Sunday, February 26th 2017

Intel Plays Dirty Over Ryzen, Attempts to Manipulate Ryzen Reviews?

Intel is rattled with AMD Ryzen. Its 10-year old Nehalem CPU architecture that has been shrunk and incrementally updated over the years, is finally coming across as dated in the wake of AMD's "Zen" architecture. What to do when a competitor with 1/50th your R&D budget threatens to wreck your next annual appraisal? Play dirty and arm-twist the media of course! And playing dirty Intel is, according to a TweakTown report.

Apparently, Intel has scrambled its PR department to call in favors with the press in return for "guidelines" on how to review AMD Ryzen. Intel's PR emails allegedly ask reviewers to "call us before you write." The guidelines are worded more to make it sound like Intel wants its chips to be reviewed "fairly" against Ryzen, but the underlying objective is clear.
Source: TweakTown
Add your own comment

72 Comments on Intel Plays Dirty Over Ryzen, Attempts to Manipulate Ryzen Reviews?

#26
notb
No proof, no details... throw dirt and some will stick. :)

In the online review world (blogs and stuff) we got used to often fairly poor quality of news and reviews, but honestly - wouldn't you expect a professional journalist to contact Intel for official statement?

From what we've seen in the leaks, the "guidance" from Intel could as simply be an information that they've been prepared and an answer is going to be released soon, so that the reviews would end with something like:
"Intel says they'll upcoming CPUs will make them competitive once more"
instead of:
"Will Intel respond?"

Sure, we might call this "stealing AMD's thunder" or simply an aggressive marketing strategy, but "dirty"?
Posted on Reply
#27
Vlada011
It's not possible to manipulate with reviews like that when 350$ CPU overclocked is faster than 1700$ CPU.
How you can explain that. Only to lose reputation with lies.
A lot of people say that Intel change very little from Nehalem and it was not hard to understand that ASUS ROG sell their processors with their premium motherboards.
But Intel was only option last 3 years or serious performance drop. AMD had problem to pull max from Kepler architecture and there are two more newer.
It's good because this is not able to compensate with 100-200$ lower price, 200-300MHz higher clock and 10-20% improvement and Intel now need 50% improvement, good for customers who get 5% every year and new chipset. New chipset need for 5% upgrade. Because of that I decide to change to Xtreme, I couldn't stand to my platform is outdate 5 months after build. From that side AMD could be very good investment. Socket will be compatible with new models up to 5 years maybe, chipset 2-3 years.
Posted on Reply
#28
Vayra86
People still visit TweakTown after that brainfart about ad blockers?
Posted on Reply
#29
bug
cyneaterSad part is intel got DEC's IP for the alpha etc and did nothing really good with it... They only wanted it so no one else could have it.
Actually, the bus that made Athlon great (EV6 or EV7 iirc), was also something AMD got from DEC ;)
And Microsoft got the guys that did NTFS.
Posted on Reply
#30
kn00tcn
see, this is the type of title people have a problem with

the call us could mean multiple things, a reviewer can cherry pick or cherry smash based on what intel says, but this doesnt count as dirty yet, it depends on what variable is changing
Posted on Reply
#32
remixedcat
Need more proof that it's in fact Intel and not just their scizo crap here....
Posted on Reply
#33
bug
Stop whining. We all know there's nothing in the pipeline at intel. If Ryzen delivers as expected, intel can only counter through marketing and pricing for a while. They will push boundaries and occasionally step across them if that saves them some $$$. It's not nice, pretty or maybe even legal, but was anyone expecting anything else? This is business, not a family affair. (Not that some families won't stab you in the back on occasion either.)
Posted on Reply
#34
EarthDog
the54thvoidThis.

CD lost credibility a long time ago. We'd need proof from a review site of this.
Here is an email I saw...

'We hear there may be some news from amd coming out tomorrow (a few days ago)..would you like a statement from Intel'?
Posted on Reply
#35
Parn
It used to be far worse during the P4/A64 era.

Anyway I'll be back to the AMD camp if the reviews turn out to be positive.
Posted on Reply
#36
Evo85
the54thvoidSo not anything unusual.
No doubt! They were wrong on every single Ryzen leak!
Posted on Reply
#37
laszlo
from Intel guideline to reviewers:

" cut end zero from amd scores and move it to our scores"
"every cut will be rewarded with a 10k $ multiplier "
Posted on Reply
#38
Vayra86
laszlofrom Intel guideline to reviewers:

" cut end zero from amd scores and move it to our scores"
"every cut will be rewarded with a 10k $ multiplier "
Intel and multipliers have always been great business. But no more ;)
Posted on Reply
#39
coolernoob
intel at its finest... tricks like these (to threten media) will not even cost a few hundred millions $ for intel... but there is more dirty plays from intel that costed billions for them in the past...and intel did pull it trhough - that is why we find our selves in such a horribly uncompetitive CPU market (... well till 02.march at least)
Posted on Reply
#40
EarthDog
I don't think I ever saw or heard of any verbiage threatening reviewers.

Where did you see that....or are we just stoking the fire???
EarthDogDid whoever is in contact with Intel @ TPU receive an email or phone call?
@btarunr
Posted on Reply
#41
Steven B
To be fair I am the CPU reviewer at TweakTown, I communicate with Intel at TweakTown, and they didnt try and ask me to talk to them about my Ryzen review and our relationship is fine. Maybe they only did it with press they thoight would use amds slides instead of making their own? idk
Posted on Reply
#42
Iluv2raceit
Not surprised at all. The more obvious proof that Intel is indeed guilty of trying to manipulate the Ryzen reviews is the fact that Intel has yet to lower their CPU prices in order to be competitive with Ryzen's much lower, more aggressive pricing. Intel is invoking a multi-stage strategy whereby they will attempt to discredit or outright lie about Ryzen's performance. The last thing Intel wants to do is cut into profits and reduce the faith of shareholders. This approach, IMHO is extremely flawed and shows that Intel has not learned from the 2009 debacle where they were caught doing the same exact thing by giving away CPUs (as well as paying money) to vendors and PC hardware websites in order to receive a favorable reviews. This is just one more reason why I am switching teams to AMD from Intel. I will NOT miss my 5-year old 3930K at all. Thanks for the memories Intel :p My R7 1800X arrives on Thursday! :D
Posted on Reply
#43
JalleR
Steven BTo be fair I am the CPU reviewer at TweakTown, I communicate with Intel at TweakTown, and they didnt try and ask me to talk to them about my Ryzen review and our relationship is fine. Maybe they only did it with press they thoight would use amds slides instead of making their own? idk
So How is Ryzen performing :D

I'm NOT working for intel. (not trying to bribe or anything)
Posted on Reply
#44
Iluv2raceit
JalleRSo How is Ryzen performing :D

I'm NOT working for intel. (not trying to bribe or anything)
You'll find out soon enough...AMD NDAs on Ryzen reviews run out at midnight on 2 March. I can guarantee you that reviews will literally post on 2 March at 12:01AM EST... :D
Posted on Reply
#46
yogurt_21
charlie's still around? I remember him being pretty much proven to be a fud spreader 11 years ago... he's still at it?
Posted on Reply
#47
EarthDog
Iluv2raceitYou'll find out soon enough...AMD NDAs on Ryzen reviews run out at midnight on 2 March. I can guarantee you that reviews will literally post on 2 March at 12:01AM EST... :D
LOL... I wouldn't bet on that...
yogurt_21charlie's still around? I remember him being pretty much proven to be a fud spreader 11 years ago... he's still at it?
I had the pleasure of meeting him in person at some of the media events... the vibe you get from his articles, are the vibe you get from him as a person....
Posted on Reply
#48
Iluv2raceit
EarthDogLOL... I wouldn't bet on that...
How much? Let's go!
Posted on Reply
#49
Iluv2raceit
yogurt_21charlie's still around? I remember him being pretty much proven to be a fud spreader 11 years ago... he's still at it?
Another 'paid under the table by Intel' lap dog? Just guessing...
Posted on Reply
#50
EarthDog
Only time will tell, right?

But bud, please edit your posts to add. Its against the rules to double posts.. Mods come through with a ruler and whack your knuckles. ;)
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 17th, 2026 20:42 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts