Thursday, October 10th 2019
AMD TRX40 Chipset Not Compatible with 1st and 2nd Gen Threadrippers
AMD is giving finishing touches to its 3rd generation Ryzen Threadripper HEDT processor lineup, and the first wave of these chips, starting with a 24-core model, will launch alongside the AMD TRX40 chipset. It turns out that the chipset won't be compatible with 1st and 2nd generation Ryzen Threadripper processors. The upcoming 3rd generation Threadripper chips won't be backwards-compatible with the AMD X399 chipset, either. We've been hearing from reliable sources rumors of this segmentation from AMD for a few days now, and tech journalist ReHWolution just tweeted its confirmation having obtained info on upcoming motherboards from a leading brand.
The underlying reason between this restriction remains a mystery. We know that the EPYC "Rome" MCM is pin-compatible with first-generation EPYC "Naples" chips due to the fact that the newer chips are drop-in compatible with older servers via a BIOS update. The TR4 socket, too, is nearly identical to SP3r2, but for four out of eight memory channels being blanked out. It remains to be seen if for TRX40 motherboards, AMD re-purposed these unused pins for something else, such as additional PCIe connectivity or more electrical pins. We'll find out in November, when AMD is expected to launch these chips.
Source:
ReHWolution (Twitter)
The underlying reason between this restriction remains a mystery. We know that the EPYC "Rome" MCM is pin-compatible with first-generation EPYC "Naples" chips due to the fact that the newer chips are drop-in compatible with older servers via a BIOS update. The TR4 socket, too, is nearly identical to SP3r2, but for four out of eight memory channels being blanked out. It remains to be seen if for TRX40 motherboards, AMD re-purposed these unused pins for something else, such as additional PCIe connectivity or more electrical pins. We'll find out in November, when AMD is expected to launch these chips.

66 Comments on AMD TRX40 Chipset Not Compatible with 1st and 2nd Gen Threadrippers
But yeah, I am wondering if it is really as much as 30% even with lower clocks.Thanks for the info.
Yes I do mean when the CPU is respecting the stock TDP.
Good to know it is still 30% faster despite the clock speed drop.
Would love to test TR3 versus CascadeLake-X. At the same time I am not spending my own dime doing the comparison. I will wait for some richer labs to investigate first. :D
At the same time Intel's Deep Learning Boost on CascadeLake-X seems to support Tensorflow
www.intel.ai/accelerating-tensorflow-inference-with-intel-deep-learning-boost-on-2nd-gen-intel-xeon-scalable-processors/#gs.9bu3a8
This is also great news. It is easy to justify buying an HEDT CPU for lab workstation. Meanwhile it is extremely hard to justify buying a gaming grade GPU, although those are usually best bang for the buck accelerators. Many lab TR builds ended up with either 1030 or RX550 as VGA output.
And these new ones will probably last another generation until Zen 4 and DDR5.
For example even under AVX work loads my 1950X will stay above the 3.4Ghz base clock, usually around 3.5Ghz. With the all core boost of the 1950X rated at 3.7Ghz.
For the 7980XE the base clock is given at 2.6Ghz but under AVX2 the 7980XE drop to 2.3Ghz when respecting the stock TDP settings.
I am unable to find the AVX clock for the 9980XE.
Perspective blinkers , you and yours are not the only users of HEDT and you are in a niche ,sorry but your university is probably quite aligned to your perspective.
I think my use cases are all that matters too though, at least to me.
AmD doesn't have a specific downclocks for Avx 2 though the increased load and heat will push all core clocks down.
Ryzen is extremely temperature sensitive, with a custom loop (3x420 Rads) I am able to maintain the a Tdie of around 60~61C max in an air-conditioned room.
Edit: Also an important thing about Ryzen, is the stock TDP takes the SOC / IMC into account as well.
So faster memory or more ranks of memory do eat into the available TDP for the cores, more so if the motherboard adjust the SOC voltage.
You say that AVX-512 gives your Intel machines a 30% advantage. Have you looked at price/performance and performance/Watt?
For us at the time of 1950X and 2990WX purchase, AMD had more than a 30% advantage in both price and power use. Again, I'm talking about our use case, which is obviously not the same as yours.
My post is regarding workstation use where no overclocking is allowed and the CPU is set to respect the actual stock TDP.
Problem is, Intel has slashed price on current gen CascadeLike-X almost in half. This makes these new Intel HEDT ones very attractive. But yeah I DO NEED to see how TR3 and Cascadelake-X competes first.
TL;DR: TR was unchallenged in HEDT for the performance/cost/$, now it has challenges.
Due to the fact that Epyc has more integrated I/O, there's no need for a traditional chipset.
For Threadripper it seems like AMD decided to save some cost per chip by reducing the on-die I/O and as such, a chipset was added mainly for peripheral connectivity, but also some additional PCIe lanes.
Obviously we don't know what TRX40 and the other rumoured chipsets brings to the table, but X399 was pretty much the same as X370/X470, so I would expect TRX40 to be quite similar to X570.
This time around, as the CPU/SoC design has changed, my guess is they're doing this so they can use a more affordable I/O die for Threadripper over Epyc, or be able to use partially functional Epyc I/O dies.
This is to cause a knee jerk reaction from the user base and draw us in.
[:banghead::cry::p]