Wednesday, May 20th 2026

Valve Counters NY Loot Box Lawsuit With Official Motion To Dismiss

In February, we reported on Valve's latest legal troubles: A lawsuit brought forward by the New York State Attorney General, Letitia James, who claims that the loot box and community market systems in games like Counter-Strike amount to "quintessential gambling," and expose children and adolescents to potential gambling addiction later in life. Valve later issued a public statement dismissing the contents of the lawsuit and arguing that loot boxes are no different from physical blind-box goods, like trading cards and Labubus. Loot boxes have been controversial in gaming for almost as long as they've been around, and this lawsuit has sparked discussions about how they could be inherently predatory, but ultimately, it seems as though Valve's argument centers around the letter of the law as much as the practical applications. According to a recent filing in the New York Supreme Court, Valve is seeking to dismiss the lawsuit based on a version of the same argument presented in the aforementioned statement and interpretation of what constitutes gambling.

Valve's motion to dismiss argues that mystery boxes are not classified as gambling under New York constitutional or statutory law, arguing that "The New York Court of Appeals has interpreted "gambling" under section 9 of the New York Constitution to prohibit 'the risking of money or something of value on games of chance, as well as bets and wagers by nonparticipants on competitions of skill.'" and that "Valve's offering of mystery boxes does not 'promote gambling' under any plausible reading of these provisions because player does not 'stake or risk' anything when purchasing a mystery box, a skin is not 'something of value,' and there is no wager 'agreement' between a player and Valve." The argument also postulates that skins do not qualify as "something of value" by the verbiage of New York's gambling law, arguing that "mystery boxes are not things of value because a 'virtual in-game item or feature designed or perceived to enhance gameplay' 'can only be used within the games themselves,'" and that "a skin is not money or property."
Sources: Valve, via Courthouse News Service
Add your own comment

23 Comments on Valve Counters NY Loot Box Lawsuit With Official Motion To Dismiss

#1
sam_86314
Just remember, surprise mechanics are such ethical, very fun.

Lootboxes are gambling, full stop. I've always found it strange how people decry other companies for doing lootboxes, but when Valve does it, it's a-okay.
Posted on Reply
#2
umeng2002
"Your honor, we plead 'we did it, who cares?"
Posted on Reply
#3
LastDudeALive
sam_86314Lootboxes are gambling, full stop. I've always found it strange how people decry other companies for doing lootboxes, but when Valve does it, it's a-okay.
The point is that if the law is read this way, it obviously also applies to trading cards and many other collectable items that have existed for decades. NY isn't applying it to them, though. They're just applying it to Steam, because they want to apply political pressure to force Valve into requiring age verification and cracking down on politically disfavored games and users.

And they're right on the letter of the law. There is a difference between a slot machine, poker game, or lottery ticket, where you are putting money in and might not get any money out, as opposed to opening a loot box or MTG booster pack, where you will always get an item that will enhance your gameplay, and the monetary value is entirely dependent on what third-parties are willing to pay for it. That's like saying a Pac-Man machine is gambling, because I may win a certain amount of tickets for it, which I can exchange for a lollipop and sell it to my brother for 25c.

Three things can be true at once. Lootboxes/booster packs are bad, they are not regulated by existing laws against gambling (or at least the law at issue here), and NY is doing this for political reasons, not to protect children.
Posted on Reply
#4
mikesg
Poor explanation by Valve... It's not risking money because it's a straight up purchase. The same as trading cards.
Posted on Reply
#5
sbacc
sam_86314Just remember, surprise mechanics are such ethical, very fun.

Lootboxes are gambling, full stop. I've always found it strange how people decry other companies for doing lootboxes, but when Valve does it, it's a-okay.
Considering the number of marketplace that sells skins for real money, out in the open (those are not some obscure, crypto only discord market) and that Valve have never done anything to stop them, either by going directly after them or by adjusting their game sytem design to make such transactions or trade impossible. Any non corrupt juge would never accept this. Those skin, clearly, have value.

And yes pokemon cards are exactly the same and having a system where only parents could buy them (for their children) should be in place. And before people start complaining, there is already a lot of products thats only adult can buy even if their usage (or consumption) is or can be done by children, medication for exemple (at least in a good number of countries)
Posted on Reply
#6
Bobaganoosh
If only Valve didn't assign a monetary value to all digital items one can purchase or "own" even without being "property". Oh wait.
Posted on Reply
#7
yfn_ratchet
NY would probably have a much stronger case if they went after the real-money marketplace mechanic instead of the actual lootboxes themselves, because it's Valve fostering a first-party marketplace service for these items (where you can assign monetary value to these quintessentially worthless items) that pushes them into what I would consider a gambling environment. Valve is, albeit indirectly, promoting the idea that you could turn a profit from opening cases, even if that's not the intended design.

Though on the other hand, while valuations are made in real dollars, the moment you sell a skin that 'money' becomes Steam store credit, and may not qualify as a money transaction on those grounds since (afaik) you cannot exfiltrate the money through any official Valve channels. The money stays below the surface when the system is used as intended.
Posted on Reply
#8
Freedom4556
We simply need to alter the definition in the law to define all "mystery boxes" as illegal gambling, physical or digital. The physical versions were never okay, either, we just tolerated it because the stakes were limited by the need to make tangible goods.

They don't call Magic: The Gathering "cardboard crack" as a joke. It's just as addictive and pointing the finger at the real goods of the past is no defense to the excesses of microtransactions.
Posted on Reply
#9
LastDudeALive
Freedom4556We simply need to alter the definition in the law to define all "mystery boxes" as illegal gambling, physical or digital.
So the existing law against gambling does not cover mystery cases/booster packs, and NY's lawsuit is without merit and should be dismissed with prejudice. I'm glad you agree with Valve.
Posted on Reply
#10
TheinsanegamerN
LastDudeALiveThe point is that if the law is read this way, it obviously also applies to trading cards and many other collectable items that have existed for decades. NY isn't applying it to them, though. They're just applying it to Steam, because they want to apply political pressure to force Valve into requiring age verification and cracking down on politically disfavored games and users.

And they're right on the letter of the law. There is a difference between a slot machine, poker game, or lottery ticket, where you are putting money in and might not get any money out, as opposed to opening a loot box or MTG booster pack, where you will always get an item that will enhance your gameplay, and the monetary value is entirely dependent on what third-parties are willing to pay for it. That's like saying a Pac-Man machine is gambling, because I may win a certain amount of tickets for it, which I can exchange for a lollipop and sell it to my brother for 25c.

Three things can be true at once. Lootboxes/booster packs are bad, they are not regulated by existing laws against gambling (or at least the law at issue here), and NY is doing this for political reasons, not to protect children.
Ding ding ding! We have a winner.

New York has no problem fully legalizing sports betting and in person gambling. They do not care about their citizens well being or financial security.
Posted on Reply
#11
Panther_Seraphin
I have a feeling there will need to be a change in the definition of Gambling before this will have a serious chance of winning.

The main reason Valve gets a "pass" in regards to its loot boxes is that it does not make its games "Pay 2 Win" that a lot of others indirectly make it. The skins have a monetary value set by the community due to rarity etc. but either have 0 impact ala CS:Go/CS2 or offer a slightly different gameplay style ala TF2.

Games like FIFA etc if you arent pouring mass amounts of money into it actually put you at a disadvantage in gameplay, hence where the term Pay 2 Win comes from and the lines blur between Loot Box and Pay 2 Win in a lot of publishers BUT valve.
Posted on Reply
#12
Onasi
Valve are correct, as the law is written and applied now their boxes are not gambling. They obviously are EFFECTIVELY and from an ethical standpoint, but the law doesn’t cover them. Of course, the law can be changed to reflect that, but that takes time and doesn’t apply retroactively anyway. So, in this instance, it really isn’t likely that Valve loses this. However, I do think that essentially anything with a monetary component and relying on chance should absolutely be classified as gambling. Though how would it be regulated is another question, things like gachas so far have been able to get away with just disclosing the odds. Which is what Valve is also doing. So if we regulate that, than the gacha games go in the same pile and how would that go considering how much money is in that industry… it really is a complex topic. Far more so than “Valve bad, make them stop boxes”.
Posted on Reply
#13
AusWolf
"A skin is not something of value" - right, so why is it sold for real money?
Posted on Reply
#14
FoulOnWhite
sam_86314Just remember, surprise mechanics are such ethical, very fun.

Lootboxes are gambling, full stop. I've always found it strange how people decry other companies for doing lootboxes, but when Valve does it, it's a-okay.
I agree, lootboxes are gambling. pay for something with a chance of winning something, is a gamble.
Posted on Reply
#15
close
LastDudeALiveThe point is that if the law is read this way, it obviously also applies to trading cards and many other collectable items that have existed for decades. NY isn't applying it to them, though. They're just applying it to Steam, because they want to apply political pressure to force Valve into requiring age verification and cracking down on politically disfavored games and users.

And they're right on the letter of the law. There is a difference between a slot machine, poker game, or lottery ticket, where you are putting money in and might not get any money out, as opposed to opening a loot box or MTG booster pack, where you will always get an item that will enhance your gameplay, and the monetary value is entirely dependent on what third-parties are willing to pay for it. That's like saying a Pac-Man machine is gambling, because I may win a certain amount of tickets for it, which I can exchange for a lollipop and sell it to my brother for 25c.

Three things can be true at once. Lootboxes/booster packs are bad, they are not regulated by existing laws against gambling (or at least the law at issue here), and NY is doing this for political reasons, not to protect children.
If the "always pays out" made it not gambling, every bit of gambling out there would cost you 1c extra and always return at least the 1c. Every poker hand, spin of the roulette wheel, every pull of that slot machine handle. Hey presto, you're a winner at this totally not gambling thing mate!

And at least to play PacMan you had to walk up to the arcade and queue. Now everyone has it in every room of their house so to speak, always one click away.

I don't want Valve to become another internet cop validating "definitely just age". But let's not pretend that putting in money to open "surprise mechanics boxes" until you get the one thing that's really worth a damn is anything but gambling.
Posted on Reply
#16
Panther_Seraphin
FoulOnWhiteI agree, lootboxes are gambling. pay for something with a chance of winning something, is a gamble.
and this is where the wording is very key

pay for something with a chance of winning something, is a gamble.

Traditionally with gambling there is a chance of not wining anything which makes it a gamble, with Loot boxes your always going to get SOMETHING, just maybe not exactly what you want.
This is also where if you do it to Valve then suddenly Football, Magic, Pokemon, every single trading card game, every single collectors etc now runs afoul of the new wording/intention.
Posted on Reply
#17
LastDudeALive
closeIf the "always pays out" made it not gambling, every bit of gambling out there would cost you 1c extra and always return at least the 1c. Every poker hand, spin of the roulette wheel, every pull of that slot machine handle. Hey presto, you're a winner at this totally not gambling thing mate!
And there's still the chance I'll lose the other 1c. With a loot box/booster pack, I will always get what is advertised, a random skin/card I can use in the game.

Many people buying cases/booster packs don't ever resell their skins or MTG cards on marketplaces, they just have fun with what they get. How many people go to casinos or gas stations just to collect chips/lotto tickets? Nobody.
Posted on Reply
#18
FoulOnWhite
Panther_Seraphinand this is where the wording is very key

pay for something with a chance of winning something, is a gamble.

Traditionally with gambling there is a chance of not wining anything which makes it a gamble, with Loot boxes your always going to get SOMETHING, just maybe not exactly what you want.
This is also where if you do it to Valve then suddenly Football, Magic, Pokemon, every single trading card game, every single collectors etc now runs afoul of the new wording/intention.
Could putting something in there just be a trick to make it not look like a gamble. Why not just make the chance of getting a nice item part of the gameplay rather than making it a paid for chance by buying an item with a chance of getting it. At the least it is a money grab if not gambling.
Posted on Reply
#19
Panther_Seraphin
FoulOnWhiteCould putting something in there just be a trick to make it not look like a gamble. Why not just make the chance of getting a nice item part of the gameplay rather than making it a paid for chance by buying an item with a chance of getting it. At the least it is a money grab if not gambling.
To answer the 1st point, currently I think that is what is preventing the lootbox mechanic being an our right "gamble" slam dunk

2nd Point a lot of games do that and the "loot box" mechanic is purely just to increase the amount of chances you get. Now can you argue pity mechanics are preying as they will guarantee people put in X amount to make sure they "win"?
Posted on Reply
#20
yfn_ratchet
Panther_Seraphinpay for something with a chance of winning something, is a gamble.

Traditionally with gambling there is a chance of not wining anything which makes it a gamble, with Loot boxes your always going to get SOMETHING, just maybe not exactly what you want.
This is also where if you do it to Valve then suddenly Football, Magic, Pokemon, every single trading card game, every single collectors etc now runs afoul of the new wording/intention.
This is also what gets me. In a good amount of games with lootbox mechanics, there are methods of opening them without any sort of monetary expense. Whether it's actually feasible to 'grind' out the lootboxes varies, but theoretically you can. This is another pain point for Valve—Valve monetizes every case/box opening by charging a fee in the form of a key. You cannot acquire these keys for free. Even if someone charitably donates a hoard of keys to you, those keys cost that person money.

If this lawsuit induces a change, I would very much enjoy the change of keys being added to the pool of after-match rewards. It would enrich the item-for-item marketplace mechanics by facilitating people trading for keys that match their crates, or vice versa. It would also likely HEAVILY drive down the price of all skins because their apparent rarity is going to be diluted by people farming (or just casually opening) cases. I don't actually mind lootboxes that much, though that's from someone who has never spent a dollar on a box.
Posted on Reply
#21
RoryEjinn
LastDudeALiveThere is a difference between a slot machine, poker game, or lottery ticket, where you are putting money in and might not get any money out, as opposed to opening a loot box or MTG booster pack, where you will always get an item that will enhance your gameplay, and the monetary value is entirely dependent on what third-parties are willing to pay for it. That's like saying a Pac-Man machine is gambling, because I may win a certain amount of tickets for it, which I can exchange for a lollipop and sell it to my brother for 25c.
(added emphasis is mine)

That's the rub isn't it. You are correct that the value of a TCG booster pack is based solely on what third-parties are willing to pay. The problem is that Valve is the the third party here. Valve's lootboxes are a lot closer to gambling than a TCG booster pack. For one, the TCG booster pack's value is entirely dependent on third party markets. The company selling me the TCG booster packs isn't going to pay me for the cards I get. This falls apart at Valve because they charge you real money for the key to open the lootbox which may then produce an item that might be worth more or less than the money you spent on the key. You then convert that item to money by selling it on Valve's marketplace where Valve will pay you in wallet funds that you can then use in their store to buy real items. It's basically a slot machine and the entire process occurs inside Valve's ecosystem (Casino).

This is further complicated by the fact that Valve disallows selling some of the items you get from lootboxes (deciding their value is essentially 0$) and imposes a minimum floor across the marketplace ($0.03 - effectively deciding their value is at least $0.03).

I don't think this is quite as cut and dry as people make it and it's wholly separate issue from TCG Booster Packs (Though I'd be okay with those being regulated too). At the least, Valve arguing the items have no value is just ridiculous as they themselves say each item is at least worth $0.03.
Posted on Reply
#22
LastDudeALive
RoryEjinnThis is further complicated by the fact that Valve disallows selling some of the items you get from lootboxes (deciding their value is essentially 0$) and imposes a minimum floor across the marketplace ($0.03 - effectively deciding their value is at least $0.03).
Those are actually good reasons that this isn't gambling. Is there any casino that says that some random poker chips you win may not be cashed in? No. But can a video game developer decide to disallow sharing certain items in a video game, including preventing the sale of those digital items for real money to third parties? Sure, it's their game, they can do what they want.

And the minimum floor isn't Valve dictating the value. It's Valve ensuring that server costs for hosting the marketplace are covered. Valve isn't buying the skins. If the skin isn't worth $0.03 to a third party, it won't sell even if it's listed. Every online retailer has similar policies. The minimum price for an eBay listing is $0.99. Is eBay running a casino because you can buy MTG booster packs, and they won't let you list the individual cards for less than $0.99, thus they're "deciding their value?" Of course not, that's silly.
Posted on Reply
#23
close
LastDudeALiveAnd there's still the chance I'll lose the other 1c. With a loot box/booster pack, I will always get what is advertised, a random skin/card I can use in the game.

Many people buying cases/booster packs don't ever resell their skins or MTG cards on marketplaces, they just have fun with what they get. How many people go to casinos or gas stations just to collect chips/lotto tickets? Nobody.
You need to make up your mind. First you said it's not gambling if "you will always get an item". Now you move the goalposts and it's still gambling if you could lose that item later? Fine, you can lose any item or its value from that marketplace too with a bad trade, or because in a move worse than gambling, you don't own or control any of your winnings any legal sense. The Valve TOS says it clearly: The Content and Services are licensed, not sold. Your license confers no title or ownership in the Content and Services.

And it happened. CS2 item market loses nearly $2B in value overnight due to “trade up” update. Once rare $14K knife now sells for $7K, some common guns jump from $10 to over $100.

If it was as easy as "not gambling if you always get something" every not-gambling outfit in the country would license you for every non-bet a super valuable nifty NFT that enhances your whatever in their exclusive marketplace. They control the supply, the value, and get a cut on every sale. They'd make money hand over fist on not gambling, and on whoever bothers to sell their "valuable item" in that marketplace.

You're gambling with real money to win monopoly money.

This lawsuit probably has nothing to do with gambling and is all about politics and maybe some money laundering schemes. Whatever the result, count on you (the average Joe) not actually winning anything. This is not a legal opinion, just a moral, common sense one. Feel free to disregard it, sense is not that common anyway.[/url]
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 19th, 2026 16:44 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts