Thursday, April 21st 2022
TSMC Founder Says Growing Domestic US Chip Production is Wasteful and Expensive
According to an article over on The Register, the TSMC founder, Morris Chang, isn't overly impressed by US efforts to grow its domestic chip production. In a podcast hosted by the Brookings Institution, Morris Chang said that the US' attempt to grow its domestic chip production will be "a wasteful, expensive exercise in futility." The reason behind his comment is that he believes the US is lacking the talent to work in the fabs, or possibly the willingness to work triple-shift to keep the fabs running 24/7, unlike the Taiwanese. Furthermore, he states that the US can't compete in terms of cost, as he claims it's 50 percent more expensive to manufacture chips in the US compared to Taiwan.
It should be pointed out that Morris Chang is no longer involved with the day to day operations at TSMC and the above are just his opinion. When questioned about why TSMC is building a fab in Arizona, Chang said that TSMC decided to do it because they were urged to do so by the US government. He also believes that despite government subsidies, the US is unlikely to become self-sufficient when it comes to semiconductors, especially as the cost per chip will be much higher, which will make it hard to compete internationally. However, he does mention that if the PRC decided to start a war with Taiwan, then the bet is likely to pay off for the US, but there are obviously other problems that such a situation would bring as well. Chang also praises US chip design talent and says that Taiwan has very little talent in comparison and that TSMC has none. However, the latter doesn't seem to be entirely true, based on the fact that TSMC is helping its customers to optimise their designs for the various production nodes at TSMC. For those interested, the podcast can be found below.
Source:
The Register
It should be pointed out that Morris Chang is no longer involved with the day to day operations at TSMC and the above are just his opinion. When questioned about why TSMC is building a fab in Arizona, Chang said that TSMC decided to do it because they were urged to do so by the US government. He also believes that despite government subsidies, the US is unlikely to become self-sufficient when it comes to semiconductors, especially as the cost per chip will be much higher, which will make it hard to compete internationally. However, he does mention that if the PRC decided to start a war with Taiwan, then the bet is likely to pay off for the US, but there are obviously other problems that such a situation would bring as well. Chang also praises US chip design talent and says that Taiwan has very little talent in comparison and that TSMC has none. However, the latter doesn't seem to be entirely true, based on the fact that TSMC is helping its customers to optimise their designs for the various production nodes at TSMC. For those interested, the podcast can be found below.
56 Comments on TSMC Founder Says Growing Domestic US Chip Production is Wasteful and Expensive
But it was more a tongue in cheek reference to how people use to gauge PSU quality...
Same with NK threatienng to level Seoul...
I'm not saying it isn't a threat but perhaps it's more nuanced than something unavoidable.
People let's try not to ruin another thread.
Thank You.
Local electronic manufacturers must buy locally for at least 50% to help local industry to grow and in the future be less expensive
Chip manufacturing jobs in the us at least at intel plants will be six figures for many employees as intel announced for its upcoming Ohio plant.
Based on the info I could find, similar fab salaries in Taiwan at TSMC are around 75K per year which is good. But less than what they would be in the USA. There’s a reason why so many companies outsourced labor of manufacturing and assembly to Asia. They rather pay less for labor and pay shipping to import the product rather than build it in the USA at USA labor prices. Of course the supply chain disruptions and rising inflation and shipping costs might very well upend that strategy, we will see.