Monday, February 2nd 2026

GOG Addresses AI Art Banner: "We Failed On Two Levels"

Recently, GOG, the game storefront and distribution platform, took some heat over the inclusion of AI-generated art in promotional imagery for a New Year sale. It received so much backlash online that an employee in the marketing department took to the GOG forum to respond the same day news broke, however, now, GOG has issued an official response in its Discord server for GOG Patrons (courtesy of Kotaku).

In the lengthy response, the GOG representative explains that the art was indeed AI generated, although this had been confirmed previously, but they explain that the banner was a WIP (work in progress) asset and was never meant to be shared. GOG also says that it "failed on at least two levels: Quality-control of the asset that landed on the front page, and then reacting quickly enough when we noticed the error." The rep goes on to acknowledge its community's disappointment in the use of AI, but says that GOG is a very small team that has been testing different technologies and tools that allow the team to do more with fewer hands. The full statement is available below, but it essentially seems as though GOG is incorporating generative AI into its workflows, despite the negative backlash, internally, externally, and even from the gaming industry at large.
Hi everyone, I'd like to address the case of our recent New Year Sale banner.

First of all, regarding the quality of the asset: This banner was a work-in-progress asset that we mistakenly allowed to be displayed on the storefront. This shouldn't have happened. We failed on at least two levels: Quality-control of the asset that landed on the front page, and then reacting quickly enough when we noticed the error.
Second, I want to confirm that this WIP asset was indeed made with the help of Al tools. We hear your disappointment with the use of this technology, and see that it's a sensitive topic for many of you.

I also want to be honest about how we chose to explore technology: We don't have the infinite resources of the industry giants. We're a dedicated, but small team, working our asses off every day for game preservation. To keep that mission alive, bring more games back to life, and make more games DRM-free, we experiment with tools that can allow us to do more with the limited hands we have.

We've been testing different technologies since our beginnings. Some experiments are successful, and some (like this banner) are not. Exploring various tech gives us the reach of a much larger team, so we never have to settle for doing less.

Lastly, I'm aware that some of you have concerns about a GOG team member leaving the Patrons Discord server. Please understand that in heated moments, people sometimes need to step back for their own well-being. That was a personal decision, and we respect it.

Thank you, everyone,
Arthur
Source: GOG via Kotaku
Add your own comment

26 Comments on GOG Addresses AI Art Banner: "We Failed On Two Levels"

#1
Fouquin
Cpt.JankGOG has issued an official response in its Discord server
This has got to stop. Official responses need to be posted on the main site, as a bulletin, in a newsletter, as a blog post, or in any other way that can be viewed from any web browser via a sharable URL.

Discord servers are not official public communication channels, they are limited access community silos with no external search indexing and zero visibility outside the platform.

This is like if a company put up an apology poster in their headquarters lobby and then acting like that's a public official announcement. Technically yes anyone can get in to view the poster but you didn't make any attempt at broadcasting.
Posted on Reply
#2
Cpt.Jank
FouquinTechnically yes anyone can get in to view the poster but you didn't make any attempt at broadcasting.
Well, no. This is in the official GOG Patrons server, which costs money to join. So it's even worse than you say.
Posted on Reply
#3
Fouquin
Cpt.JankWell, no. This is in the official GOG Patrons server, which costs money to join. So it's even worse than you say.
Great so they can publish an ACTUAL announcement on their community blog, or on their press page, or in their publicly visible community forum with an updated title, "We Failed on Three Levels" because if you are making an actual official apology or announcement you wouldn't hide it an a paid-access Discord server.
Posted on Reply
#4
Beertintedgoggles
At this point, just double down and have AI write the apology.
Posted on Reply
#5
qlum
Apart from the way they appologised which is terrible.

I don't think internal use of image generators is bad. It gives artists a mood / reference that may ve hard to convey by someone who is not good at those things. It can be a nice visual reference to work with. Of course publishing it, is not for a store like gog.
Posted on Reply
#6
Solaris17
Super Dainty Moderator
FouquinThis has got to stop. Official responses need to be posted on the main site, as a bulletin, in a newsletter, as a blog post, or in any other way that can be viewed from any web browser via a sharable URL.

Discord servers are not official public communication channels, they are limited access community silos with no external search indexing and zero visibility outside the platform.

This is like if a company put up an apology poster in their headquarters lobby and then acting like that's a public official announcement. Technically yes anyone can get in to view the poster but you didn't make any attempt at broadcasting.
I dont care about this "outrage" at all with the banner, im just here to support you in that discord is terrible and a terrible official communications channel that makes you look like a child.
Posted on Reply
#7
FreedomEclipse
~Technological Technocrat~
If GoG was going to be a bitch by bending the knee and apologising.

Either apologise where EVERYONE and I mean EVERY-ONE i.e the whole world can see it openly for it to actually mean something or just not bother at all.

Because now you are going to get shit on not just because you bent the knee and apologised but because you also tried to hide it.

GoG shouldnt have apologised either way. But now they'll lose respect and get even more shit flung at them from both sides.

GoG should fire their PR manager.
Posted on Reply
#8
Shihab
Cpt.Jankthe banner was a WIP (work in progress) asset and was never meant to be shared.
Please tell me this isn’t going to be the standard “apology” for genAI-related backlash.
Posted on Reply
#9
lexluthermiester
Wonderful response from GOG! It's the most amazing way of telling the whiners to STFU I have ever seen. It's subtle without being too subtle, it's direct without being overly overt and it's an unmistakable smackdown without coming off as a smackdown! Beautifully masterful!

I love the new owners of GOG!

EDIT:
Oh, and guess what's still on the front page? If you guessed the very same "offending" banner, you'd be right!

Yup, Rock on GOG, fricken Rock on! :rockout:
Posted on Reply
#10
Phuncz
Solaris17I dont care about this "outrage" at all with the banner, im just here to support you in that discord is terrible and a terrible official communications channel that makes you look like a child.
This 100%. The rage about the banner is energy put in the completely wrong place, but Discord is a quicksand trap for data. Without the means to easily find data, like knowing words used in a post, important data gets lost in the sheer amount. It’s a non-public platform without registering and might be blocked in certain situations. This communication specifically being behind another layer of access is even worse. At any point Discord can adjust access, prune old data or require payment for archived data at any time. Or issues with search, limiting search etc.
Posted on Reply
#11
Shihab
“I also want to be honest about how we chose to explore technology: We don't have the infinite resources of the industry giants.”

Reading this paragraph out of context would make you think people were angry that they don’t ship their own OS.

I can pick up a rock and find three dozens of artists happily willing to produce anything for 50~100 bucks. That’s barely even a petty cash expense to even a soho.

You are not a charity to get away with a we can’t afford to excuse, you are a bloody business!
Posted on Reply
#12
Vayra86
Solaris17I dont care about this "outrage" at all with the banner, im just here to support you in that discord is terrible and a terrible official communications channel that makes you look like a child.
Not to mention the fact Discord is rapidly going the Roblox way, infested with bots, scammers and other nonsensical bullshit nobody wants to be in contact with (at least not if you want a clean public branding strategy).

Its weird, man. Why do people with brains follow the brainrotting idiots into their lairs? Because its close to the community? LOL. Yeah, its all love isn't it. Similar things occur on X versus serious journalism and mainstream media. Everyone should have cut ties long ago. Fuck those platforms. All of them are manipulative, misplaced pieces of crap. Great for p2p communication, horrible for public relations and your mental state. It was once good promotion tooling. Das war einmal. And even that is doubtful, you just do it because others do, always trying to find a bigger megaphone for your message. The whole principle is built on continuous escalation. It could never end well.
Posted on Reply
#13
eyenix
I don't see any problem, they are right to use AI
Posted on Reply
#14
Vayra86
lexluthermiesterWonderful response from GOG! It's the most amazing way of telling the whiners to STFU I have ever seen. It's subtle without being too subtle, it's direct without being overly overt and it's an unmistakable smackdown without coming off as a smackdown! Beautifully masterful!

I love the new owners of GOG!

EDIT:
Oh, and guess what's still on the front page? If you guessed the very same "offending" banner, you'd be right!

Yup, Rock on GOG, fricken Rock on! :rockout:
That's... a very interesting take, let's put it like that. But I think you're reading too much into it...

As far as I can see this is a storm in teapot situation, both the 'massive outrage' as well as the 'smart response'... all I see is a few nobodies battling it out on keyboards, really, and TPU reporting it as news. Of course nothing changes. This kind of activism is fun for the daily hype train that is all. There's no logic to any of it. Artists don't cost this much and some one-day-fly ad is not going to make waves anywhere for anyone even if AI wasn't in the picture. They just did something with AI and moved on, saw outrage and somebody posted a message on some nondescript forum nobody cares about. And now we have a story about the response to that.

This is tabloid level journalism, and even that is rating it far too high. If anyone was thinking this is the kind of activism that stops AI push and changes general perception on it... lol.
Posted on Reply
#15
mb194dc
That banner could be done in photoshop in 1 minute by anyone competent. If they're just using free tools and not wasting money that could be better put to use elsewhere, I don't see the problem here.
Posted on Reply
#16
Why_Me
Apologizing for a banner. lol
Posted on Reply
#17
lexluthermiester
Vayra86But I think you're reading too much into it...
Not at all. I'm seeing it for what it is.
Vayra86They just did something with AI and moved on, saw outrage and somebody posted a message on some nondescript forum nobody cares about. And now we have a story about the response to that.
It's knee-jerk outrage about nothing-sauce. That outrage is a genuine example of special-snowflaking.
mb194dcThat banner could be done in photoshop in 1 minute by anyone competent. If they're just using free tools and not wasting money that could be better put to use elsewhere, I don't see the problem here.
Exactly!
Why_MeApologizing for a banner. lol
Yeah the one that is still on the GOG front page.. Such a great apology!
Posted on Reply
#18
Onasi
I don’t know about this being a great apology, it being on Discord aside, including gems like “exploring new technology” while being a store called Good OLD Games and explaining a GOG community manager leaving in a huff as a “heated gamer moment” just adds levels of hilarity to this being an inexplicable shitshow in my opinion. This is peak internet drama without much reason, though I stand by saying that this was easily avoidable without any great expenditure of resources.
Posted on Reply
#19
cvaldes
LOL, this whole episode -- including the comments here at TPU -- are like an SNL parody of the online gamer community.

Bravo everyone!

:):p:D

:clap::peace::lovetpu:

P.S. I only assume that these sort of situations will repeat more frequently in the upcoming months with even greater hilarity. I can't wait!
Posted on Reply
#20
cinemaware
So, if the company in question was, say, Ubisoft, would you guys still say it's a nothingburger, whining, storm in a teacup, etc?
Posted on Reply
#21
claylomax
This story just reminds me I have a GOG account
Posted on Reply
#22
Assimilator
The most important questions that nobody has asked are:
  1. Why does a for-profit company have a donation program?
  2. Who is stupid enough to donate to it?
I guess it's not entirely unexpected, given we live in a world populated by people who paid money for Star Citizen and NFTs, but holy crap. Y'all mofos gotta stop simping for capitalism.
Posted on Reply
#23
qlum
lexluthermiesterWonderful response from GOG! It's the most amazing way of telling the whiners to STFU I have ever seen. It's subtle without being too subtle, it's direct without being overly overt and it's an unmistakable smackdown without coming off as a smackdown! Beautifully masterful!

I love the new owners of GOG!

EDIT:
Oh, and guess what's still on the front page? If you guessed the very same "offending" banner, you'd be right!

Yup, Rock on GOG, fricken Rock on! :rockout:
Oof, imagine apologizing to your paying patrons and keeping the banner anyway.
Posted on Reply
#24
sam_86314
The biggest problem with this banner is it looks like ass.

Out of curiosity, I fired up FLUX.2 Klein locally via SD-Next (FOSS, yay) and made some slop that I think looks at least a bit better.



Prompt is literally just "white and purple 3d text that says "GOG WINTER SALE", realistic video game snowy landscape in the background"
Posted on Reply
#25
lexluthermiester
AssimilatorWhy does a for-profit company have a donation program?
Because it costs a lot of money to R&D backward compatibility for so many older game titles, especially when GOG does not have access to the original source code.
AssimilatorWho is stupid enough to donate to it?
The fact that YOU are calling anyone else stupid says much about your complete lack of understanding. That's on you. Enlighten yourself.
qlumOof, imagine apologizing to your paying patrons and keeping the banner anyway.
I'm one of them and have no problem with the use of AI tools to assist in the ways that have been shown.
sam_86314Out of curiosity, I fired up FLUX.2 Klein locally via SD-Next (FOSS, yay) and made some slop that I think looks at least a bit better.



Prompt is literally just "white and purple 3d text that says "GOG WINTER SALE", realistic video game snowy landscape in the background"
That's not bad. I would have done the "GOG" in purple and the "Winter Sale" in white, but that's just me.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 15th, 2026 20:31 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts