Wednesday, February 25th 2026

Valve in Legal Hot Water in New York Over Loot Boxes and Gambling

The State of New York's attorney general, Letitia James, has officially taken gaming giant, Valve, to court in a state court in Manhattan, alleging that the combination of games like Counter-Strike, Team Fortress, and Dota, wherein players can earn and use real money to buy loot boxes, and Steam's Community Market, where rare skins and items can be sold, often for exorbitant prices, amount to "quintessential gambling." There are reports of Counter-Strike: Global Offensive skins selling for as much as $2.5 million, with the game touted as having the biggest in-game economy of any video game. Valve previously adjusted the way it presented loot boxes and their rewards to players, seemingly specifically to avoid EU gambling regulations.

The lawsuit, spotted by Reuters, alleges that "Valve's loot boxes are particularly pernicious because they are popular among children and adolescents," going on to state that these mechanics put children at risk of becoming addicted, with the complaint adding that children are four times more at risk of becoming addicted to gambling in adulthood if they are exposed to gambling before the age of 12. The lawsuit seeks restitution for players and a fine of three times Valve's earnings from any activities deemed to be illegal. Loot boxes are largely looked down on by gamers and lawmakers alike, because players are encouraged to spend money on them, and they provide no guarantee of any return or specific value. If James succeeds against Valve in the lawsuit, it could set a precedent that may result in sweeping changes across both Steam and the gaming industry at large.
Source: Reuters
Add your own comment

21 Comments on Valve in Legal Hot Water in New York Over Loot Boxes and Gambling

#1
soulphie
fucking yes, finally, Valve is the goldenboy of gaming but we cant let them get away with this gambling shit
Posted on Reply
#2
zenlessyank
fdisk the loot box. Just release the game. If you want more money release another game.
Posted on Reply
#3
yfn_ratchet
On one hand, in a system like CS:GO/CS2's skin market, there is nothing actually providing intrinsic value to any given skin except, potentially, a desire to make a return on the money invested into acquiring it (feeding the skinner box).

On the other hand, Valve should not be at liberty to permit users to speculate on the value of these items on their own marketplace pursuant to a perceived profit made possible via loot box mechanics, because that would very easily qualify it as a gambling scheme and not just people being financially/personally irresponsible. Could be remediated if keys were also available as F2P rewards, or if they abolished a money-backed market entirely in interest of an item bartering market to replace it.
Posted on Reply
#4
shuffy_losys
Every time I see this, I ask... why is TCG seemingly exempt? Just because it's a physical item?
Posted on Reply
#5
yfn_ratchet
shuffy_losysEvery time I see this, I ask... why is TCG seemingly exempt? Just because it's a physical item?
I imagine that's because the businesses/individuals providing a way to monetarily trade cards/packs are external to the business producing them, therefore the producer is not liable for people speculating on the value of rare pieces of printed paper. If you could, for example, trade Pokemon cards for money through a service provided by Nintendo, I imagine things would get very litigious very quickly.
Posted on Reply
#6
shuffy_losys
yfn_ratchetI imagine that's because the businesses/individuals providing a way to monetarily trade cards/packs are external to the business producing them, therefore the producer is not liable for people speculating on the value of rare pieces of printed paper. If you could, for example, trade Pokemon cards for money through a service provided by Nintendo, I imagine things would get very litigious very quickly.
I'm pretty sure a lot of the major TCG manufacturers sell direct now. Or at the very least, Nintendo sells Pokemon cards directly.
Posted on Reply
#7
Onasi
“are exposed to gambling before the age of 12”

Mmm, remind me, what’s the age rating on those games? Oh, it’s not E? It’s actually 12+ or even 17+? Funny how that works.

Anyway, I assume Valve will get out of this the same way they always did - by claiming that those items don’t have intrinsic monetary value, hence not gambling. It’s bullshit, of course, but worked for them previously. Even if this time it doesn’t, they’ve been cognizant of which way the wind blows on this and have been pivoting with things like the new CS terminals.
Posted on Reply
#8
dom1tian
The situation with Pokémon cards is out of pocket. Ive witnessed it first hand. As for valve and gambling. I agree make the keys available as a F2p reward.
Posted on Reply
#9
Visible Noise
OnasiMmm, remind me, what’s the age rating on those games? Oh, it’s not E? It’s actually 12+ or even 17+? Funny how that works
Exactly. Maybe take the kids parents to court for not supervising them, and you know, actually parenting their children.
Posted on Reply
#10
1freedude
I have zero first-hand knowledge of this, but it seems more like money laundering and tax evasion.
Posted on Reply
#11
Visible Noise
1freedudeI have zero first-hand knowledge of this, but it seems more like money laundering and tax evasion.
Steam requires your tax id once you sell a certain amount, for reporting to the IRS. You will get a 1099 form.
Posted on Reply
#12
Onasi
Visible NoiseExactly. Maybe take the kids parents to court for not supervising them, and you know, actually parenting their children.
Oh god, I saw this gem just now looking through the case on the NY GA site:

“In addition, although this case is about illegal gambling, it is important to note that Valve’s promotion of games that glorify violence and guns helps fuel the dangerous epidemic of gun violence, particularly among young gamers who can become numbed to grave violence before their brains are fully developed.”

Yeah, okay, this is a clown case.
Posted on Reply
#13
dom1tian
OnasiOh god, I saw this gem just now looking through the case on the NY GA site:

“In addition, although this case is about illegal gambling, it is important to note that Valve’s promotion of games that glorify violence and guns helps fuel the dangerous epidemic of gun violence, particularly among young gamers who can become numbed to grave violence before their brains are fully developed.”

Yeah, okay, this is a clown case.
Lol
Posted on Reply
#14
cinemaware
soulphiefucking yes, finally, Valve is the goldenboy of gaming but we cant let them get away with this gambling shit
The goldenboy that takes nearly one third of dev/publisher income and murdered physical games. Three cheers to that. The "gambling shit", disgusting as it is, is small beer compared to these things.
Posted on Reply
#15
LastDudeALive
cinemawareThe goldenboy that takes nearly one third of dev/publisher income and murdered physical games. Three cheers to that. The "gambling shit", disgusting as it is, is small beer compared to these things.
Oh no, not physical games! I love having to download my games from an easily damaged storage medium and being limited by the slow developments in blue-ray disk technology instead of getting them in seconds from a world-wide CDN along with cloud saves, patches & DLC, friends list, & quick refunds if the game is bad/unplayable. I totally want to have to lug a blue-ray player around just to play on my laptop, Steam Deck, VR headset, etc.
Posted on Reply
#16
Visible Noise
OnasiOh god, I saw this gem just now looking through the case on the NY GA site:

“In addition, although this case is about illegal gambling, it is important to note that Valve’s promotion of games that glorify violence and guns helps fuel the dangerous epidemic of gun violence, particularly among young gamers who can become numbed to grave violence before their brains are fully developed.”

Yeah, okay, this is a clown case.
But won’t you think about the children!

/s
Posted on Reply
#17
yfn_ratchet
shuffy_losysI'm pretty sure a lot of the major TCG manufacturers sell direct now. Or at the very least, Nintendo sells Pokemon cards directly.
I meant moreso you could 'sell' your cards back to Nintendo for money, or be paid by someone for your card via a Nintendo service. Being the original seller of the packs by itself has very little grounds for encouraging gambling, lol.
Posted on Reply
#18
Vayra86
shuffy_losysI'm pretty sure a lot of the major TCG manufacturers sell direct now. Or at the very least, Nintendo sells Pokemon cards directly.
They do. I think part of it is indeed physical item, and with that comes a certain balance of power in the market. A digital skin is nothing really, for similar reasons an NFT is an empty shell. But an actual card, limited in print - or printed in a certain way, or during a certain time, with or without usage marks is more like a rare painting. You can play a game with it. Or you can collect them for god knows what reason. You could also speculate with it. Even if said card is reprinted, it will never be of that specific print run or era.

Digital goods lack this uniqueness and therefore a similar market dynamic, even though lots of idiots keep believing it somehow can be. Again; the failure of NFT proves it will never be the same.
yfn_ratchetI imagine that's because the businesses/individuals providing a way to monetarily trade cards/packs are external to the business producing them, therefore the producer is not liable for people speculating on the value of rare pieces of printed paper. If you could, for example, trade Pokemon cards for money through a service provided by Nintendo, I imagine things would get very litigious very quickly.
Yep. You can trade cards freely but for CS skins you can only access them through a service and all you really own is a license.
Posted on Reply
#19
vlad.coolish
Let she taking to court for Sotheby's.
How can this skin for canvas cost US $400 million? :rolleyes:
Posted on Reply
#20
csendesmark
I like Valve, one of the best developer studio ever,
but I really hate this lootbox stuff,
LOOTBOXES MUST GO!
vlad.coolishLet she taking to court for Sotheby's.
How can this skin for canvas cost US $400 million? :rolleyes:
modern art is basically just became tax fraud
that too should go
Posted on Reply
#21
vigor
Who is paying more than $10 for these skins! :kookoo:
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 18th, 2026 11:18 CST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts