Thursday, September 7th 2017

Do Inflated AMD Radeon GPU Prices Have an Official Sanction?

Over the past couple of months, inflation in AMD Radeon GPU prices, in part fueled by silicon shortages, and in part by non-gamers (read: crypto-currency miners) buying up graphics cards, have impacted the AMD Radeon brand in the eyes of its target audience - PC gamers and graphics professionals. It was initially believed that market forces are driving the inflation, and that AMD had little to do with the price inflation. We then uncovered a clue that not just end-users, but even retailers are being sold AMD Radeon graphics cards at prices way above AMD's launch SEP. A Tweet by an official AMD Twitter handle shows that inflated AMD Radeon graphics card prices has the company's official sanction.

"@AMDGaming," a verified Twitter handle held by AMD, which promotes the company's products targeted at gamers, such as AMD Radeon graphics cards, and Ryzen processors; posted a promotion in which an XFX branded Radeon RX 570 graphics card, which is being sold at USD $279, including a free coupon for a "Quake Champions" pack free, was made to appear as if at its price, it's a great deal. The RX 570 was launched at USD $169 for the 4 GB variant, and $199 for the 8 GB variant. The XFX Radeon RX 570 4 GB RS (the card being marketed in the Tweet) was launched at $179. The Tweet was met with angry reactions for how blatantly AMD was marketing price-inflated Radeon graphics cards, without actually doing something about taming the prices.
Add your own comment

100 Comments on Do Inflated AMD Radeon GPU Prices Have an Official Sanction?

#26
Nokiron
john_That sells as a hi end.
So you are telling me Vega 56 and 64 is mid-tier?

Performance matter, not die-size.
Posted on Reply
#27
john_
Raevenlordwww.techpowerup.com/236201/graphics-memory-prices-surge-30-in-august-could-affect-graphics-card-prices

All graphics cards, not just NVIDIA. Sorry if we didn't opt for the clickbait article.

It would read so much better if we had used NVIDIA and green images, wouldn't it?

This article here is strictly about an AMD tweet - an official channel by all means, irrespective of who is running it. If it wasn't official, people wouldn't be losing jobs over some tweets/facebook posts like they do.

See the difference?
I don't remember Digitimes being a click bait site. Maybe when it is bad news about Nvidia stuff, we should consider it a click bait site.

Also Digitimes' article was posted in the 1st of September and probably was having info specifically for Nvidia cards. Maybe too many green images to be posted here?

And you don't opt for click bait titles you say? I keep looking at this article's title and I am having a small problem believing you. Maybe you should have a look again at the title before going full sarcastic?

Nvidia official explanation about the whole 970 mess was lack of communication between it's departments. THE OFFICIAL EXPLANATION. Here a tweet from an employee can't be miscommunication or just bad judgment from it's superior in the marketing department, failing to understand that the current price for a 570, is NOT something that consumers will see it and smile. No, a tweet from someone working on AMD's marketing, is a direct proof of how Raja and Su thinks. Great.
Posted on Reply
#28
Nokiron
john_I don't remember Digitimes being a click bait site. Maybe when it is bad news about Nvidia stuff, we should consider it a click bait site.

Also Digitimes' article was posted in the 1st of September and probably was having info specifically for Nvidia cards. Maybe too many green images to be posted here?

And you don't opt for click bait titles you say? I keep looking at this article's title and I am having a small problem believing you. Maybe you should have a look again at the title before going full sarcastic?

Nvidia official explanation about the whole 970 mess was lack of communication between it's departments. THE OFFICIAL EXPLANATION. Here a tweet from an employee can't be miscommunication or just bad judgment from it's superior in the marketing department, failing to understand that the current price for a 570, is NOT something that consumers will see it and smile. No, a tweet from someone working on AMD's marketing, is a direct proof of how Raja and Su thinks. Great.
So you are just guessing? You seem to have problems with criticism against AMD.

They still represent AMD as a whole, that's what they are hired for.
Posted on Reply
#29
john_
NokironSo you are just guessing? You seem to have problems with criticism against AMD.

They still represent AMD as a whole, that's what they are hired for.
I am guessing? You have proofs? What? A tweet? Who wrote it? Who gave him the OK to wrote it? Is this person a hi ranked official? Does he realize that those prices have a negative impact on many consumers? Was it a mistake from his part, or deliberate? You seem to know. You seem to not guess, but have inside information. Please, don't keep it for yourself. Or you can avoid answering.

You want criticism for AMD? Their "poor volta" advertisement was a huge lie, they sell factory overclocked cards and then they come out and say "Oh yes, you can run them at lower frequencies and have lower power consumption" that it is stupid, and they totally lost the low end market, with Nvidia offering today the best VFM models, at under $80 and in the price range from $120 and above, when 2 years ago it was the opposite in most price points. You need more, or are you happy?

The only one having problems here is you. You got here to bash AMD and see others bashing AMD and I just spoiled your fun. Sorry.
Posted on Reply
#30
Nokiron
john_I am guessing? You have proofs? What? A tweet? Who wrote it? Who gave him the OK to wrote it? Is this person a hi ranked official? Does he realize that those prices have a negative impact on many consumers? Was it a mistake from his part, or deliberate? You seem to know. You seem to not guess, but have inside information. Please, don't keep it for yourself. Or you can avoid answering.

You want criticism for AMD? Their "poor volta" advertisement was a huge lie, they sell factory overclocked cards and then they come out and say "Oh yes, you can run them at lower frequencies and have lower power consumption" that it is stupid, and they totally lost the low end market, with Nvidia offering today the best VFM models, at under $80 and in the price range from $120 and above, when 2 years ago it was the opposite in most price points. You need more, or are you happy?

The only having problems here is you. You got here to bash AMD and see others bashing AMD and I just spoiled your fun. Sorry.
Digitimes is literally behind a paywall. You wrote "probably" since you most likely are not paying for it and can't read it. That's why.

Why does it matter that someone special wrote it? They posted it on both their Twitter account as well as their Facebook, both of which have huge reach. None of your questions matter when it affects potential customers, they don't care who wrote it when it comes from official sources.

I'm not the problem here. Atleast I can see the repercussions.
Posted on Reply
#31
dyonoctis
john_I don't remember Digitimes being a click bait site. Maybe when it is bad news about Nvidia stuff, we should consider it a click bait site.

Also Digitimes' article was posted in the 1st of September and probably was having info specifically for Nvidia cards. Maybe too many green images to be posted here?

And you don't opt for click bait titles you say? I keep looking at this article's title and I am having a small problem believing you. Maybe you should have a look again at the title before going full sarcastic?

Nvidia official explanation about the whole 970 mess was lack of communication between it's departments. THE OFFICIAL EXPLANATION. Here a tweet from an employee can't be miscommunication or just bad judgment from it's superior in the marketing department, failing to understand that the current price for a 570, is NOT something that consumers will see it and smile. No, a tweet from someone working on AMD's marketing, is a direct proof of how Raja and Su thinks. Great.
If the marketing/pr team isn't aware of a situation that's been going on for more than 2 month, then they are doing their job wrong. You can't do this kind of work without observing the market. That tweet have been here for a while to be just a tiny mistake, I'm seeing this as playing the ostrich, and this isn't something that they can afford right now, showing that they really need help in that departement.

The diffrence with the gtx 970 was that the 970 was made in a vicious way: the card did have 4gb of memory, it just had 512mb that's slower. It took a while for discovering that. The official explanation from Nvidia smell the lies, and they probaly just decided to market the gpu as a 4GB one because it sound better than 3.5Gb.
Posted on Reply
#32
TheoneandonlyMrK
john_I am guessing? You have proofs? What? A tweet? Who wrote it? Who gave him the OK to wrote it? Is this person a hi ranked official? Does he realize that those prices have a negative impact on many consumers? Was it a mistake from his part, or deliberate? You seem to know. You seem to not guess, but have inside information. Please, don't keep it for yourself. Or you can avoid answering.

You want criticism for AMD? Their "poor volta" advertisement was a huge lie, they sell factory overclocked cards and then they come out and say "Oh yes, you can run them at lower frequencies and have lower power consumption" that it is stupid, and they totally lost the low end market, with Nvidia offering today the best VFM models, at under $80 and in the price range from $120 and above, when 2 years ago it was the opposite in most price points. You need more, or are you happy?

The only one having problems here is you. You got here to bash AMD and see others bashing AMD and I just spoiled your fun. Sorry.
Even poor voltas bang on tbh ,got shown a few months ago but its not even on the block to discuss imho ,it was an irrelevant comment though they may as well have said the one after volta.

And the markets so feckled ,it's a real mess, i mean everything is dearer even old tat that's been sat for years ,is getting inflated, that price points are a crapshoot..
Posted on Reply
#33
john_
NokironDigitimes is literally behind a paywall. You wrote "probably" since you most likely are not paying for it and can't read it. That's why.
As I said, You can just avoid answering. If you don't want to enlighten us about your inside information about AMD tweet, maybe you can enlighten us about your inside information considering that paywall and Digitimes. Please, don't keep that information to yourself.
Why does it matter that someone special wrote it? They posted it on both their Twitter account as well as their Facebook, both of which have huge reach. None of your questions matter when it affects potential customers, they don't care who wrote it when it comes from official sources.
If you ever build a company, hire 10 employees. One to post marketing info in Twitter, one to post THE SAME INFO in Facebook, one in Instagram, one in Twitch etc. This makes total sense.
I'm not the problem here. Atleast I can see the repercussions.
Of course you can.
Posted on Reply
#34
Nokiron
john_As I said, You can just avoid answering. If you don't want to enlighten us about your inside information about AMD tweet, maybe you can enlighten us about your inside information considering that paywall and Digitimes. Please, don't keep that information to yourself.
Why do I need insider information? The post is right there and affecting people. Have you tried going to the article on Digitimes that's linked in the WCCFtech post you posted? I sure can't access it unless I am a paid subscriber.

You are the one to prove that they wrote Nvidia-specific information in that source. Not me.

wccftech.com/nvidia-graphics-cards-see-price-increases-starting-month-due-memory-shortage/
www.digitimes.com/newregister/join.asp?view=Article&DATEPUBLISH=2017/08/28&PAGES=PD&SEQ=207
john_If you ever build a company, hire 10 employees. One to post marketing info in Twitter, one to post THE SAME INFO in Facebook, one in Instagram, one in Twitch etc. This makes total sense.
This is irrelevant and nothing to do with my post, it does not matter what they used to publish it. The posts still exists.

John Doe does not care one bit on who posted it. I'ts official material.
john_Of course you can.
Isn't it blatantly obvious? You can read the comments on the posts themselves and see the reactions.
Posted on Reply
#35
john_
theoneandonlymrkEven poor voltas bang on tbh ,got shown a few months ago but its not even on the block to discuss imho ,it was an irrelevant comment though they may as well have said the one after volta.

And the markets so feckled ,it's a real mess, i mean everything is dearer even old tat that's been sat for years ,is getting inflated, that price points are a crapshoot..
They messed up. They probably expected more performance in gaming from Vega and that they could lower the power consumption until they have the card ready. They couldn't do that, so they just postponed the release as much as they could. Siggraph has nothing to do with gaming cards, but it was last in the list of events.

If Volta was out now as gaming cards, probably it wouldn't be much better than Pascal cards in gaming. AMD throw all it's R&D cash to shrink Fiji to 14nm and add more compute capabilities. Nvidia throw all it's R&D to create Volta's Tensor Units. In both cases nothing new for gamers. There is a possibility on the other hand, Volta models to have more CUDA cores, compared to Pascal model. And probably that's what we will see next year. A GTX 2070 with 2560 CUDA cores.

As for prices and market, yes, it's a whole mess.
Posted on Reply
#36
cadaveca
My name is Dave
john_They messed up. They probably expected more performance in gaming from Vega and that they could lower the power consumption until they have the card ready. They couldn't do that, so they just postponed the release as much as they could.
I prefer to go full-crazy and think that AMD held the cards back so they could use them for mining for themselves. Whether the company or individuals @ AMD benefitted from that, well, doesn't matter.

Like, I look at earning potential of these cards in mining, and the "inflated prices" actually make A LOT of sense. Gaming and any part of the market other than mining seems unimportant to pricing these days.

BTW, VEGA is available in HUGE numbers here, but I'm not going to pay $1000 CAD for a card. I could buy more than 10 cards right this morning locally, as soon as the store opens. Between all their branches, it seems that this particular retailer has about 50-75 cards in stock, and has more coming. The local branches has had 20-25 cards for over a week now, and they aren't selling very well it seems. Usually Bioware's local offices and staff would have snapped those cards up, but they took the majority of the launch cards, leaving pretty much none for the public, and I guess they bought so many that they don't need any more now.

Anyway, point is, supply and demand, locally, doesn't explain "inflated" pricing, at least, not locally. I mentioned back when the cards launched, that we'll see how well AMD is doing if I can go and buy the card I want (WC Limited edition), and I can't do that, but I can buy the card I don't want.


Posted on Reply
#37
john_
NokironWhy do I need insider information?
Of course not. Only the other person needs to prove his posts. You don't. Your posts are facts.
The post is right there and affecting people. Have you tried going to the article on Digitimes that's linked in the WCCFtech post you posted? I sure can't access it unless I am a paid subscriber.

You are the one to prove that they wrote Nvidia-specific information in that source. Not me.

wccftech.com/nvidia-graphics-cards-see-price-increases-starting-month-due-memory-shortage/
www.digitimes.com/newregister/join.asp?view=Article&DATEPUBLISH=2017/08/28&PAGES=PD&SEQ=207
Digitimes articles stay free to read to everybody for a period of time only. Of course it is easy to google and see multiple articles referring to Digitime's article. On the other hand you still avoid answering my question. As I said, you only ask the other person to prove his post.
This is irrelevant and nothing to do with my post, it does not matter what they used to publish it. The posts still exists.

John Doe does not care one bit on who posted it. I'ts official material.
No you are just missing the point. The same person/persons are responsible for all those posts and it's them that they have to realize that their posts are more harmful for AMD now than a good idea. Probably they have an obligation to their partner and they can't remove those posts. What i am guessing again? Damn. I forgot, we only talk with facts here. As for John Doe, he sees a 570 card with a price that he can ignore.
Isn't it blatantly obvious? You can read the comments on the posts themselves and see the reactions.
And that's how it is affecting people.


OK I am stopping here. I have done the moderating job and reading a dialog between two members that leads to nowhere is more than boring.
Posted on Reply
#38
TheoneandonlyMrK
cadavecaI prefer to go full-crazy and think that AMD held the cards back so they could use them for mining for themselves. Whether the company or individuals @ AMD benefitted from that, well, doesn't matter.

Like, I look at earning potential of these cards in mining, and the "inflated prices" actually make A LOT of sense. Gaming and any part of the market other than mining seems unimportant to pricing these days.

BTW, VEGA is available in HUGE numbers here, but I'm not going to pay $1000 CAD for a card. I could buy more than 10 cards right this morning locally, as soon as the store opens. Between all their branches, it seems that this particular retailer has about 50-75 cards in stock, and has more coming. The local branches has had 20-25 cards for over a week now, and they aren't selling very well it seems. Usually Bioware's local offices and staff would have snapped those cards up, but they took the majority of the launch cards, leaving pretty much none for the public, and I guess they bought so many that they don't need any more now.

Anyway, point is, supply and demand, locally, doesn't explain "inflated" pricing, at least, not locally. I mentioned back when the cards launched, that we'll see how well AMD is doing if I can go and buy the card I want (WC Limited edition), and I can't do that, but I can buy the card I don't want.


A reasonable argument i largely agree with but:),
You emphasize what Amd is doing but what they aren't doing is selling them to you.
That price is absolutely ridiculous, but Again its the distribution and shop to blame , you could probably import a £480 one from ocuk to there and still save money.

So what the hell gives with US and Canadian shopkeepers.....

If it were my region i wouldn't buy for that price tbh.

Ohh and Amd are not bitmain, my vega was unused on delivery im sure , mining leaves its marks you know like tinged mounting plates etc same as 24/7 folding.
Posted on Reply
#39
Nokiron
john_Of course not. Only the other person needs to prove his posts. You don't. Your posts are facts.
I didn't assume anything. You did with the "probably".

I had to scavenge comments from neogaf to find a readable link with allegedly less information. www.digitimes.com/news/a20170828PD207.html

There, I searched up the source (well, somewhat) since you didn't bother to care.
john_Digitimes articles stay free to read to everybody for a period of time only. Of course it is easy to google and see multiple articles referring to Digitime's article. On the other hand you still avoid answering my question. As I said, you only ask the other person to prove his post.
Again, I did not state anything. You did.

"Also Digitimes' article was posted in the 1st of September and probably was having info specifically for Nvidia cards."

I questioned the "probably" in that statement. Since the Digitimes article could not be read at the time of posting by WCCFtech.
john_No you are just missing the point. The same person/persons are responsible for all those posts and it's them that they have to realize that their posts are more harmful for AMD now than a good idea. Probably they have an obligation to their partner and they can't remove those posts. What i am guessing again? Damn. I forgot, we only talk with facts here. As for John Doe, he sees a 570 card with a price that he can ignore.
So just because they have an obligation makes their post completely fine for everyone? Are you sure everyone understands that? I sure don't, and the reactions are a clear indication that it is not received well.

I'm personally well aware why they posted it. But you have to see it from a different perspective.
john_And that's how it is affecting people.
You are saying they are not people?
john_OK I am stopping here. I have done the moderating job and reading a dialog between two members that leads to nowhere is more than boring.
Don't put this on me dude, this is all you.
Posted on Reply
#40
Xzibit
I find these Headline grabbers comical.

For the past months since the GPU prices have been inflated you could go to AMD site click SHOP and it links to external selling with current market prices.

That's pretty much all the research you needed to do and could say the exact same thing, That current market prices are AMD sanctioned.

Whats the difference. Well pointing it out then prior to Vega launch wont give you the headline grabber it does now.
Posted on Reply
#41
john_
cadavecaI prefer to go full-crazy and think that AMD held the cards back so they could use them for mining for themselves. Whether the company or individuals @ AMD benefitted from that, well, doesn't matter.

Like, I look at earning potential of these cards in mining, and the "inflated prices" actually make A LOT of sense. Gaming and any part of the market other than mining seems unimportant to pricing these days.

BTW, VEGA is available in HUGE numbers here, but I'm not going to pay $1000 CAD for a card. I could buy more than 10 cards right this morning locally, as soon as the store opens. Between all their branches, it seems that this particular retailer has about 50-75 cards in stock, and has more coming. The local branches has had 20-25 cards for over a week now, and they aren't selling very well it seems. Usually Bioware's local offices and staff would have snapped those cards up, but they took the majority of the launch cards, leaving pretty much none for the public, and I guess they bought so many that they don't need any more now.

Anyway, point is, supply and demand, locally, doesn't explain "inflated" pricing, at least, not locally. I mentioned back when the cards launched, that we'll see how well AMD is doing if I can go and buy the card I want (WC Limited edition), and I can't do that, but I can buy the card I don't want.


That would be interesting. Hope they made enough money to build Navi as a totally new design, not improve Tonga again, for the 4th I think time? :laugh:

I think that after they saw that they can't create a 1080 killer they decided to turn to mining. That's why they created that special driver(at the same time they where tutting that Radeon packs where created to limit sales to miners). Bitcoin sold all 290/X reference cards that no one was going to buy because of their cooling solution and with the custom models only 2 months away. So they thought they can do the same. Especially now that they are probably selling Vega at a loss or single digit profit margins. They knew that retailers will make again huge profit margins and they(AMD) will be feeling stupid, so they messed up with the launch price, leaving it open in a way, so they have the option to make some extra income from the RX cards latter. Maybe they where also fearing VRAM prices going up.

At those prices I wouldn't have bought either, even if I had found the money in the pavement just outside the shop selling Vega.

Internet gives shops the chance to not be local shops. They could be hoping to sell some Vegas to customers in areas where Vegas are more expensive or difficult to find.

But this mess with Vega has probably nothing to do with that tweet. XFX asked them to promote it's card, AMD tweeted about the card, and here we go....
Posted on Reply
#42
john_
Nokiron....
Just a quick reply. When I post an opinion I will always say probably. Others think that everything they post it must be cast in stone. Me, I leave it to the reader, to either read that probably as an honest opinion, or as a change to use it to discredit that opinion.
I like also how you come to conclusions about what I mean.

The end.

PS(really john_? after the end? :p )
NokironDon't put this on me dude, this is all you.
You quoted me, with multiple conclusions and questions about what I meant. And no, I wasn't putting this on you. One more of your conclusions. NO "probably" here, just another conclusion/fact of yours.
Posted on Reply
#43
TheoneandonlyMrK
XzibitI find these Headline grabbers comical.

For the past months since the GPU prices have been inflated you could go to AMD site click SHOP and it links to external selling with current market prices.

That's pretty much all the research you needed to do and could say the exact same thing, That current market prices are AMD sanctioned.

Whats the difference. Well pointing it out then prior to Vega launch wont give you the headline grabber it does now.
Exactly , the cards have already been sold at that price for four months not good but market is what it is ,so Amd or xfx up the game to push sales by packaging a game and its bad.
I bought 10 gtx 1060s not long ago that should have been 200£ but bought for 269 with rocket league , same shit sans pr tweet and alls fine.
The last two 1060s cost 40£ (2days later ,same card)more because Nvidia are shits.

No the guy selling it me was the Shit.
Posted on Reply
#44
efikkan
BytalesHow about when Nvidia inflates the MSRP Prices from the get go ?
Geforce 1080 MSRP at Launch ??
For a mid Tier Chip ? Nobody seemed to care.
Nvidia only inflated the prices of their FE cards.
Posted on Reply
#45
TheoneandonlyMrK
efikkanNvidia only inflated the prices of their FE cards.
What and that had no effect on Aib cards????? Or the pricing of what it replaced????
Posted on Reply
#46
R0H1T
cadavecaI prefer to go full-crazy and think that AMD held the cards back so they could use them for mining for themselves. Whether the company or individuals @ AMD benefitted from that, well, doesn't matter.
I actually suggested that multiple times on this forum, here's hoping Raja didn't listen to me :slap:
Of course if they did, then I guess the Wells Fargo fake account scandal might look like a drop in the ocean, considering this one will have more serious repercussions for AMD :shadedshu:
Posted on Reply
#47
Slizzo
theoneandonlymrkWhat and that had no effect on Aib cards????? Or the pricing of what it replaced????
No, it didn't. The FE cards were still very clearly priced well above the partner cards.

I bought my GTX 1080 G1 Gaming for $649. MSRP of GTX 1080 was $599, FE was $699. There you go: partner card, with custom cooler, and custom PCB was smack dab in the middle of those two price points.
Posted on Reply
#48
Poul-erik
In Denmark vi have to pay 700$ for a RX Vega 64.
Posted on Reply
#49
cadaveca
My name is Dave
R0H1TI actually suggested that multiple times on this forum, here's hoping Raja didn't listen to me :slap:
Of course if they did, then I guess the Wells Fargo fake account scandal might look like a drop in the ocean, considering this one will have more serious repercussions for AMD :shadedshu:
I don't think so. they can do whatever they like with whatever they make. Perhaps they need to test each GPU with mining to ensure stability? So no big deal.
Posted on Reply
#50
efikkan
theoneandonlymrkWhat and that had no effect on Aib cards????? Or the pricing of what it replaced????
GTX 1060-1080 Ti have been available around the MSRP, I've built several computers with these cards. Aib cards start around MSRP, as usual.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 19th, 2026 04:42 PST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts