Thursday, April 21st 2022
TSMC Founder Says Growing Domestic US Chip Production is Wasteful and Expensive
According to an article over on The Register, the TSMC founder, Morris Chang, isn't overly impressed by US efforts to grow its domestic chip production. In a podcast hosted by the Brookings Institution, Morris Chang said that the US' attempt to grow its domestic chip production will be "a wasteful, expensive exercise in futility." The reason behind his comment is that he believes the US is lacking the talent to work in the fabs, or possibly the willingness to work triple-shift to keep the fabs running 24/7, unlike the Taiwanese. Furthermore, he states that the US can't compete in terms of cost, as he claims it's 50 percent more expensive to manufacture chips in the US compared to Taiwan.
It should be pointed out that Morris Chang is no longer involved with the day to day operations at TSMC and the above are just his opinion. When questioned about why TSMC is building a fab in Arizona, Chang said that TSMC decided to do it because they were urged to do so by the US government. He also believes that despite government subsidies, the US is unlikely to become self-sufficient when it comes to semiconductors, especially as the cost per chip will be much higher, which will make it hard to compete internationally. However, he does mention that if the PRC decided to start a war with Taiwan, then the bet is likely to pay off for the US, but there are obviously other problems that such a situation would bring as well. Chang also praises US chip design talent and says that Taiwan has very little talent in comparison and that TSMC has none. However, the latter doesn't seem to be entirely true, based on the fact that TSMC is helping its customers to optimise their designs for the various production nodes at TSMC. For those interested, the podcast can be found below.
Source:
The Register
It should be pointed out that Morris Chang is no longer involved with the day to day operations at TSMC and the above are just his opinion. When questioned about why TSMC is building a fab in Arizona, Chang said that TSMC decided to do it because they were urged to do so by the US government. He also believes that despite government subsidies, the US is unlikely to become self-sufficient when it comes to semiconductors, especially as the cost per chip will be much higher, which will make it hard to compete internationally. However, he does mention that if the PRC decided to start a war with Taiwan, then the bet is likely to pay off for the US, but there are obviously other problems that such a situation would bring as well. Chang also praises US chip design talent and says that Taiwan has very little talent in comparison and that TSMC has none. However, the latter doesn't seem to be entirely true, based on the fact that TSMC is helping its customers to optimise their designs for the various production nodes at TSMC. For those interested, the podcast can be found below.
56 Comments on TSMC Founder Says Growing Domestic US Chip Production is Wasteful and Expensive
I'll be honest here, it sounds like talent is talent. That said, it it not. What he could have said more accurately it:
"The US doesn't have the manpower and labor history required to manufacture in the same way that Taiwan does. Conversely, Taiwan doesn't have the design skills to make that fabrication capability into anything useful."
Let me start this conversations by starting.
1) Raw materials are mined and converted - see: very low skilled countries
2) Machines are made, to turn those raw materials into complex goods - see: Germany (where EUV machines are fabricated)
3) Engineers design the complex goods - see: The US
4) Low paid, but highly educated areas manufacture the complex goods - see: Taiwan
1 exists to be low cost, high risk, low skills, and high labor. 2 exists to be high cost, low risk, high skills, and moderate labor. 3 exists to be high cost, low risk, high skills, and low labor. Finally, 4 is low cost, low risk, high skills, and moderate labor. Notice none of this overlaps.
The "burn" here is that the US doesn't make anything anymore. They can't compete against the skilled laborers from other countries, because they cost too much. The counter-burn is that Taiwan has labor but no ability to design. Both are useless without the other.
My $0.02 is that this is correct, if a bit simplistic. I've worked at plenty of places with three shifts...but when you think about the US it's difficult to equate that to how many people work "banker hours." I think this is just a myopic view of a country that is much bigger than people think, especially when you're comparing to an island nation...that was taken over from the natives after the CCP won the civil war post WWII.
It's hard, but go to Europe. Go to Taiwan. Ask them what the "average American" is...and be surprised. Sometimes a lot of the truth is lost when people aren't willing to understand that LA, Chicago, Detroit, Tulsa, Boise, and Ore are all cities amongst the same country. What do all of these cities have in common...? Basically nothing other than being in the same country. Despite this, people believe they "understand" America. It's the same jangoistic idiocy that leads people in the US joking about Russia being composed of bears on unicycles.
"However, he does mention that if the PRC decided to start a war with Taiwan, then the bet is likely to pay off for the US"
Then:
1) He thinks that USA made a bet with financing and giving incentives for expanding the local semiconductor manufacturing capacity
2) this bet will pay off only if PRC start a war with Taiwan
Well i don't know anyone making a bet without wanting to win;)
Just tell me when the new fabs will be ready, I need to buy before that.
Just joking, it's what he said, just blame Morris Chang.
If you look at Intel 10nm transistor density, at 10nm it is 2x that of TSMC.
Workforce costs might be higher in the US, but as compared to consumables, I don't think the difference is as significant as they claim.
When MWIMB spent millions in Clarksville TN to start building a semiconductor plant, Red China dumped them on the market. Construction was halted and the property was eventually sold. The local state college started a slew of classes aimed at filling the positions at the plant.
Taiwan is freely manufacturing on borrowed time.
i cant see the logic behind that statement
Assuming a pipe is still in fact made here, the quality level should be based on the experience of the worker, not how many asians are churning them out.
The issues Intel had with 10nm were entirely hubris based: they were very density aggressive, used exotic materials, dismissed EUV, and cut R&D spending. The first product that came out on a more advanced process than Intel had was in September 2018. Intel being successful with
IDFIFS2 would be huge for the entire industry as it would bring another leading edge manufacturing process to the worldwide market.35-45k is a far more normal salary.With regards to CEO pay, the two top people at TSMC each got paid just over NT$144 million last year. Quite a difference, yet that's hardly a crap salary in any currency.You're aware that a significant amount of labour in Taiwan comes from the Philippines, Indonesia, Vietnam and Thailand, right? Some of them are almost treated like slave labour. Maybe not in the semiconductor industry, but look up the Taiwanese fishing fleet and your opinion about Taiwan might drop a peg or two. The Taiwanese treat their neighbouring nations like crap.
you need to build chips on your american continent even if you are inefficient at start it is of strategic value...
and yes of cause some taiwanese "founder" doesn't like the idear as it saves taiwan less from the claw of china, the us is not going to world war when china attacs taiwan after europe is self absorbt by ukraine war :p
Any move to "not produce chips" on your own continent is a stategic error on epic scale, it just show you learned nothing from the last years
The wage needed to live in the US is far more higher than any country : everything is expensive. A 1M dollar bill because of 2 weeks in the ICU is just insane. Same goes for houses, insurances, rent, etc.
It's easier in Europe because our average wage is lower, and we don't have power shortage problems.
As mentionned before, if US' is qualified enough to design chips, but they can't technically run fabs without make huge efforts which aren't profitable except for production independence.
Just to give you an indication : 30$/h wage reprensents 4200$/month for us, which is huge. Many people don't reach that even with a Master degree and a good expertise.
Average in europe is around 2500€/month (global) in "rich" countries.
Most higher management and HR departments in Taiwan, are trying to keep salaries as low as possible.
The standard for salaries is a website called 104, which is an employment website that list salaries and everyone is seemingly trying to compete with regards to who can pay the least to hire someone...
privateintellectual property to the CCP. That alone leads to massive loss once they start to produce their copy pasta CCP chips. With production in the West you can control such things way better.And saying muricans can't do the job is nonsense. There are enough competent people who can be trained. In the end it just shows that we went too far with our grashopper capitalism. We need to bring essential production back. Which will also create more meaningful jobs, good for mental health of all who would otherwise waste their life in stupid jobs (paper shovelers, keyboard smashers, seat heaters, etc.).
Fyi paper pushers/deskjockeys.
Im a blue collar worker being a Landing gear tech, I love computers but I can't sit at one and do paper work all day. (Yes paperwork is about 50% of my job)It be good if TI, AMD had their own fabs here.
Fab 51 was originally an AMD Fab in Dresden Germany that was sold to Globalfoundries unfortunately.