Thursday, March 5th 2020

Researchers Find Unfixable Vulnerability Inside Intel CPUs

Researchers have found another vulnerability Inside Intel's Converged Security and Management Engine (CSME). For starters, the CSME is a tiny CPU within a CPU that has access to whole data throughput and is dedicated to the security of the whole SoC. The CSME system is a kind of a black box, given that Intel is protecting its documentation so it can stop its copying by other vendors, however, researchers have discovered a flaw in the design of CSME and are now able to exploit millions of systems based on Intel CPUs manufactured in the last five years.

Discovered by Positive Technologies, the flaw is lying inside the Read-Only Memory (ROM) of the CSME. Given that the Mask ROM is hardcoded in the CPU, the exploit can not be fixed by a simple firmware update. The researchers from Positive Technologies describe it as such: "Unfortunately, no security system is perfect. Like all security architectures, Intel's had a weakness: the boot ROM, in this case. An early-stage vulnerability in ROM enables control over the reading of the Chipset Key and generation of all other encryption keys. One of these keys is for the Integrity Control Value Blob (ICVB). With this key, attackers can forge the code of any Intel CSME firmware module in a way that authenticity checks cannot detect. This is functionally equivalent to a breach of the private key for the Intel CSME firmware digital signature, but limited to a specific platform."
Every CPU manufactured in the last 5 years is subject to exploit, except the latest 10th generation, Ice Point-based chipsets and SoCs. The only solution for owners of prior generation CPUs is to upgrade to the latest platform as a simple firmware update can not resolve this. The good thing, however, is that to exploit a system, an attacker must have physical access to the hardware in question, as remote exploitation is not possible.
Sources: Positive Technologies, Thanks to the biffzinker for the tip
Add your own comment

29 Comments on Researchers Find Unfixable Vulnerability Inside Intel CPUs

#26
Dredi
CheeseballCurrently, CVE-2019-0090 states that exploiting this requires physical access to the target machine.

They are still exploring how to exploit this through a virtual machine (since they use IOMMUs to map out to the memory), but the exploit needing DMA to get into the Intel CSME makes that difficult without directly connecting to the hardware.
Yes, the CVE states that that method does require physical access. The attack vector however is visible even without it, they just haven’t had the resources to make a proof of concept(s) yet which are necessary for the CVE’s.
”We think there might be many ways to exploit this vulnerability in ROM. Some of them might require local access; others need physical access.”
Posted on Reply
#27
R-T-B
DrediWhat a sick burn! Too bad that this allows for things to happen even without physical access.
Sort of. If you can execute local admin level code somehow, you don't need physical access. But how do you get that? Likely malware infection or similar. For a healthy system you are going to need physical access or at the very least, social engineering.

I might note that bug would be rendered powerless by using the ME "Temp disable" (actually permanent) mode I used to provide. They'd log into a shutdown platform, effectively (if it even allowed login). I need to think of a way to provide that that doesn't require firmware hacking, too time consuming.
Posted on Reply
#28
Totally
rtwjunkieSo, much ado about nothing, since physical access is required.


Is anyone still using that?
Yes, and it's gaining traction as more companies switch to mobile centric operating models. You're probably think Java, unless you were being sarcastic, don't mind me.
Posted on Reply
#29
lexluthermiester
I posted this in another thread but it's relevant here as well. They touch on every important aspect and explain a few things in some detail.
Please refer to the first topic starting at 1:56
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 20th, 2026 13:21 PST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts