Wednesday, October 12th 2011
Review Consensus: AMD FX Processor 8150 Underwhelming
It's been in the works for over three years now. That's right, the first we heard of "Bulldozer" as a processor architecture under development was shortly after the launch of "Barcelona" K10 architecture. Granted, it wasn't possible to load close to 2 billion transistors on the silicon fab technology AMD had at the time, but AMD had a clear window over the last year to at least paper-launch the AMD FX. Delays and bad marketing may have cost AMD dearly in shaping up the product for the market.
After drawing a consensus from about 25 reviews (links in Today's Reviews on the front page), it emerges that:
After drawing a consensus from about 25 reviews (links in Today's Reviews on the front page), it emerges that:
- AMD FX-8150 is missing its performance expectations by a fair margin. Not to mention performance gains in its own presentation, these expectations were built up by how AMD was shaping the product to be a full-fledged enthusiast product with significant performance gains over the previous generation
- AMD ill-marketed the FX-8150. Hype is a double-edged sword, and should not be used if you're not confident your offering will live up to at least most of the hype. AMD marketed at least the top-tier FX-8000 series eight-core processors as the second coming of Athlon64 FX.
- FX-8150 launch isn't backed up by launch of other AMD FX processors. This could go on to become a blunder. The presence of other FX series processors such as the FX-8120, six-core and four-core FX processors could have at least made the price performance charts look better, given that all FX processors are unlocked, buyers could see the value in buying them to overclock. TweakTown took a closer look into this.
- There are no significant clock-for-clock improvements over even AMD's own previous generation. The FX-8150 drags its feet behind the Phenom II X6 1100T in single-threaded math benchmarks such as Super/HyperPi, the picture isn't any better with Cinebench single-threaded, either.
- Multi-threaded data streaming applications such as data compression (WINRAR, 7-ZIP) reveal the FX-8150 to catch up with competition from even the Core i7-2600K. This trend keeps up with popular video encoding benchmarks such as Handbrake and x264 HD.
- Load power draw is bad, by today's standards. It's not like AMD is lagging behind in silicon fabrication technologies, or the engineering potential that turned around AMD Radeon power consumption figures over generations.
- Price could be a major saving grace. In the end, AMD FX 8150 has an acceptable price-performance figure. At just $25 over the Core i5-2500K, the FX-8150 offers a good performance lead.
- Impressive overclocking potential. We weren't exactly in awe when AMD announced its Guinness Record-breaking overclocking feat, but reviewers across the board have noticed fairly good overclocking potential and performance scaling.
450 Comments on Review Consensus: AMD FX Processor 8150 Underwhelming
Desktop CPU - Intel 70.9%, AMD 28.9%
Mobile CPU - Intel 84.4%, AMD 15.2%
Server/workstation CPU - Intel 94.5%, AMD 5.5%
There was an article written by the leadership team at AMD in February 2005 saying that by 2015 AMD WILL hold at least 50% of the CPU marketing share, at the same time a Joint report by IBM and a US University stated that if AMD did not double their market share within 5 years (2010) they would go bust, they have not.
Let's hope that Bulldozer is a success, just because enthusiasts who make up about 5% of consumers think it's fail does not actually mean it will fail, it may well continue to increase AMD's market share, lets all hope it does because a world without AMD will be a much sadder (and more expensive) place.
The GTX 580 came out last November and replaced the GTX 480 as the fastest single GPU, and then the GTX 570 came out in early December before the HD 6970 and 6950 were released, the HD 6970 compete's with the GTX 570.
The GTX 560 Ti came out in January to replace the GTX 470.
The crown for fastest card is I believe still debated between the HD 6990 and the GTX 590.
Maybe if you run only heavy multithread all the time, but in reality it's pretty much mixed load all the time.
I really don't know what went wrong here, I mean the chip has 2B transistors huge cache and barely beats an X6 which has around 900M transistors and is built on 45nm.
The thing I noticed is that the cache latency is horrible but I don't know how much impact that has on the performance, but there must be some impact.
We can only hope that GF starts getting better yields, because right now they clearly have yield issues, since there aren't many different CPU models.
I did notice that it overclocks nicely but the power consumption goes through the roof, I can see a lot of blown VRM's on weaker boards...
I really feel sorry for everyone who bought a 990fx board and are now stuck with a PII because the "upgrade" is not worth it.
We can only hope that the process and yields get better so AMD can ramp up the clock speed/IPC further, I guess the waiting for Piledriver has begun, if it fails/gets delayed, AMD will be in a very bad situation...
Bulldozer might have given them a nice starting point for the future but for now it did not deliver.
These CPU's do not deserve to be called FX at all.
I wonder if they would be better off just shrinking the PII to 32nm and going straight for Piledriver to have more time to improve.
For now BD = Phenom I; PD = Phenom II; I just hope they improve the design to keep in touch with the competition, it's better for all of us.
I've had Intel for years and I can tell you I'm not gloating. We need the competition to keep leapfrogging each other every generation, not one company dominating the other like this. This way, performance stagnates and prices stay high. :mad:
Just look at the next SB platform: two major bugs and performance barely better than the current generation and all because AMD couldn't compete. Yeah, something to look forward to. :rolleyes:
I tell you, it must have been soul destroying for those engineers working on Bulldozer for the last year or two, knowing it was gonna come up second best after all that hard work. I don't envy them.
However, threads executed is what AMD was showing off by "real" core design.
However if these new parts eventually drop down in price then maybe just maybe I'd might reconsider?? Still SB-E/2011 is coming and when/(if ;)) the performance gap increases yet again... I may just go that route.
Don't have anything positive to say about Bulldozer but at least can contribute the above.
That's all really.
Although I am a little dissapointed with the 8150, I am very curious about the 4100 and how will it fare against the more expensive i3 and the cheaperst i5. Also the 6100 against the i5 2400.
My biggest dissapointment, however, is that this is bad for us, ethusiasts and especially for fanboys (both sides). Why? It's a huge hit in AMD fanboi's egos and a hit in intel fanboi's wallets.
I was expecting that, with bulldozer, a performance war would start again, with price battles and real innovation with each new model and platform. Seem slike I will have to wait some more time.
I don't think naming this processor line "Phenom III" is such a bad idea.
/My2cents
Edit. Thanks btarunr for the low down on the reviews I don't have days to look over all the reviews that are out. :toast: