Tuesday, July 21st 2026

Forza Horizon 5 Creative Director Defends Xbox Game Pass: "It's a Good Idea"

In a recent episode of the MinnMax podcast, Mike Brown, creative director of Forza Horizon 5 and co-founder of Maverick Games since leaving Playground Games to work on Clutch at Maverick Games, commented on Xbox's recent sweeping changes and the state of Xbox Game Pass. He has a lot of praise for the former Xbox leadership, both Sarah Bond and Phil Spencer, and comments that the current state of Xbox and the recent layoffs are both "sad."

Brown goes on to say about Game Pass that "they've obviously invested a fortune in the concept of Game Pass, as a service," which has led to "loads of acquisitions" in order to get games in Game Pass, but he adds that "not enough people have subscribed to it at prices that they needed to pay in order to make that business viable." He explains that the concept of Game Pass was "well-meaning," "player-focussed," and a "good concept."
Brown praises Game Pass, commenting that the combination of low pricing and a wide and diverse
selection of games with the convenience of a subscription service is a good idea and probably led to games being created that otherwise wouldn't be able to exist. Recent reported numbers put peak Game Pass subscribers at 30 million at the end of FY 2026, which is 47 million shy of the 77 million target set when Game Pass first launched in 2017.

Following Asha Sharma's takeover as CEO of Xbox, the company has started to pivot away from game production and features like Game Pass as its main attraction—while Game Pass has become cheaper under Sharma, the new CEO has also removed Call of Duty from Game Pass along with many other day-one launches. Instead, Sharma will be leaning into Xbox's hardware business and trying to claw back market share with a renewed interest in Xbox exclusives.
Source: MinnMax on YouTube
Add your own comment

22 Comments on Forza Horizon 5 Creative Director Defends Xbox Game Pass: "It's a Good Idea"

#1
Onasi
Saying that it’s a good idea and in the same breath laying out why it straight up wasn’t feasible as a business model is… a take.
Posted on Reply
#2
Bigshrimp
OnasiSaying that it’s a good idea and in the same breath laying out why it straight up wasn’t feasible as a business model is… a take.
It's just more E-suite doublespeak. They always contradict themselves as they don't really mean what they say, ever. They will just move the goal posts after being caught out in their bs.
Posted on Reply
#3
Let3r
It is a good idea, for XBox and the people profiting from it.
Posted on Reply
#5
JustBenching
Dr. DroThe creator of Ori has it right:


The only game I really wanted to keep playing through XGP back then is a game I have on Steam and with 3400 hours on rn. If I bother with my Xbox ever again, I'll just buy it...
South of midnight cost 100m? What? Why? AA titles like that cost between 5 and 20.
Posted on Reply
#6
lambda
JustBenchingSouth of midnight cost 100m? What? Why? AA titles like that cost between 5 and 20.
A lot of creative fields have poor "ROI" in strictly business terms but you cannot evaluate art just on the basis of revenue.

Sad to see people being laid off due to terrible decisions from Xbox mgmnt.
Posted on Reply
#7
Dr. Dro
JustBenchingSouth of midnight cost 100m? What? Why? AA titles like that cost between 5 and 20.
My best guess is all the incurred overhead from, ahem, "consultancy" and hiring practices. That it sold 500K copies is a dubious claim in itself, the market for a game like that simply doesn't exist.
Posted on Reply
#8
Bigshrimp
lambdaA lot of creative fields have poor "ROI" in strictly business terms but you cannot evaluate art just on the basis of revenue.

Sad to see people being laid off due to terrible decisions from Xbox mgmnt.
Agreed. The employees are typically the real victims of management's failures. All the while, management gets a golden parachute and another job somewhere else, like clockwork.
Posted on Reply
#9
Dr_b_
So much for the "you will own nothing, and be happy" business model. That was a dream for business to persistently extract rents from people
Posted on Reply
#10
TheinsanegamerN
BigshrimpAgreed. The employees are typically the real victims of management's failures. All the while, management gets a golden parachute and another job somewhere else, like clockwork.
This concept of the "poor worker" has helped perpetuate the cycle of failure.

The employees are complicit with management's failures. They are the ones making the game, they are the ones who put out such poor effort, and often they are the ones pushing to attack their own audience and make their game worse to please political objectives. Management may demand characters meet racial diversity quotas or espouse certain social leanings; they may demand games be of a certain gameplay type or contain mincrotransactions, but they're not mandating that characters must be written horribly, that the gameplay needs to be horrifically boring, that the worlds must be copy paste slop, or that the e shop must be the only thing that works right at launch (oh hi halo infinite). We've seen enough evidence over the years of devs that not only treat their audiences with absolute contempt but also hate the IP they are working on. We've also seen examples of this where, despite management mandating things that are unpopular in the online space, the games are still successful. Overwatch still maintains a healthy playerbase a decade after launch and baulders gate 3 was wildly succesful, and both contain aspects that people hammer Microsoft studios for injecting into their products.

Management gets golden parachutes, after their employees got paid ridiculous sums to attend adult daycare and cry on Bluesky all day. These games should not take anywhere near this long to make, and both management and the workers are guilty of sitting on their bougie arses enjoying lifestyles most could only dream of while producing nothing of value. .
Posted on Reply
#11
Dr. Dro
Dr_b_So much for the "you will own nothing, and be happy" business model. That was a dream for business to persistently extract rents from people
Y'know, it'd help the cause if people screaming "rent" and "WEF" over digital media were a little more honest. Even organizations that fight for game preservation acknowledge that the move to digital isn't a major roadblock, if anything, it democratizes access to media as it makes it much easier to redistribute software. Oldest key activation on my Steam account, this thing came with a Radeon HD 5970 I used to have eons ago, in fact, the key lingered for over half a year before I was even bothered activating it. Was never into racing games other than one called Diddy Kong Racing for the N64, or perhaps the original SFC Mario Kart



It's still here on my account. I could download it at any time, 16 years later. So much for a "rent".

Posted on Reply
#12
TheinsanegamerN
Dr. DroY'know, it'd help the cause if people screaming "rent" and "WEF" over digital media were a little more honest. Even organizations that fight for game preservation acknowledge that the move to digital isn't a major roadblock, if anything, it democratizes access to media as it makes it much easier to redistribute software. Oldest key activation on my Steam account, this thing came with a Radeon HD 5970 I used to have eons ago, in fact, the key lingered for over half a year before I was even bothered activating it. Was never into racing games other than one called Diddy Kong Racing for the N64, or perhaps the original SFC Mario Kart



It's still here on my account. I could download it at any time, 16 years later. So much for a "rent".

Now take down Steam and see how much of that software you "own".

Digital "ownership" is not ownership. Valve is far better then Sony is, but any digital distribution platform is vulnerable to the company in charge deciding to dick over its users. If you need a digital platform to install your game, you have merely rented it.

I already went through this multiple times, not just on consoles with Nintendo's shutdowns, but with Impulse on PC. The hundreds of dollars I spent on software there, like Supreme Commander and Sins of a Solar Empire? All gone. Proofed out of existence one day. Meanwhile, the physical DVD copy of Supreme Commander and Sins of a Solar Empire? Those still work, and I can still install from them.

Those of us that scream "Rent" and "WEF" are being perfectly honest. The convenience offered by digital distribution is a Brave New World style trap, one that consumers as a whole have fully fallen for, sacrificing their right to ownership in the name of convenience and pleasure. Yes, it is far easier to distribute software, it is also far easier to remove access to that software, and control what you may have access to in ways not possible before. You have not democratized it, you have placed it under the rule of a king, praying to the gods that the king continues to be benevolent and not turn into a tyrannical dictator.

We know from history how that usually ends up.
Posted on Reply
#13
Dr. Dro
TheinsanegamerNNow take down Steam and see how much of that software you "own".

Digital "ownership" is not ownership. Valve is far better then Sony is, but any digital distribution platform is vulnerable to the company in charge deciding to dick over its users. If you need a digital platform to install your game, you have merely rented it.

I already went through this multiple times, not just on consoles with Nintendo's shutdowns, but with Impulse on PC. The hundreds of dollars I spent on software there, like Supreme Commander and Sins of a Solar Empire? All gone. Proofed out of existence one day. Meanwhile, the physical DVD copy of Supreme Commander and Sins of a Solar Empire? Those still work, and I can still install from them.

Those of us that scream "Rent" and "WEF" are being perfectly honest. The convenience offered by digital distribution is a Brave New World style trap, one that consumers as a whole have fully fallen for, sacrificing their right to ownership in the name of convenience and pleasure. Yes, it is far easier to distribute software, it is also far easier to remove access to that software, and control what you may have access to in ways not possible before. You have not democratized it, you have placed it under the rule of a king, praying to the gods that the king continues to be benevolent and not turn into a tyrannical dictator.

We know from history how that usually ends up.
I don't think Steam is going anywhere, really. I've had my Steam account since I was 16, I am now 33 and it's still here, barring some major calamity like WWIII sparking, I expect it will still be here by the time I am 50. Odd that you mention SupCom, was one of the earlier games I got on my account too. That Left 4 Dead bundle, btw? I was just playing L4D2 last week



The whole ownership debacle is a can of worms all its own. Having a disc, technically, doesn't necessarily mean you "own" anything, in fact, you might not even be authorized to use that disc depending on your licensing terms. Good luck enforcing that, though.
Posted on Reply
#14
TheinsanegamerN
Dr. DroI don't think Steam is going anywhere, really. I've had my Steam account since I was 16, I am now 33 and it's still here, barring some major calamity like WWIII sparking, I expect it will still be here by the time I am 50. Odd that you mention SupCom, was one of the earlier games I got on my account too. That Left 4 Dead bundle, btw? I was just playing L4D2 last week

Dotn get complacent, just because Steam has been good so far.

What happens when gabe retires? The man isnt going to live forever, nor want to work forever. They're a private company, for now, but what happens when he leaves and they decide to go public to raise funds for some BS? Hell, even if they stay private, one wrong C suite in charge and all that beautiful software you own could get locked behind licensing agreements or paywalls.

the fact you maintain access to software that has been delisted is a Steam thing mainly, and a GoG thing. On other platforms, once it is delisted, you lose access to it. Guess what will change once Gabe is gone? It only took 2 years for Gamestop to destroy Impulse.

This is what I meant by "King". Gabe is holding this up, corporations rarely maintain the same direction once their founders are gone.
Dr. DroThe whole ownership debacle is a can of worms all its own. Having a disc, technically, doesn't necessarily mean you "own" anything, in fact, you might not even be authorized to use that disc depending on your licensing terms. Good luck enforcing that, though.
If there is no way to determine authorization and prevent installation, you own it, regardless of what a license may say. Once you, as a consumer, buy the product, you may use it as you see fit.
Posted on Reply
#15
Hecate91
Game pass never was a good idea, not when it's partially the reason why Xbox is in the mess they're in.

But when Gabe decides to hand over Valve to someone else, we can only hope it doesn't go to some greedy mega corporation like Microslop, EA, or Ubislop, or some private equity group that sucks everything good out of the platform until they ruin it.
Steam isn't exactly ownership, it only happens to be the least anti-consumer way of a digital storefront. Not being able to physically own your games is why people got so upset over consoles killing off discs.
Posted on Reply
#16
Bigshrimp
TheinsanegamerNThis concept of the "poor worker" has helped perpetuate the cycle of failure.

The employees are complicit with management's failures. They are the ones making the game, they are the ones who put out such poor effort, and often they are the ones pushing to attack their own audience and make their game worse to please political objectives. Management may demand characters meet racial diversity quotas or espouse certain social leanings; they may demand games be of a certain gameplay type or contain mincrotransactions, but they're not mandating that characters must be written horribly, that the gameplay needs to be horrifically boring, that the worlds must be copy paste slop, or that the e shop must be the only thing that works right at launch (oh hi halo infinite). We've seen enough evidence over the years of devs that not only treat their audiences with absolute contempt but also hate the IP they are working on. We've also seen examples of this where, despite management mandating things that are unpopular in the online space, the games are still successful. Overwatch still maintains a healthy playerbase a decade after launch and baulders gate 3 was wildly succesful, and both contain aspects that people hammer Microsoft studios for injecting into their products.

Management gets golden parachutes, after their employees got paid ridiculous sums to attend adult daycare and cry on Bluesky all day. These games should not take anywhere near this long to make, and both management and the workers are guilty of sitting on their bougie arses enjoying lifestyles most could only dream of while producing nothing of value. .
The failure of this "cycle" is due to unbending greed as the line must go up no matter the cost. The failure is big money squeezing everything to its last drop. At least there are indie developers pulling up some of the slack from the slop being produced with tons of money, but for little value.
Posted on Reply
#17
mrnagant
I find it funny Sony has and have had the exact same model, but literally no one ever talks about it, like ever. They have more subs than Game Pass (understandable with more sold PlayStations) but they have almost as many subing to their higher tiers than Xbox has total Game Pass subs. Sometimes it pays to just sit in the background and be utterly silent about your existence. LOL.
Posted on Reply
#18
TheinsanegamerN
BigshrimpThe failure of this "cycle" is due to unbending greed as the line must go up no matter the cost. The failure is big money squeezing everything to its last drop. At least there are indie developers pulling up some of the slack from the slop being produced with tons of money, but for little value.
This argument holds no water with Microsoft. Microsoft studios have been allowed to work with guaranteed budgets for, in most cases, over a decade while producing garbage nobody wants. We've already covered these studios and their constant failures. That is the exact opposite of "muh capitalism" and "line must go up". Line went DOWN, profits were LOST, yet these developers kept their jobs. "Big Money" perpetuated these failures by shielding these developers from losing their jobs for years.

This is far closer to Soviet Communism where funds were continuously burned in excess to maintain a bloated bureaucratic jobs program while production continued to decline in both quality and quantity, eventually leading to collapse of the host when the funds finally ran dry.

Under your notion of "greed", Bethesda, Id, and Activision should have been butchered 5 years ago. Double fine should have been shut down in 2015. 343 should have been shuttered after the failure of Infinite. And so on. Compulsion Games should have been old yellered after the failure of WHF, and South of Midnight never would have been made, even by another studio, because there is no market for it.
Posted on Reply
#19
Dr. Dro
TheinsanegamerNDotn get complacent, just because Steam has been good so far.

What happens when gabe retires? The man isnt going to live forever, nor want to work forever. They're a private company, for now, but what happens when he leaves and they decide to go public to raise funds for some BS? Hell, even if they stay private, one wrong C suite in charge and all that beautiful software you own could get locked behind licensing agreements or paywalls.

the fact you maintain access to software that has been delisted is a Steam thing mainly, and a GoG thing. On other platforms, once it is delisted, you lose access to it. Guess what will change once Gabe is gone? It only took 2 years for Gamestop to destroy Impulse.

This is what I meant by "King". Gabe is holding this up, corporations rarely maintain the same direction once their founders are gone.

If there is no way to determine authorization and prevent installation, you own it, regardless of what a license may say. Once you, as a consumer, buy the product, you may use it as you see fit.
It may be a little different with Valve since it is a privately owned business and generally I don't think Gabe actually works beyond "hey boss we need funding for x or y project" anymore, Valve's a pretty large company overall and he is old and rich enough to pursue his dreams, which he does ;)

yachtway.com/news/gabe-newells-ocean-research-ship-inside-the-300-million-research-vessel-that-will-reach-the-oceans-darkest-depths/

Besides, Valve prints money with their game economy (CS skins alone move so much money it's crazy), so it's very low risk overall, IMHO

At the end of the day while you arguments generally hold true, it's more conceptual than anything at this point in time.
Posted on Reply
#20
Dr_b_
Dr. DroY'know, it'd help the cause if people screaming "rent" and "WEF" over digital media were a little more honest. Even organizations that fight for game preservation acknowledge that the move to digital isn't a major roadblock, if anything, it democratizes access to media as it makes it much easier to redistribute software. Oldest key activation on my Steam account, this thing came with a Radeon HD 5970 I used to have eons ago, in fact, the key lingered for over half a year before I was even bothered activating it. Was never into racing games other than one called Diddy Kong Racing for the N64, or perhaps the original SFC Mario Kart



It's still here on my account. I could download it at any time, 16 years later. So much for a "rent".
You’re confusing digital convenience with actual ownership—and missing my point about rent-seeking entirely, pointing out a 16-year-old Steam key still works is irrelevant. That’s a one-time digital purchase, not the endless subscription model (like Game Pass or SaaS) I was talking about, where you pay forever just to keep temporary access to a rotating library.
access isn't ownership. You hold a revocable license on steam. You can’t resell that game, lend it to a friend, or keep it if Valve ever loses distribution rights or locks your account, or as other's point out, goes under or bought out. Physical media is an asset you actually contrrol

Nobody’s denying digital downloads are convenient tho waving off legitimate criticism of publishers trying to phase out buying games entirely—in favor of permanent monthly fees—just hands all your leverage as a consumer over to corporate balance sheets.
Posted on Reply
#21
Dr. Dro
Dr_b_You’re confusing digital convenience with actual ownership—and missing my point about rent-seeking entirely, pointing out a 16-year-old Steam key still works is irrelevant. That’s a one-time digital purchase, not the endless subscription model (like Game Pass or SaaS) I was talking about, where you pay forever just to keep temporary access to a rotating library.
access isn't ownership. You hold a revocable license on steam. You can’t resell that game, lend it to a friend, or keep it if Valve ever loses distribution rights or locks your account, or as other's point out, goes under or bought out. Physical media is an asset you actually contrrol

Nobody’s denying digital downloads are convenient tho waving off legitimate criticism of publishers trying to phase out buying games entirely—in favor of permanent monthly fees—just hands all your leverage as a consumer over to corporate balance sheets.
You also hold a revocable license of a physical game disc. You are expressly forbidden from reproducing and redistributing it illegally without written consent from the rightsholder. See, being a stick in the mud cuts both ways. It's not mere convenience anymore.
Posted on Reply
#22
shuffy_losys
Dr_b_You’re confusing digital convenience with actual ownership
If you define actual ownership as "I can sell the thing without legal repercussions", then sure, physical media in that regard is superior at least as long as the license to play the game is by way of proving you own the disc.

Except in some cases, that's not true. I have a handful of physical copies of games in my possession where I can sell it, but it sure as hell would flag me on eBay as a scammer because playing the game requires online activation. Many of those require Steam, so another person can no longer use the physical copy because they've been registered to my account. At least one uses an online activation service that I'm sure the publisher shut down years ago.

And in some cases, these physical copies don't contain the entire game. They contain a partial copy and I have to download the rest.

Otherwise, I don't really have any actual ownership of the game. Copyright law gets in the way of that. I can't make copies and sell it. Technically I'm not allowed to modify the data (it might be considered a derivative work). And DMCA gets in the way of being allowed to strip its DRM. So if I want to be clean and legal, I pretty much have a bunch of coasters.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 18th, 2026 19:34 PST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts