Tuesday, August 27th 2019
AMD to Cough Up $12.1 Million to Settle "Bulldozer" Core Count Class-Action Lawsuit
AMD reached a settlement in the Class Action Lawsuit filed against it, over alleged false-marketing of the core-counts of its eight-core FX-series processors based on the "Bulldozer" microarchitecture. Each member of the Class receives a one-time payout of USD $35 per chip, while the company takes a hit of $12.1 million. The lawsuit dates back to 2015, when Tony Dickey, representing himself in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, accused AMD of false-marketing of its FX-series "Bulldozer" processor of having 8 CPU cores. Over the following four years, the case gained traction as a Class Action was built against AMD this January.
In the months that followed the January set-up of a 12-member Jury to examine the case, lawyers representing the Class and AMD argued over the underlying technology that makes "Bulldozer" a multi-core processor, and eventually discussed what a fair settlement would be for the Class. They eventually agreed on a number - $12.1 million, or roughly $35 per chip AMD sold, which they agreed was "fair," and yet significantly less than the "$60 million in premiums" consumers contended they paid for these processors. Sifting through these numbers, it's important to understand what the Class consists of. It consists of U.S. consumers who became interested to be part of the Class Action, and who bought an 8-core processor based on the "Bulldozer" microarchitecture. It excludes consumers of every other "Bulldozer" derivative (4-core, 6-core parts, APUs; and follow-ups to "Bulldozer" such as "Piledriver," "Excavator," etc.).Image Credit: Taylor Alger
Source:
The Register
In the months that followed the January set-up of a 12-member Jury to examine the case, lawyers representing the Class and AMD argued over the underlying technology that makes "Bulldozer" a multi-core processor, and eventually discussed what a fair settlement would be for the Class. They eventually agreed on a number - $12.1 million, or roughly $35 per chip AMD sold, which they agreed was "fair," and yet significantly less than the "$60 million in premiums" consumers contended they paid for these processors. Sifting through these numbers, it's important to understand what the Class consists of. It consists of U.S. consumers who became interested to be part of the Class Action, and who bought an 8-core processor based on the "Bulldozer" microarchitecture. It excludes consumers of every other "Bulldozer" derivative (4-core, 6-core parts, APUs; and follow-ups to "Bulldozer" such as "Piledriver," "Excavator," etc.).Image Credit: Taylor Alger

291 Comments on AMD to Cough Up $12.1 Million to Settle "Bulldozer" Core Count Class-Action Lawsuit
Selling a "4 GB" card with 512 MB of its VRAM being sneaky hidden slug RAM is fraud, pure and simple. This is especially true given the context of marketing it as a 4 GB part when 970 SLI was a big thing because of the high cost of the 4 GB 980.
Plenty of people felt duped because they would have more strongly considered a 980, gone AMD, or waited for something else before spending their money. But, hey, look at the great deal on the 970 in SLI — it has the same amount of VRAM as the expensive 980! Oops.
I remember how Witcher 3's visuals were downgraded to fit into the 970's 3.5 GB. Nvidia is powerful, indeed.
If I do this with 8 FPU only threads and 4 FPU only threads on the 8150 the workload is gonna finish in an similar amount of time in both cases. Main problem is that for an real 8 core cpu this is not what I would expect. If I don't say what type of threads I used, because I don't have to say, you advertised an 8 cores 8 threads cpu so I can put whatever type of threads I want on that cpu, then anyone that see the result will start to wonder why a properly thread splited workload is showing no improvement at all when using 8 threads compared to 4.
You gonna say again about faster. And you are wrong. (If the 8 and 4 threads have nothing to do with FPU the 8150 starts to behave as expected...)
If 8150 would had been advertised as an 8 cores 4 threads cpu I wouldn't had anything to say. (I would wonder why you need 2 cores for 1 thread and how exactly you split that 1 thread internaly between the 2 cores...)
You are free to point to a cpu advertised to have more cores than threads. I'm not aware of such case.
Another further point about it, too: The 970's VRAM wasn't even apparent initially. By contrast, anyone who had bothered to read reviews from legitimate sites would have seen that Bulldozer wasn't delivering (and Piledriver, although, at least, it was very cheap near the end). 970 buyers truly were tricked. Bulldozer and Piledriver buyers were either too impatient (pre-orders) or too lazy (didn't check reviews) and deserve the product their received. AMD was under no legal obligation to make its cores as powerful or more powerful when compared with Intel's.
It's a good thing for Intel that this guy didn't buy an Atom. It wasn't out-of-order, after all. He would have sued on the basis that any modern CPU is expected to have out-of-order design for performance since in-order hadn't been on the market since the Pentium 1. Of course, there's also the bait-and-switch of the chipset using far more power than the CPU, negating the justification for the performance-killing in-order design to conserve power.
processing units = integer cluster
Integer cluster is execution unit.
1+ CPU -> 1+ core -> 1+ integer cluster -> 1+ execution unit
FX-8350 -> 4 core -> 8 integer cluster -> 64 execution unit (don't quote me on that, fast research)
R7 1800 -> 8 core -> 8 integer cluster -> 48 execution unit (again, fast research)
I just stated a simple fact that as far as software is concerned, they're the same. Each core is either given one thread or two. It's no more complicated than that without drilling deep into the hardware design.
Unrelated to this post but related to the previous one about Atom... In the case of that bait-and-switch, it actually was worse for the shopper if one had done his/her homework early-on because there was a lot of hype around how Intel's engineers had worked so hard with a pure philosophy of only adding functionality if it could be put in without using too much power. It was very dreamy in its presentation, at least that was the intent.
The cold reality was that the chipset was a terrible pig that made the entire thing into a sad joke. Despite that, the hype machine was in full force and netbooks with this terrible tech sold very well as a result.
BIOS settings are sometimes a bit of smoke and mirrors. In the long thread there were examples of settings that allow disabling each core separately which is technically impossible. I mean, you can disable part of a module (Integer Cluster) in Bulldozer and the rest will be a functional core. But you cannot disable anything else without compromizing core functionality. This goes back to the problem of not being independent.
AMD - will stop flase Marketing - and I like that !
Of course, being utterly corrupt, it's widely praised and influential to this day.Too vague a statement to be useful here. One guy's problem with AMD's marketing managed to get some success in the courts. That's proof of very little.
Atom is actually the bigger fraud but since it was backed by Intel and not presented as a high-performance architecture people were more content to be duped. Being duped by the illusion of some grand power-conservation Zen magic is more tolerable, I guess — despite the plethora of netbooks that filled stores and which vanished like the mighty dinosaur in a comparative flash.
Atom would have been lame with a good chipset but it would have been lame on its own terms, not false pretenses. At least it would have been quieter, with more battery life, and with less heat.
AMD screamed the lie from the top of the mountains.
New processors only have the core/thread count on the tiny little sticker sealing the box now. :roll:
If they just snuck the little word "integer" in there, this would have never happened because the packaging is truthful. But no. They had to make their product stand out...
(makes Magenta face)
quote: "AMD made a critical mistake by omitting 'integer' on their products."
Not this:
This guy is many billion transistors short of what it claims to be.
There isn't a single multi-core processor on the planet that can truly operate 100% independently and that doesn't share anything. This notion of separate processors does not exist in this context, stop using it.
The only truly separate processors are the ones on different boards. End of story.