stance on the use of gen AI throughout the nomination process and during the ceremony itself. When it was submitted for consideration, a representative of Sandfall Interactive agreed that no gen AI was used in the development of Clair Obscur: Expedition 33. In light of a resurfaced interview with Sandfall Interactive confirming the use of gen AI art in production being brought to our attention on the day of the Indie Game Awards 2025 premiere, this does disqualify Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 from its nomination. While the assets in question were patched out and it is a wonderful game, it does go against the regulations we have in place. As a result, the IGAs nomination committee has agreed to officially retract both the Debut Game and Game of the Year awards.

Each award will be going to the next highest-ranked game in its respective category:

Debut Game: Sorry We're Closed

Game of the Year: Blue Prince

Both à la mode games and Dogubomb have been notified and were invited to record acceptance speeches. Since the IGAs premiere took place just ahead of the holiday break, we expect both acceptance speeches to be recorded and published in early 2026.
Sources: The Indie Game Awards on Bluesky, The Indie Game Awards FAQ
Add your own comment

56 Comments on Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 Loses Indie Game Awards Wins Over AI Use

#1
Easo
So Indie Games accepted nomination months ago and now, suddenly, found out that there was some already patched out (IIRC before the nomination) AI texture content? Really?
Sounds like someone wants some drama for relevancy.
Posted on Reply
#2
RejZoR
I find this drama such an absolute bullshit. What's wrong if they used generative tools to create some assets? Can we acknowledge that gradient tool in Photoshop that has existed for literal decades and has been used by everyone, from artists to game designers is literally no different than "generative Ai"? But that's fine and generating a texture is suddenly not because Ai reeeeeeee. I'm among the people who are most against Ai, but this is getting ridiculous. There is a huge difference between creating whole generated Ai content like the current Battlefield 6 drama on some stupid badge/sticker where rifle has two barrels, two ejection ports just stacked one on top of another and no one gave a damn to check the generated result and just sent it out to production. It's entirely different if apparently a masterpiece like Expedition 33 made few assets with Ai and suddenly they are the worst of the worst somehow.

Knowing game design tools, most game engines have used generative tools for YEARS. CryEngine showcased a vegetation paintbrush tool years ago where you just selected vegetation type and simply painted it on terrain and map editor would spawn random vegetation types within that class and make a field of grass and flowers in pseudo randomized order without designer having to manually place grass. Is that not generative? Ai or not Ai, it's a stupid argument, it automatically creates something out of basically nothing, making game design faster and easier. That's one thing. Another is telling a tool to generate entire island with everything on it. That's a different thing where artist has very little of actual creative input. Both Unreal Engine and CryEngine have had tons of almost fully automatic tools for world building way before whole Ai was even a thing. How come no one brushed at it back then, but suddenly it's an issue? I don't get it.
Posted on Reply
#3
dj-electric
A game that had some AI asset most people didn't notice, that got replaced a week into the game being out doesn't get disqualified for generative AI.
To be speculative, I believe that the reason for it is simply IGA people don't want E33 to be there, and that reason sounds good enough to disqualify it.
Posted on Reply
#4
sam_86314
The way I see it, genAI is just another tool that can be used in game development, among other things. You can use it to run a slop factory, or you can use it to support development on a proper project.

Ultimately, I figure if the game is good, then who cares? Do you really think some AI-slop game would be remotely close to being in the running for GOTY?

Wait 'til they hear that DLSS and FSR4 have genAI in them. Are games that use those technologies going to be disqualified, too?

I finally started playing E33, it's pretty good, but I suck at the QTEs. I dunno if I'm just bad and need to git gud, or if the QTEs themselves are too unforgiving.

And yes, I consider E33 (and BG3 for that matter) to be indie games. They're developed by independent teams without a publisher exerting creative control. If anything, BG3 is more of an indie than E33 since it's self-published.
Posted on Reply
#5
lexluthermiester
EasoSo Indie Games accepted nomination months ago and now, suddenly, found out that there was some already patched out (IIRC before the nomination) AI texture content? Really?
Sounds like someone wants some drama for relevancy.
I'm with the Awards committee. Any game that RELEASES with AI content that helped contribute to the success of the title, regardless if it's later patched out, does not and should never qualify for any award where human skill is the primary consideration factor.
dj-electricA game that had some AI asset most people didn't notice, that got replaced a week into the game being out doesn't get disqualified for generative AI.
To be speculative, I believe that the reason for it is simply IGA people don't want E33 to be there, and that reason sounds good enough to disqualify it.
No, it's called being honest and playing by the rules. Ethics and whatnot. For me it's not about the game or how good it is in this kind of situation. It's about the merits.
Posted on Reply
#6
dj-electric
lexluthermiesterNo, it's called being honest and playing by the rules. Ethics and whatnot. For me it's not about the game or how good it is. It's about the merits.
Some hidden news post from an asset pack in some corner of a map nobody has noticed (not even me, and i'm "very sensitive" to AI slop), that got replaced a week into release, definitely had just about 0 contribution to the success of E33. I feel like considering the circumstances, and this is a very grey area no doubt, E33 could have stayed in that race. Sandfall's problem was not being more transparent about this move, I agree.
Posted on Reply
#7
lexluthermiester
dj-electricSome hidden news post from an asset pack in some corner of a map nobody has noticed (not even me, and i'm "very sensitive" to AI slop), that got replaced a week into release, definitely had just about 0 contribution to the success of E33. I feel like considering the circumstances, and this is a very grey area no doubt, E33 could have stayed in that race.
If Sandfall had written their own AI code and used it to assist and automate certain time-consuming tasks and had been upfront about it, that would be a different situation.
dj-electricSandfall's problem was not being more transparent about this move, I agree.
That's my take.
Posted on Reply
#8
HOkay
My take is that any legal tool is fair game. That said, if the rules against AI tools were there all along, & if they were asked to confirm they obeyed all the rules & lied about it, then imo that should disqualify them. But that's ultimately a stupid rule from IGA & I now have less respect for their awards.
Posted on Reply
#9
Ware
lexluthermiesterI'm with the Awards committee...For me it's not about the game or how good it is....
Sounds about right.
Awards have clearly become meaningless.
That's my take.
Posted on Reply
#10
lexluthermiester
WareSounds about right.
Awards have clearly become meaningless.
That's my take.
See edit..
Posted on Reply
#11
Darmok N Jalad
I think this is a matter of creative rights. With all of this AI talk, the argument sort of skirted past one of the bigger issues creators have with it—plagiarism. Don’t these models learn by studying existing work, and haven’t we seen cases where they are using creative works without permission from the original content provider? Comedians already sued for it. As an amateur photographer that shares content online, I know that many pros take issue with their work being used to train models that will eventually put them out of a job. It was serious enough that Adobe had to offer assurances that professional portfolios in their creative cloud were not being used to train their AI.

If so, then this is far different than some tools in photoshop that help make creating easier. It’s still being penned by an individual. Sure, that human could be copying someone else’s work, but there is more legal recourse for that. That is even a side point, as the use of AI could potentially be robbing humans of creative positions. Kindofa big deal if you’re a human in a creative field.
Posted on Reply
#12
Kinsa83
Rightfully so. Transparency so people are informed. Still going to play it at some point.
Posted on Reply
#13
TheinsanegamerN
Game developers release product without sticking foot in mouth challenge (impossible difficulty).

Why lie about it? If you know AI pisses people off, then dont use it! We've made games for half a century without AI after all!
dj-electricSome hidden news post from an asset pack in some corner of a map nobody has noticed (not even me, and i'm "very sensitive" to AI slop), that got replaced a week into release, definitely had just about 0 contribution to the success of E33. I feel like considering the circumstances, and this is a very grey area no doubt, E33 could have stayed in that race. Sandfall's problem was not being more transparent about this move, I agree.
I agree it want a major impact, but then why lie about it? Nothing pisses off people more then being lied to, whether its finding out someone is a poser, or they're fed BS about the use of AI, or finding out someone is a hypocrite.
Posted on Reply
#14
scottslayer
I can't believe the 50 person team run by the son of a billionaire didn't win an award at the Literally Who Awards, breaks my heart.
This has already been beaten to death on actual gaming sites days ago, how did it end up here finally?
Posted on Reply
#15
lexluthermiester
TheinsanegamerNWhy lie about it? If you know AI pisses people off, then dont use it! We've made games for half a century without AI after all!
Exactly right!
Posted on Reply
#16
Marcus L
Cpt.JankThis is in spite of Sandbox Interactive previously confirming during the deliberation process that it had not used generative AI in the game.
I mean this says it all, whether you agree with their requirements or not, the devs knew about them and lied only to go back on previous claims, whether it had to do specifically with Ai or another rule requirement, makes no difference
Posted on Reply
#17
FoulOnWhite
Previously taken a stance against the use of generative AI, this. They broke this rule which they must have known about. Simple
Posted on Reply
#18
Unregistered
lexluthermiesterI'm with the Awards committee. Any game that RELEASES with AI content that helped contribute to the success of the title, regardless if it's later patched out, does not and should never qualify for any award where human skill is the primary consideration factor.
Nonsense. The purpose of the rewards is ostensibly to recognize the quality of the game itself, not the individual developers. It's like claiming a new automobile that achieved double the fuel efficiency, comfort, reliability, and safety ratings of any past vehicle wasn't eligible for any awards, because an AI tool was used to help design it.
Posted on Edit | Reply
#19
Marcus L
EndymioNonsense. The purpose of the rewards is ostensibly to recognize the quality of the game itself, not the individual developers. It's like claiming a new automobile that achieved double the fuel efficiency, comfort, reliability, and safety ratings of any past vehicle wasn't eligible for any awards, because an AI tool was used to help design it.
It's nothing of the sort, if it's an entry/winning requirement no matter how much you agree with it or not then that is the rules to be eligible, they could have any rules they want, it's not law, it's an organisation that hosts an award and they can deem whatever they want as entry/winning requirement, which were clear beforehand and the game publishers/dev team lied about those particular requirements and said "oops we forgot", whether it makes sense to you or not, if it's their awards and they set out the rules to qualify and win then it is cut and clear IMO, not that it makes a difference to anything outside of the awards as the game is a resounding success.
Posted on Reply
#20
lexluthermiester
EndymioNonsense. The purpose of the rewards is ostensibly to recognize the quality of the game itself, not the individual developers.
There are rules for a reason. IF devs don't follow the rules, they are disqualified. This is not earth-shattering information. It does not take a genius to understand this very simple dynamic. Sandfall did not follow the rules and therefore...
Posted on Reply
#21
Veseleil
Strange feeling when not giving an F for either side in this dispute. Less AI the better though, but this is ridiculous.
Posted on Reply
#22
dyonoctis
Following the publication of this article, Sandfall Interactive wishes to provide the following clarifications.
The studio states that it was in contact with El País on April 25 - three months prior to this publication. During these exchanges, Sandfall Interactive indicated that it had used a limited number of pre-existing assets, notably 3D assets sourced from the Unreal Engine Marketplace. None of these assets were created using artificial intelligence.
Sandfall Interactive further clarifies that there are no generative Al-created assets in the game. When the first Al tools became available in 2022, some members of the team briefly experimented with them to generate temporary placeholder textures. Upon release, instances of a placeholder texture were removed within 5 days to be replaced with the correct textures that had always been intended for release, but were missed during the Quality Assurance process.
english.elpais.com/culture/2025-07-19/the-low-cost-creative-revolution-how-technology-is-making-art-accessible-to-everyone.html

eh. I do feel like the internet is massively overacting, even beyond the "NO AI in any shape or form, stance of the IGA. While I have strong reservations about full AI as the final output in a creative medium, I do think it can have its place for quick, early drafts or other mundane tasks.

Since 2019, using Photoshop could potentially be enough to be disqualified from those awards, with selection or patch tools now being powered by "A.I". Autodesk Maya is also about to implement an AI-assisted workflow to speed up some tasks, so using an industry standard tool might also be grounds for a disqualification.
TheinsanegamerNGame developers release product without sticking foot in mouth challenge (impossible difficulty).

Why lie about it? If you know AI pisses people off, then dont use it! We've made games for half a century without AI after all!


I agree it want a major impact, but then why lie about it? Nothing pisses off people more then being lied to, whether its finding out someone is a poser, or they're fed BS about the use of AI, or finding out someone is a hypocrite.
Depending on the timeline, they didn't lie about it. In July, they already said that they were using a tiny bit of A.I:
“We use some AI, but not much,” François Meurisse, producer of Clair Obscur, tells EL PAÍS via videoconference. “The key is that we were very clear about what we wanted to do and what to invest in. And, of course, technology has allowed us to do things that were unthinkable a short time ago,” explains Meurisse. “Unreal Engine 5’s tools and assets have been very important in improving the graphics, gameplay, and cinematics.”
But once again, it seems that Sandfall considers that using AI as placeholders isn't the same as shipping a game mostly made of AI assets. (which is something that seems to become common in the guilty trash categories of games)
Posted on Reply
#23
Unregistered
Marcus Lit's an organisation that hosts an award and they can deem whatever they want as entry/winning requirement, which were clear beforehand...
Sure, they can set whatever rules they want. But two points.

1. From a legalistic standpoint, anyone using so much as a Photoshop filter these days can be deemed to have "used AI tools". Nor would any reasonable person consider a placeholder texture that doesn't even appear in the shipping game as breaking the rules as written.

2. While a private organization can set whatever rules they want, we as private citizens have a similar right to criticize how ethical and reasonable those rules are. Would you consider it OK for this group to disqualify any team that hired female developers? What if they set a rule that any assets developed on non-Intel CPUs were disqualifying? AI is the future of asset generation. Rules like this aren't simply nonsensical -- they're stultifying to the industry as a whole.
Posted on Edit | Reply
#24
Marcus L
Endymio1. From a legalistic standpoint
You don't have a leg to stand on, there's nothing "legalistic" about it, they set the rules and you aren't obliged to enter/take part if you don't agree

2: Yes, you can have an opinion and choose to support or ignore them, makes no difference though does it. Doesn't matter what I think, they can say that only unicorn poo can be used to decorate a game for a chance to be in winning, my opinion, political persuasion doesn't mean anything, why do we care about this, the games an overwhelming success regardless
Posted on Reply
#25
Solaris17
Super Dainty Moderator
AI didnt make this game a masterpiece, committee is a bunch of tools, and to do it so late? Please. You wouldnt have handed out trophies if you needed time to think about how to handle it. Drama for the sake of drama 100% or at worst greased palms from the like of ubisoft/EA take your pick at any of the AAA that didnt win shit.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 17th, 2026 13:51 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts