Tuesday, August 27th 2019
AMD to Cough Up $12.1 Million to Settle "Bulldozer" Core Count Class-Action Lawsuit
AMD reached a settlement in the Class Action Lawsuit filed against it, over alleged false-marketing of the core-counts of its eight-core FX-series processors based on the "Bulldozer" microarchitecture. Each member of the Class receives a one-time payout of USD $35 per chip, while the company takes a hit of $12.1 million. The lawsuit dates back to 2015, when Tony Dickey, representing himself in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, accused AMD of false-marketing of its FX-series "Bulldozer" processor of having 8 CPU cores. Over the following four years, the case gained traction as a Class Action was built against AMD this January.
In the months that followed the January set-up of a 12-member Jury to examine the case, lawyers representing the Class and AMD argued over the underlying technology that makes "Bulldozer" a multi-core processor, and eventually discussed what a fair settlement would be for the Class. They eventually agreed on a number - $12.1 million, or roughly $35 per chip AMD sold, which they agreed was "fair," and yet significantly less than the "$60 million in premiums" consumers contended they paid for these processors. Sifting through these numbers, it's important to understand what the Class consists of. It consists of U.S. consumers who became interested to be part of the Class Action, and who bought an 8-core processor based on the "Bulldozer" microarchitecture. It excludes consumers of every other "Bulldozer" derivative (4-core, 6-core parts, APUs; and follow-ups to "Bulldozer" such as "Piledriver," "Excavator," etc.).Image Credit: Taylor Alger
Source:
The Register
In the months that followed the January set-up of a 12-member Jury to examine the case, lawyers representing the Class and AMD argued over the underlying technology that makes "Bulldozer" a multi-core processor, and eventually discussed what a fair settlement would be for the Class. They eventually agreed on a number - $12.1 million, or roughly $35 per chip AMD sold, which they agreed was "fair," and yet significantly less than the "$60 million in premiums" consumers contended they paid for these processors. Sifting through these numbers, it's important to understand what the Class consists of. It consists of U.S. consumers who became interested to be part of the Class Action, and who bought an 8-core processor based on the "Bulldozer" microarchitecture. It excludes consumers of every other "Bulldozer" derivative (4-core, 6-core parts, APUs; and follow-ups to "Bulldozer" such as "Piledriver," "Excavator," etc.).Image Credit: Taylor Alger

291 Comments on AMD to Cough Up $12.1 Million to Settle "Bulldozer" Core Count Class-Action Lawsuit
Just a few excerpts. I would definitely recommend reading more, starting with part 1.The architectural organization of cores comes primarily from the multiprocessor systems (type of which a multicore system is). With Zen and talking about memory/core access latency, NUMA is a term to keep in mind.
So what do we do after all of this, what is a core at the end of the day ? The material out there is in accordance with AMD's claims, or rather, it doesn't contradict them in any way if you prefer it that way.
Why would I consider that AMD settled because they thought they couldn't win ? I seriously doubt that, the plaintiffs could never prove this, there is simply no way to construct a counter argument that makes sense and which doesn't trump a million other definitions as well. They know this and that's why they accepted the settlement too.
They settled because this is actually a really small amount of money that they need to pay under obscure terms and this way they don't look like a big evil corporation squashing some displeased customers.
Nvidia provided incorrect specifications about one of their products and not only that but there was no way you could verify this easily. AMD didn't, even if you thought their modules didn't actually contain two cores you could simply go and look at the diagrams and information that they released about their micro-architecture.
Nothing was hidden about what was going on under the hood of their products as was in Nvidia's case.
But ontopic - How do you define a core?
Whereas AMD had the 4-modules with 2 cores each that shared some resources and that was clear from the start. No matter what we use to call cores, it has 8 of those. Might be weaker in some calculations and better in others (it was a server focused arch afterall not helped by the manufacturing process of 32nm vs the 22nm used by Intel back then) but it wasn't a lie. Those arch's shortbacks were clearly shown in the day-1 reviews' results where the previous gen AMD CPUs were almost equal in some tasks and fell back in others. In conclusion, AMD didn't gain market share or sales from the 8-core label on the box.
In other words, they were falsely advertising something and actively hiding information. There was no way that they could have denied this, if I remember correctly they even admitted they did a "mistake". That's why they settled.
But these two cases aren't alike, they deal with different matter. You brought this up because I think you like to twist and nitpick at things.
It was ROPs and L2. Whether their admitted 'mistake' was a mistake is arguable but I am pretty sure it wasn't. With correct specs the memory problem would have been found much quicker ;)Not some resources. Most of them. This is why definition of a core matters.
Given a sufficiently parallelized workload a perfectly valid expectation for 8-core CPU is 8 cores to perform 8 times better than 1 core (perhaps 7.9 times). With Bulldozer, that is not the case. It will perform about 80% of that, sometimes worse (with FPU load).
parallel =/= faster (not always faster)
more cores =/= faster parallel execution (definitely not always faster)
That's what your average Joe might think , that 8 means times 8 performance. But if he feels cheated by AMD he should feel cheated by any CPU manufacturer that does multi-core CPU because that's the case for all of them.
But it always gets down to the same complaint in the end, that AMD's CPU wasn't as fast as others. In the end this core debate garbage isn't even relevant to most people. I am sure as hell they wouldn't have given a damn if AMD didn't have real cores but they were 10 times faster.
Going through the list looking for x-core/x-thread CPUs with single core results and OC (to be kind of sure sc runs at the same clock):
i5 8600K - 6C/6T @ 5282 MHz - 557 cb - 3276 cb - 5.88x (98%)
FX 8370 - 8C/8T @ 5080 MHz - 263 cb - 1719 cb - 6.54x (82%)
i3 8350K - 3C/3T @ 4988 MHz - 525 cb - 1537 cb - 2.93x (98%)
FX-8320 - 8C/8T @ 3813 MHz - 195 cp - 1264 cb - 6.48x (81%)
FX-83x0 is Piledriver with minor improvements over Bulldozer.
Not everything is Cinebench and let's just say that the user that was expecting perfect scaling and felt lied to wasn't probably thinking about running just Cinebench.
There is a ton of software that hits a dead end after a certain point in terms of multithreading, as a matter of fact that's generally the rule not the exception.
For some reason, it does not work like that on Bulldozer (or Piledriver).
20%-ish performance deficiency is noteworthy, isn't it?
This would be an awesome result for SMT and is quite noteworthy for CMT but is very worrying for independent cores.
Or is it that software scales in all sorts of ways irrespective of how many cores there are ?
Edit:
I get it, you are just trying to be a contrarian. OK.Examples?
22x scaling. This one does have SMT but hey, 18 cores are 18 cores. Your time x cores math is a valid expectation, according to you. Cores are cores and everything is set in stone.
Also, you are aware that in your amazing comparison of Piledriver with other CPUs that those newer Intel processors have much more aggressive single core and multi core turbos, right ?
Check this out :
i5 6500
1326 / 374 = 3.54x , 88.5% , interesting. Not quite 100% but much closer to 80% the deficiency goes down to about 6%, noteworthy not noteworthy what do you say. Is this really a quad core I wonder ?And you replying to every comment of mine for the past couple of pages are ... not ... right ?
:eek: