Monday, July 20th 2026

Ex-Valve Writer Says Consumers Pushed PlayStation To Kill the Disc

Unsurprisingly, there has been more than a little backlash following Sony's recent decision to end the production of physical games media in 2028. Much of that backlash has been met with questions from skeptics about the real-world success of physical media compared to digital, and even game preservation experts have highlighted that the death of physical media hardly changes the landscape, given the dependence on day-one patches.

Now, former Valve employee, and writer for Left 4 Dead, Chet Faliszek, has added his voice to the chorus questioning the backlash, with the writer arguing in a recent YouTube video that Sony's decision is purely a result of consumer choice. He argues that consumers and gamers created the circumstances that drove Sony to make the decision to end physical media production by preferring digital media.
The majority of his argument hinges on Sony's sales figures, citing financial results that show 78% of game sales on the PS5 and PS4 in the 2025 financial year were digital downloads and not physical media—only 2% more than the previous year. He goes on to cite examples like GameStop's figures that show just 18% of the company's revenue comes from games, Xbox Game Pass, which is a digital subscription service.
You, the consumer, have made a choice, and your choice is for digital. I keep seeing this, like, 'Oh, they should do memory cards. They should do…' Right now, today - the games we are talking about are available at retail today. The used games are available at retail today, and you aren't going into retail and buying them.
Comments on the video are mixed, with some agreeing with his sentiment, while others point out that 22% of game sales is still a significant portion of the overall consumer base. Others pointed out that GameStop itself has acknowledged that a large portion of its revenue is from trading cards, which are currently a hot commodity for speculative investment, so those sales are inflated.

Others still argued that, while digital games have won out as the more convenient option, that's not for nothing, since many games launch to digital marketplaces weeks or months before the physical versions are available. Additionally, pre-orders and game preloading is a practice that has become all the more common in the modern gaming market, all of which serve to incentivize gamers to pick up digital copies of games instead of physical copies. There are also those who pointed out that the issue isn't really the physical media at all; rather the issue that it effectively turns the PlayStation Store into a monopoly for PlayStation games.
Source: Chet Faliszek on YouTube
Add your own comment

58 Comments on Ex-Valve Writer Says Consumers Pushed PlayStation To Kill the Disc

#1
Dr. Dro
I honestly understand the desire for something tangible, physical. But gaming has evolved past that, even for consoles. With the data changes that modern games have - patches, update, content, all things we've come to expect, write-once physical media has become completely obsolete. Physical, especially optical media which is extremely slow is best left for movies (the home video industry was killed by streaming services that are much more practical) or high-fidelity audio (another area where streaming has dealt physical media a serious blow).

It's getting increasingly niched in retro gaming or steelbook deluxe releases of older games and movies, and predictably so. Personally I have absolutely no love for physical media, it's completely worthless to me as goodies that once came with discs are no longer included with standard editions, the limitations of optical media, which is also prone to damage, and these releases are usually laden with DRM.

Digital files on an HDD + a dock can't be beat.
Posted on Reply
#2
JustBenching
I don't care about physical media but going with his own data - 22% of sales being still physical - that's a HUGE market. If it was 95%-98% digital i'd get it, but 22%, holy cow.
Posted on Reply
#3
azrael
You, the consumer, have made a choice, and your choice is for digital.
Hmm... I might be in the minority here, but to me at least it seems as if companies have made that choice for me. If physical releases are cut back by companies more and more in favour of digital ones how do I have a choice? That also holds true for things like (UHD) Blu-ray and CDs.
Posted on Reply
#4
Frick
Fishfaced Nincompoop
azraelHmm... I might be in the minority here, but to me at least it seems as if companies have made that choice for me. If physical releases are cut back by companies more and more in favour if digital ones how do I have a choice? That also holds true for things like (UHD) Blu-ray and CDs.
I very clearly remember when Steam arrived and people loved it because they didn't have to buy discs.
Posted on Reply
#5
londiste
FrickI very clearly remember when Steam arrived and people loved it because they didn't have to buy discs.
I very clearly remember when Steam arrived and everybody hated it because of all the same reasons that come up with Playstation now. Then Valve had to strong-arm players with Half-life 2 being Steam-only to get the player base there. Granted, Valve has later been relatively benevolent about things that helped the popularity but we surely do not expect the same approach from Sony.
Posted on Reply
#6
Onasi
Chet is based and also fully correct in this. I already mentioned that the choice for digital has been made on PC years ago. Consoles are just catching up.
londisteI very clearly remember when Steam arrived and everybody hated it because of all the same reasons that come up with Playstation now.
Kind of, sort of. The pushback against Steam in 2004 was far, far more understandable on every level than going “I don’t want digital distribution” in 2026. Situations are vastly different. People aren’t really running 56k modems anymore.
Posted on Reply
#8
GodisanAtheist
Steam on PC is kinda a weird case.

PC games were always the redheaded stepchild at any EB Games/Gamestop/Toys R' Us, usually relegated to some crappy trolly somewhere while the current console gen games got all the wall space.

Additionally, thanks to the basically infinite backward compatibility of PCs, a gamer was never going to find the entire PC gaming library at one stop while consoles cycled through generations pretty regularly.

As such, PC is sort of uniquely suited for digital downloads in a way that consoles never were.

OFC console manufacturers and publishers would rather resell those old, now backward compatible games, to a new and familiar audiences as "remasters" than simply allowing old fashioned backward compatibility. Killing the used game market would be a huge for them as well.
Posted on Reply
#9
Dr. Dro
GodisanAtheistSteam on PC is kinda a weird case.

PC games were always the redheaded stepchild at any EB Games/Gamestop/Toys R' Us, usually relegated to some crappy trolly somewhere while the current console gen games got all the wall space.

Additionally, thanks to the basically infinite backward compatibility of PCs, a gamer was never going to find the entire PC gaming library at one stop while consoles cycled through generations pretty regularly.

As such, PC is sort of uniquely suited for digital downloads in a way that consoles never were.

OFC console manufacturers and publishers would rather resell those old, now backward compatible games, to a new and familiar audiences as "remasters" than simply allowing old fashioned backward compatibility. Killing the used game market would be a huge for them as well.
Entirely due to market segmentation and the way Americans introduced video games as "toys" as early as the 1983 crash if not before that, a notion I utterly reject with stronger and stronger feelings as I grow older and hopefully, wiser. We still deal with the consequences of this choice, even in other regions where this never held up, in the form of censorship and console manufacturer gatekeeping. PCs were never marketed as toys, which is why you wouldn't find PC games in... what's effectively a toy shop. One of the centerpieces of the blanket ban on ESRB AO games is that retail chains refuse to carry "objectionable adult material", it would be hilarious if it wasn't so morally bankrupt and sad.
Posted on Reply
#10
Kinsa83
Hes not wrong. People act with convience most of the time and dont often think of other scenerios. I keep some physical media around for those times when the internet goes out.
Posted on Reply
#11
Onasi
GodisanAtheistPC games were always the redheaded stepchild at any EB Games/Gamestop/Toys R' Us, usually relegated to some crappy trolly somewhere while the current console gen games got all the wall space.
That’s mostly a western thing, especially Murica. Plenty of markets were and are PC first.


@Dr. Dro
And all that too, yeah. Even the famed “crash” is actually widely misunderstood and is somewhat of a myth - said crash was solely console and US based. It wasn’t some sort of industry-wide correction or systemic failure, as it became erroneously known for… some reason.
Posted on Reply
#12
happytohear
Sony's decision is purely a result of consumer choice.
Absolutely not purely based on consumer choice. Sony is a capitalist business aiming for maximized profits. Money is the top priority. It's obvious that anyone claiming the consumers is at fault is inaccurate or lying by omission. There is simply more money left for Sony in digital licenes.

Posted on Reply
#13
faquino
Since the arrival of internet-connected consoles, the content on a game disc is often pure garbage, preventing you from even starting or finishing the game. It's been a long time since you hadn't to download a zero-day patch just to get the game working. On top of that, the physical version requires you to keep the disc inserted to play, just to make noise and wear out the drive. It's not like I'm going to knock on my neighbor's door to borrow the disc to boot the game.

If this was a choice, it's been a forced one. I don't think this situation was caused by the gamers themselves, to be honest. Certainly we should have flooded the platforms with class-action lawsuits every time a game was released in such deplorable condition. Perhaps we can still create a platform with that purpose.
Posted on Reply
#14
Frick
Fishfaced Nincompoop
londisteI very clearly remember when Steam arrived and everybody hated it because of all the same reasons that come up with Playstation now. Then Valve had to strong-arm players with Half-life 2 being Steam-only to get the player base there. Granted, Valve has later been relatively benevolent about things that helped the popularity but we surely do not expect the same approach from Sony.
At the time it certinaly felt like a minority... In any case it didn't take long for people embracing it.
Posted on Reply
#15
Vayra86
Cpt.Jankthe issue isn't really the physical media at all; rather the issue that it effectively turns the PlayStation Store into a monopoly for PlayStation games.
Holy shit... sherlock is in the building guys! Watch out Sony, they're on to you now!

Playstation is a monopoly for Playstation games? I need some therapy to get over this I think.
But hey, hey, console gamer... look at this thing called PC. Its really nice. You can even keep using your dualshocks
Dr. DroEntirely due to market segmentation and the way Americans introduced video games as "toys" as early as the 1983 crash if not before that, a notion I utterly reject with stronger and stronger feelings as I grow older and hopefully, wiser. We still deal with the consequences of this choice, even in other regions where this never held up, in the form of censorship and console manufacturer gatekeeping. PCs were never marketed as toys, which is why you wouldn't find PC games in... what's effectively a toy shop. One of the centerpieces of the blanket ban on ESRB AO games is that retail chains refuse to carry "objectionable adult material", it would be hilarious if it wasn't so morally bankrupt and sad.
This is just one of the many, many reasons I never liked physical retail. Like really... you waited last week because you saw some item and return to hear 'its out of stock'... or 'yeah I still have one here, but its slightly damaged, but you can have it for five bucks less'... or you already know and see you're paying way too much to begin with, as the shop's margin is just gross.

Somehow I've barely if ever met a shop that was really making my life simpler every purchase. Online shops though? They definitely do that, a lot even. Digital distribution is much the same. I really do NOT see the disadvantage especially on a PC platform where you have libraries full of tooling to yank out any kind of DRM you get fed up with. A digital purchase is also automagically insured or at least has a paper trail you can use if need be. You're not saving a paper receipt where the ink wears off after a month; etc etc.

And let's not begin to mention the overwhelming amount of physical stores that just simply offer poor service all the way, prior, during and post purchase. They exist and I've had my share of them. There is also no benefit to holding a physical item like a dishwasher or something. Clothing, I can get into, to some degree, needs a physical store, just like more unique items and local/gifts might do. Everything else? I couldn't care less.
Posted on Reply
#16
Onasi
@Vayra86
…do people believe that buying a physical copy off GameStop (or whatever, I don’t know where Muricans buy their discs) is somehow avoiding giving money to Sony because it’s not their store? I, uh… that’s not how closed ecosystems work?

I suppose it’s just phrased clumsily and the implication is that you can only buy games for your PS in the PS Store and have no alternative ways to acquire them, which… I guess that is a concern, somewhat. But again - it’s a fucking closed ecosystem, what did you expect? Petition the EU to allow alternative storefronts or something, I dunno.
Posted on Reply
#17
Vayra86
Onasi@Vayra86
…do people believe that buying a physical copy off GameStop (or whatever, I don’t know where Muricans buy their discs) is somehow avoiding giving money to Sony because it’s not their store? I, uh… that’s not how closed ecosystems work?

I suppose it’s just phrased clumsily and the implication is that you can only buy games for your PS Plus n the PS Store and have no alternative ways to acquire them, which… I guess that is a concern, somewhat. But again - it’s a fucking closed ecosystem, what did you expect? Petition the EU to allow alternative storefronts or something, I dunno.
I honestly don't know what people believe but I do know the % of stupidity in the internet discourse is way above 50% and this article breathes it. Damn son
Posted on Reply
#18
Dr. Dro
Onasi@Vayra86
…do people believe that buying a physical copy off GameStop (or whatever, I don’t know where Muricans buy their discs) is somehow avoiding giving money to Sony because it’s not their store? I, uh… that’s not how closed ecosystems work?

I suppose it’s just phrased clumsily and the implication is that you can only buy games for your PS in the PS Store and have no alternative ways to acquire them, which… I guess that is a concern, somewhat. But again - it’s a fucking closed ecosystem, what did you expect? Petition the EU to allow alternative storefronts or something, I dunno.
Yes, it's actually thrown around a lot especially considering digital full price and physical clearance sales. End of the day people want cheap stuff, but PlayStation isn't the platform for cheap, especially with that subsidized hardware, if anything, they're actually aware that prices are worse and they still choose that platform.
Posted on Reply
#19
Vayra86
Dr. DroYes, it's actually thrown around a lot especially considering digital full price and physical clearance sales. End of the day people want cheap stuff, but PlayStation isn't the platform for cheap, especially with that subsidized hardware, if anything, they're actually aware that prices are worse and they still choose that platform.
Mainstream-peer-pressure-logic, that. Its the same reason you watch football or listen to pop music; not because it somehow benefits you, but because everyone does. And the reality check never comes, because surely its not that crappy, right? But yes, it really is that crappy, there's just a lot of cognitive dissonance in the way of clear thought.
Posted on Reply
#20
Lanmanna
Dr. DroSteam is 23 years old. Back in 2003, we were using Internet Explorer 6, Windows Update was a webpage, and waaaow you have a Pentium 4 with 512 RAM? Dayumm! Needless to say, the landscape was quite different. Many people still relied on agonizingly slow dial-up (I presume you are old enough to remember "linkin park - numb.mp3" with cassette quality that took 3 hours to download), downloading DVD-sized games on ISDN or early ADSL that when it was good, topped at like 4 Mbps download speeds wasn't exactly feasible.

But it is 2026. You live in the age of Starlink. It doesn't matter if you live in the middle of Nowhere, you have high-speed internet available at reasonable latencies, and any modern computer has enough storage capacity to handle game downloads. They are also easily upgradable, despite the recent pricing situation.

There are only negatives, no positives whatsoever for physical media in modern game platforms, and even for home video and music, it remains niched in a high-definition, high-fidelity, premium distribution medium. I just don't really see the point. Even if we bring the data caps argument, it's a matter of consumer pressure, you tell your ISP to go to hell, once enough competition happens, the data caps problem will be solved on its own.
You literally can't think of one positive to physical? How about the fact that you can trade and sell your games? Or buy games when they're on clearance or deeply discounted? Are you're that quick to forget how Sony removed Studio Canal TV shows/movies? Literally happened a week before Sony announced the end of physical. And it's not like they were delisted. They removed them from people's libraries. Sure, someone could lose their physical collection by a fire or robbery but at least Sony can't show up and take them from you.
faquinoSince the arrival of internet-connected consoles, the content on a game disc is often pure garbage, preventing you from even starting or finishing the game. It's been a long time since you hadn't to download a zero-day patch just to get the game working. On top of that, the physical version requires you to keep the disc inserted to play, just to make noise and wear out the drive. It's not like I'm going to knock on my neighbor's door to borrow the disc to boot the game.

If this was a choice, it's been a forced one. I don't think this situation was caused by the gamers themselves, to be honest. Certainly we should have flooded the platforms with class-action lawsuits every time a game was released in such deplorable condition. Perhaps we can still create a platform with that purpose.
A majority of PS5 games are playable to the end without patches. Just look at the site DoesItPlay. Even without using the disc drive, you're still wearing out the SSD/HDD.


I don't get why some people are gungho about this. If you're already digital, it has no effect on you. It's not like games will get cheaper, which I've heard before. It didn't happen when digital was first introduced. It won't happen now. It's just less choice for consumers.
Posted on Reply
#21
Pasi123
I've bought almost all of my console games from thrift stores for below PlayStation store prices. If there's no physical games then I wont be buying a new console. Though I do understand that I'm the type of person Sony wants to get rid of. If there's no used physical games then everyone has to buy them from the PS store.
Onasi@Vayra86
…do people believe that buying a physical copy off GameStop (or whatever, I don’t know where Muricans buy their discs) is somehow avoiding giving money to Sony because it’s not their store? I, uh… that’s not how closed ecosystems work?

I suppose it’s just phrased clumsily and the implication is that you can only buy games for your PS in the PS Store and have no alternative ways to acquire them, which… I guess that is a concern, somewhat. But again - it’s a fucking closed ecosystem, what did you expect? Petition the EU to allow alternative storefronts or something, I dunno.
Where do they get the money from if I buy a used 5€ game from a thrift store and play it on a console that too was bought from a thrift store? Sure the individuals I bought games from might use the money to buy some new games but I wouldn't count that
Posted on Reply
#22
Onasi
Pasi123Where do they get the money from if I buy a used 5€ game from a thrift store and play it on a console that too was bought from a thrift store? Sure the individuals I bought games from might use the money to buy some new games but I wouldn't count that
Used games are an aberration in the eyes of publishers and would be on their way out regardless. That writing was on the wall for a while. They are completely irrelevant to the conversation, might as well bring up the fact that one can theoretically acquire games from… alternative sources without giving any money to the publisher either.
Posted on Reply
#23
Dr. Dro
LanmannaYou literally can't think of one positive to physical? How about the fact that you can trade and sell your games? Or buy games when they're on clearance or deeply discounted? Are you're that quick to forget how Sony removed Studio Canal TV shows/movies? Literally happened a week before Sony announced the end of physical. And it's not like they were delisted. They removed them from people's libraries. Sure, someone could lose their physical collection by a fire or robbery but at least Sony can't show up and take them from you.
Not interested in flipping games "I don't want anymore" because I'm short on cash. Besides, I haven't been a console gamer for 20 years. That's a little under two thirds of my time on this planet. If you're reliant on selling and flipping games "you've finished", I'm sorry to say, but video games should be extremely low on your priority list. Maybe a second job would help.
Posted on Reply
#24
Hecate91
LanmannaI don't get why some people are gungho about this. If you're already digital, it has no effect on you. It's not like games will get cheaper, which I've heard before. It didn't happen when digital was first introduced. It won't happen now. It's just less choice for consumers.
Some are incredibly excited over this because they think it'll cause a shift over to PC gaming, a majority of console users won't deal with the hassles of a PC such as Windows updates or whatever Microslop decides to break, or the higher upfront cost of buying or building a PC. PC enthusiasts don't mind tinkering with the hardware and software, console gamers just want to press a button and play games.
And sure you could keep on using a Sony dualshock controller on PC but that also requires extra software for it work.
I don't recall discs disappearing being a consumer decision, it's one companies made for the consumer to keep profits higher while game quality worsened with day 1 updates, more microtransactions and paid DLC's.
Posted on Reply
#25
Pasi123
OnasiUsed games are an aberration in the eyes of publishers and would be on their way out regardless. That writing was on the wall for a while. They are completely irrelevant to the conversation, might as well bring up the fact that one can theoretically acquire games from… alternative sources without giving any money to the publisher either.
My bad, I forgot GameStop doesn't only sell used games. Now what you said makes a lot more sense
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 22nd, 2026 13:30 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts