Monday, October 15th 2018
NVIDIA Recreates Lunar Landing with RTX Technology and Ray Tracing
NVIDIA has released an exquisite lunar landing recreation powered by their RTX technology, bringing a fresh coat of paint to their previous iteration of the video. The new version goes to great lengths to showcase exactly what ray tracing is all about: those little, graphics-card-accelerated rays of light interact perfectly with objects and their physical qualities. This means reflections, ambient occlusion, shadows, and the entire graphics reality - no longer effects - that ensues.
Developed under Unreal Engine 4 with a ray-tracing capable graphics path, this is a serious showcase of actual physically-accurate lighting, and NVIDIA, of course, took the opportunity to throw in a time-travel joke for how good their RTX graphics cards are in rendering reality. Can't really blame the green company, though.
Developed under Unreal Engine 4 with a ray-tracing capable graphics path, this is a serious showcase of actual physically-accurate lighting, and NVIDIA, of course, took the opportunity to throw in a time-travel joke for how good their RTX graphics cards are in rendering reality. Can't really blame the green company, though.
44 Comments on NVIDIA Recreates Lunar Landing with RTX Technology and Ray Tracing
During GTC 18 Nvidia specificaly said 2spp on certain affects would be preferable at but performance wasnt there. Would mean going down to 2spp or 1spp would introduce more noise and the demo was environment only.
Should wait until the final version of the implementation are done. Going off these demos done at higher outputs that wont be feasible in a actual game isnt good for expectations.
You should ALWAYS be skeptical.
No this is no exciting at all, its I guess ok, some progress in visual fidelity but pls cool it a bit.
"Far reaching potential" yeah ok.
We fear nothing, we doubt the marketing that Nvidia put forth.
Nvidia RT is going to be part of GameWorks so there is your answer
The other RTRT demos supposedly running on DXR cannot be tested either as AMD has yet to release DXR drivers for Vega.The implementation is part of GameWorks. All the games showing off RTRT are running in DX12 with DXR. Vulkan got NV Extensions and while unclear whether it will get a generic RTRT support, there is a good chance it might. This is pretty good as far as standardization goes.
You say you see the writing on the wall - THAT is the writing on the wall. Performance is abysmal and that is underlined every time we see or hear of RTRT. And if its not, its blurry junk that, while 'dynamic', is convincingly uglier than the tried and tested approach; while still performing worse than that approach.
The quality we need in RTRT is still far beyond reach for most games in any sort of playable setting.
Last but not least, and this is very important to keep in the back of your head:
'RT cores' and the current state of Turing is just a hand-me-down from Volta. The intention was never to go all out on ray tracing, its just something that tensor is quite capable of. But almost nothing in the Turing GPU was specifically built for RTRT in games. Its still mostly meant for development work. This tech was meant for Quadro and Tesla class GPUs. That also confirms why we get cut down chips. It also confirms that yields are not fantastic, that the cost/risk is rather high, and the performance confirms that none of this was purpose built for real time RT. It just works 'okay ish' on Turing as well. That is a somewhat different, but far more realistic perspective to the 'why' behind this release, and I daresay a tad more believable than Nvidia saying they've worked on it for 10 years.
So, bottom line, for me:
- this can easily turn out to be PhysX 2.0
- industry 'support' says about nothing. Remember DX12's MGPU support? If you leave it to devs to implement, it will be scarce.
- Nvidia is destroying all incentive to saturate the market with RT capable cards (only high end, no content to trigger buyers on release, killing SLI @ midrange all contribute to this)
- Implementation today means spending resources and time for a tiny niche of the gaming market
- Ray Tracing isn't new, and trying to get it done in realtime isn't new either. If its such a holy grail, why approach it with such a sad attempt and for such a tiny subgroup of buyers? If Nvidia truly believed in it, the approach would be different.
Turing is a test vehicle for RTRT. Mark my words. If it doesn't stick, it'll remain an afterthought that will barely see implementation.
www.nvidia.com/coolstuff/demos#!/apollo-11
I was running this like the video did with 8 gb DDRIII 1600Mhz + i7 4770 & a GTX 970 STRIX.... so Nvidia is a huge fuckup nowdays....