Friday, January 30th 2026

GOG Takes Flak for AI Art in Sale Banner

GOG recently announced its New Year sale, and fans immediately noticed something was off about the site banner advertising the event, with Liam Dawe from GamingOnLinux taking to Reddit to question whether or not the banner was AI-generated. The post generated a range of responses, mostly ranging from outrage to apathy, but a handful of redditors also pointed out that this wasn't the first time GOG used AI art in its marketing images, and that it had recently specifically mentioned proficiency with AI tools in a recent job listing for a developer to work on the Linux version of GOG Galaxy.

The topic of the AI-generated banner was also brought up on the GOG forum, where a GOG employee, who is involved in graphic design in the marketing department, commented at length on the post. The artist confirmed that the artwork is completely AI generated, although they deny that it was their work and decline to comment further on the company's internal AI use. However, they do expand on their personal opposition to AI at length, lamenting how ubiquitous it has become and how, around five years ago, "everything you'd see was something someone had spent time on...so it was worth being looked at," while this is not the case anymore. The full comment speaks to what appears to be an internal divide on the use of AI art, and this is a divide we observed in a recent State of the Gaming Industry survey as well, where many game industry workers admitted to using AI but most still thought it was harmful to gaming.
Sources: Liam Dawe on Reddit, GOG, GamingOnLinux, KosmicznaPluskwa on the GOG forum
Add your own comment

72 Comments on GOG Takes Flak for AI Art in Sale Banner

#26
Athena
AssimilatorIf this was a piece of art that was going on a company-internal PowerPoint I'd be inclined to agree, but that banner image will be seen by thousands, maybe millions of people. If it was created by an artist, that would represent a massive opportunity for their work to be seen, and potentially for them to be contacted by people who like the style and want to commission work from said artist.
Hmm? artists don't sign banner ads, so how is someone going to know that a specific artist made it?

I know artists that have portfolios of things that they have created, and use that to get a new job, but nobody is going to look at a banner on GOG and go, I have got to get in touch with the person who made it, that isn't how it works

there are a TON of artists out there that do pretty much what AI is doing, and even worse, outright stealing other artists work, and call it their own

heck, it's even legal to do so in some communist countries, there are a TON of knock-offs, but I suppose you think this is fine, since otherwise the knock-off artists would be deprived of income?

some artists walk down the street and get inspiration from other people's work, be it car designs or buildings or whatever else that they might see along the way, and from that create their own work
does the artist then go out and find all the people that gave them the inspiration from what they made, and give them a cut on the finished product?
No, that would be silly


the same arguments were made when some robots started to take over some jobs, never mind that the robots were saving human lives from extremely dangerous work, the robots were depriving those humans of income

bottom line is, GOG did nothing wrong, they DO have a paid person overseeing marketing, and AI is just a tool they can use to get the job done
Posted on Reply
#27
Vayra86
lexluthermiesterThis an interesting perspective. I kinda like it.

I'm no fan of AI intruding on our lives, but as a tool, hell yes it's a good thing.
This is how the use of agentic AI is supposed to work, too.
Posted on Reply
#28
R-T-B
FreedomEclipseAm I the only one here that sees this as an non issue?

There are loads of things to take issue with when it comes to Ai in game design. Using it to write scripts, generate Ai art for the game - fill in job rolls that shouldn't be filled in because real people cost money etc etc.

But staff here are still getting paid and it takes probably less than 5 mins to generate banners that aren't hurting anyone.

I don't see what the problem is here. It seems to be a big fuss over nothing.
I'll always take issue with AI given how it essentially operates as a legal plagiarism machine.
Solaris17No. People will cry about anything.
I don't see plagiarism like AI does in its training process as a light issue, but ok.

I'm honestly surprised given how whiney TPU can be that not more of you are upset at this.
Posted on Reply
#29
Scircura
I appreciated the GOG employee (KosmicznaPluskwa)'s old-school internet wall of text ramble. Their words:
Maybe it doesn't matter some store put out sloppy work on promo banner - in the end everyone is just there to buy the product - but I know I enjoy seeing cool new artworks out there, when I'm out to buy new products as well.
Posted on Reply
#30
Frick
Fishfaced Nincompoop
Vayra86Original, mind blowing, interesting, unique, are all possible connotations for things we perceive as 'better'. There are many more, and they are also directly influenced by the moment in which they're made and the general experience of the audience seeing it.

Its incredibly abstract, and yet, its really not, which is why we define some things as 'art' and other stuff as 'slop'.
Who decides what is slop and not? There's a lot of bad human art, but at least someone has touched it.
Vayra86It also describes how generative AI will eventually generate itself into a hole of 'whatever, we've seen this before'.
This is true.
NaterAre you kidding me? Generative design is a game changer, it's been around for years, and the AI boogy-man only enhances it. It's the kind of tech that will take us out of this galaxy someday.
How?
Posted on Reply
#32
Ware
Vayra86a vast majority of 'artists' are really not that good and are themselves a big pile of derivative works and techniques
Good or not is subjective, but it's just a fact that we all have influences.
Listening to modern artists act like they just invented something is comical to me.
Ultimately, we all are riding on the work of the first caveman that grunted and picked up a rock.
AssimilatorAnd yes, programming is a creative profession - another thing that the people trying to automate it away lie about or don't understand. Mostly because they're not programmers; they're MBAs, whose only creative ideas involve the imposition of misery.
Profound and true
R-T-Bit essentially operates as a legal plagiarism machine
I'm honestly trying to consider this position, and I've seen that some AI can be just that.
I'm thinking of a parallel with 'clean room design'. Like the AI training is 'team A', and inference is 'team B'. Team B never has access to the original training material.
If an AI generates a picture that looks exactly like a picture it was trained on, but it WAS generated and not just copied, then you're good to go.
It feels like that law randomly falls on either side of this issue - probably the side with more money.

Nobody cared when people that actually made things lost their jobs to machines.
Now some machines took "artist's" jobs and it's a big deal?
If you ever went to school for anything, you learned how to copy other peoples work.
If you're actually creative, the machines can't take that away yet.
Posted on Reply
#33
Vayra86
FrickWho decides what is slop and not? There's a lot of bad human art, but at least someone has touched it.
I hope individuals do that themselves. Honestly, is art better simply because a human touched it? And... then we get to the definition of human touch. What is that? Some famous painters used their mouth to paint while they were trippin on harddrugs. New painters might let the AI do the trippin for them as they feed it with an ever expanding prompt. Is there a difference and what is it?

Additionally... the space of art should be especially interested in exploring this space 'as art'. Look at the tools artists have used to create works. Its super diverse.
Posted on Reply
#34
Prime2515102
I wonder how many AI created games will be on GOG 20 years from now...
Posted on Reply
#35
evernessince
FreedomEclipseAm I the only one here that sees this as an non issue?

There are loads of things to take issue with when it comes to Ai in game design. Using it to write scripts, generate Ai art for the game - fill in job rolls that shouldn't be filled in because real people cost money etc etc.

But staff here are still getting paid and it takes probably less than 5 mins to generate banners that aren't hurting anyone.

I don't see what the problem is here. It seems to be a big fuss over nothing.
I dunno, maybe if it looked good but it doesn't. It looks like generic AI art. With AI art you are relying entirely on the person inputting the prompt and are limited by what the AI model can do. You still need an artist is some way shape or form, they'll know what'll look best for what you are going for and they have experience to know what works and what doesn't. An artist will also give you complete control over what you want to do. With AI, it's very hard to maintain consistency.
Posted on Reply
#36
Frick
Fishfaced Nincompoop
Nater
I'm not even sure what you're point is. Note how many comments say "this is topology optimization which isn't generative design". I'm yet to see an example of why generative AI "art" is actually beneficial.
Vayra86I hope individuals do that themselves. Honestly, is art better simply because a human touched it? And... then we get to the definition of human touch. What is that? Some famous painters used their mouth to paint while they were trippin on harddrugs. New painters might let the AI do the trippin for them as they feed it with an ever expanding prompt. Is there a difference and what is it?

Additionally... the space of art should be especially interested in exploring this space 'as art'. Look at the tools artists have used to create works. Its super diverse.
I don't even know what you're talking about anymore man. But sure, any art made by humans is better than AI art because AI can't make art. They can generate images and whatever, but that's not the same thing.
Posted on Reply
#37
Athena
FrickI don't even know what you're talking about anymore man. But sure, any art made by humans is better than AI art because AI can't make art. They can generate images and whatever, but that's not the same thing.
That's the thing though, there are AIs that can generate original art, so how is that not the same thing?

I assume you admit that humans get their ideas from what they see (for the most part), right?
AIs can do basically the same thing, they can scan billions of images, be it from nature or space or other work, and from that, it can generate an original image

A portrait of Edmond de Belamy, that was trained on 15K historical images was sold for $430K
Posted on Reply
#38
R-T-B
WareNow some machines took "artist's" jobs and it's a big deal?
Yes. Art is a fundemental pillar of the human experience so hell yes its an issue.
Vayra86Honestly, is art better simply because a human touched it?
Yes.
Athenathere are AIs that can generate original art,
I am highly doubtful... The way AIs do it is honestly not comparable at all.
Posted on Reply
#39
Frick
Fishfaced Nincompoop
AthenaThat's the thing though, there are AIs that can generate original art, so how is that not the same thing?

I assume you admit that humans get their ideas from what they see (for the most part), right?
AIs can do basically the same thing, they can scan billions of images, be it from nature or space or other work, and from that, it can generate an original image

A portrait of Edmond de Belamy, that was trained on 15K historical images was sold for $430K
So this argument came up a lot when this thing started and it's entirely nonsensical. No combination of hardware or software can even come close to replicate the complexities of something like the brain of the dumbest dog. And that's the point: Sure an algorithm might be able to create a compilation of colours that has never existed before, but why is that interesting? There is no thought or emotion or drive behind any of it. We've been afflicted with the idea of money and worth and value for a very long time and now we are supposed to make ourselves worthy of a "living wage". Artists are only worth whatever they are able to sell, which means art has a market value. It's a commodity. And as with all commodities trends are coming and going and with those trends comes assumptions, like that X is good and Y is not as good and therefore the closer something is to X the better it is. Enter AI and techbros, which is the natural progression of the little shits who walk around a modern art gallery and say things like "My kid can do that, this is therefore bad art". On a fundemental level it's a question of education, and capitalism: What has worth, and what does not have worth? X has worth, Y has no worth, therefore X is better. I have a relative who sends me AI generated stuff and says things like "The first chapters suck because I wrote them on my own but the rest of the book is pretty great because AI" and the AI stuff is without exception the most soulless things you can imagine. It's tragic, and it's offensive to my core, because humans are worth so much more than computers and I truly believe if you remove the human from any creative endevour you remove its purpose.

So lets go back to the banner this is about, and why art direction is everywhere. Look at the furniture you have. Look at the website you're currently visiting. Look at the keyboard you're typing on. Look at the toothbrush you have. Literally every single one of those things is a result of art and design, and if they look soulless and shitty that is a result of the times we're living in. Streamlined looks. Designers burnt out and educated by a system unintersted in anything buy profit. That is the system that birthed AI. Who are pushing the hardest for AI? The people selling it, and people who doesn't want to make the effort of actually making something. As this very topic hints at a lot of people are drawing lines in the sand. They've taken everything else, and now the assholes are coming for our art? The thing we use as an outlet? It's a cry of rebellion in a way. Like how I think most music is bad, but even the shittiest of jazz albums is infinitely more valuable than anything any AI can ever achieve.

But a lot of people don't understand this, especially not the variously autistic computer nerds, and they are the shits who, alongside the boomers, are more or less ruling the world becaue they rule the tech-side of the world. And they're trying to usurp art, because they have been taught they're bad at it. I don't know why people are ok with it. This was a rant, and some day I might articulate it better, but whenever I try to think about it I just get so sad my brain malfunctions and anyway what's the point? No matter what I say people will still say shit like "no this is good because someone spent $430k at it". You know what people also spent a lot of money on? NFTs.
Posted on Reply
#40
GodisanAtheist
AI is part of the culture war (TM) now.

You're either for it or you're against it. No nuance allowed.

GOG should have known better. It appeals to a niche of hipster type individuals who are all about "ownership" and "preservation" and likely overlap pretty well with the "BOO AI SLOP" crowd.
Posted on Reply
#41
lexluthermiester
GodisanAtheistYou're either for it or you're against it. No nuance allowed.
Nonsense. There is a nuance for everything in life. Whiners are whining, little more.
Posted on Reply
#42
cinemaware
GodisanAtheistAI is part of the culture war (TM) now.

You're either for it or you're against it. No nuance allowed.

GOG should have known better. It appeals to a niche of hipster type individuals who are all about "ownership" and "preservation" and likely overlap pretty well with the "BOO AI SLOP" crowd.
I'm all for videogame preservation and ownership but don't think GOG is particularly relevant to either of these notions (reasons). Nevertheless, I like and support this store.

I think AI is very useful right now when it comes to search and some other data-related tasks, and use it every day. I think that perhaps in the future there is a chance it could lead to some important breakthroughs in science too. I also think that overall its net worth will be negative for human race and would switch it off forever if I could.

And finally, right now, I think that AI has no place in art-related endeavours, (outside of personal use). That includes GOG banners. AI art slop is real.

Was that nuanced enough, or am I a part of the hipster boo crowd? ;)
Posted on Reply
#43
Athena
R-T-BI am highly doubtful... The way AIs do it is honestly not comparable at all.
so, looking at all these, aiartshop.com/collections/portraits-ai, you are saying that those don't compare to what a human can do?

as these things keep getting better and better, you won't be able to tell any difference at all, and that isn't that far off
Posted on Reply
#44
Scrizz
AssimilatorNo, a software engineer is paid to deliver value. Writing and throwing away code is part of the process that allows you to get to the design that is the best value for the problem at hand, in the exact same way that an artist tries out multiple sketches before deciding to progress one of them to a painting.

The lie that the AI companies are pushing, and that people who don't understand creative professions buy into, is that you get the same result if these "menial" processes are automated away. The problem is that it's also part of the job of creatives to explain to others, why their grand idea cannot be made real - generally precisely because it cannot be accommodated by those menial processes, that are fundamental to the discipline at hand.

Or to put it more bluntly, part of what I get paid for as a developer is to tell you that your idea is s**t because it can't be implemented. Throwing that idea at an LLM won't change that fact.

And yes, programming is a creative profession - another thing that the people trying to automate it away lie about or don't understand. Mostly because they're not programmers; they're MBAs, whose only creative ideas involve the imposition of misery.
Believe it or not, you're actually agreeing with that I said.
It's the creative professional/engineers job to know what works, what doesn't, and why... not the tool's job.
:laugh:
Posted on Reply
#45
Fourstaff
Back in the good old days, digital art is not art. Real artists use paint, not some pixel on screen nonsense. I am happy to report that digital art is now art, only because AI is not art. One day, maybe we will have robots making art. That will not be art, but if its AI prompted by humans, that is art.
Posted on Reply
#46
lexluthermiester
I am both a digital artist and an oil painter. Whether your tool for making art is an oil brush or a mouse/digital pen, the fundamental concept of being an artist is the act of creating. This is just the scope of creating visual forms of image art. There are many other forms of artistry.

How AI factors in is open for debate, and debate can be healthy.
Posted on Reply
#47
Vayra86
FrickSo this argument came up a lot when this thing started and it's entirely nonsensical. No combination of hardware or software can even come close to replicate the complexities of something like the brain of the dumbest dog. And that's the point: Sure an algorithm might be able to create a compilation of colours that has never existed before, but why is that interesting? There is no thought or emotion or drive behind any of it. We've been afflicted with the idea of money and worth and value for a very long time and now we are supposed to make ourselves worthy of a "living wage". Artists are only worth whatever they are able to sell, which means art has a market value. It's a commodity. And as with all commodities trends are coming and going and with those trends comes assumptions, like that X is good and Y is not as good and therefore the closer something is to X the better it is. Enter AI and techbros, which is the natural progression of the little shits who walk around a modern art gallery and say things like "My kid can do that, this is therefore bad art". On a fundemental level it's a question of education, and capitalism: What has worth, and what does not have worth? X has worth, Y has no worth, therefore X is better. I have a relative who sends me AI generated stuff and says things like "The first chapters suck because I wrote them on my own but the rest of the book is pretty great because AI" and the AI stuff is without exception the most soulless things you can imagine. It's tragic, and it's offensive to my core, because humans are worth so much more than computers and I truly believe if you remove the human from any creative endevour you remove its purpose.

So lets go back to the banner this is about, and why art direction is everywhere. Look at the furniture you have. Look at the website you're currently visiting. Look at the keyboard you're typing on. Look at the toothbrush you have. Literally every single one of those things is a result of art and design, and if they look soulless and shitty that is a result of the times we're living in. Streamlined looks. Designers burnt out and educated by a system unintersted in anything buy profit. That is the system that birthed AI. Who are pushing the hardest for AI? The people selling it, and people who doesn't want to make the effort of actually making something. As this very topic hints at a lot of people are drawing lines in the sand. They've taken everything else, and now the assholes are coming for our art? The thing we use as an outlet? It's a cry of rebellion in a way. Like how I think most music is bad, but even the shittiest of jazz albums is infinitely more valuable than anything any AI can ever achieve.

But a lot of people don't understand this, especially not the variously autistic computer nerds, and they are the shits who, alongside the boomers, are more or less ruling the world becaue they rule the tech-side of the world. And they're trying to usurp art, because they have been taught they're bad at it. I don't know why people are ok with it. This was a rant, and some day I might articulate it better, but whenever I try to think about it I just get so sad my brain malfunctions and anyway what's the point? No matter what I say people will still say shit like "no this is good because someone spent $430k at it". You know what people also spent a lot of money on? NFTs.
Could not agree more on that perspective. Well said.

But I do think the exploration part of it is capable of being art. It would be silly to say an artist cant explore AI as a tool to make something. But it is as you say: the why is what defines what is art and whats 13 in a dozen crap.

As much as I see the bullshit money going around NFT-level 'art', I still do trust humans quite a bit when it comes to their personal taste. Art was never a mass mainstream thing. This wont change, but I also think art will always be relevant. Its an intrinsic thing.
FourstaffBack in the good old days, digital art is not art. Real artists use paint, not some pixel on screen nonsense. I am happy to report that digital art is now art, only because AI is not art. One day, maybe we will have robots making art. That will not be art, but if its AI prompted by humans, that is art.
Yep the sliding scale....
Posted on Reply
#48
Easo
The outrage is both too big (common people...) and also of course GoG really should have just paid the "100 bucks" to anyone on DeviantArt or whatever.
Posted on Reply
#49
R-T-B
Athenayou are saying that those don't compare to what a human can do?
No, I'm saying that literally isn't the point of art for me. It could be stick figures and I'd still prefer it to unthinking machine slop.
Vayra86The movement is in the other direction: away from coding and into prompting to produce code for you.
Only if you want garbage code, or boilerplate.
Athenayou won't be able to tell any difference at all
That doesn't make it any less wrong.
Posted on Reply
#50
Assimilator
Athenaso, looking at all these, aiartshop.com/collections/portraits-ai, you are saying that those don't compare to what a human can do?

as these things keep getting better and better, you won't be able to tell any difference at all, and that isn't that far off
It's not about what comparing to what a human can or can't do. It's the fact that art is art precisely because it involves a human, a piece of its creator; an LLM doesn't involve a human, so it isn't art. Or you could say that an LLM-generated work involves every human whose training data was used for that LM - except that in the same way mixing every colour produces brown, which nobody wants, an LLM is an average of every unique human input - and therefore soulless.

The fact that someone paid hundreds of thousands of dollars for a piece of AI-generated art proves nothing. People paid the same amount for NFTs and those are worthless now.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 15th, 2026 20:33 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts